Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[manicpie]

I'll take option 3 - I don't need to prove anything to you or anyone else on this forum, and couldn't care less what you think of me.

we all love you fadge, that's the only thing that matters

 

[Worm4]

I'll take option 3 - I don't need to prove anything to you or anyone else on this forum, and couldn't care less what you think of me.

Then why state on a forum of your wagering habits ?

 

[Worm4]

You actually need evidence?

Any "astute" punter wouldn't have made the bet . It is just a dumb bet. But a sure as the earth is round, if by the odd chance that Carlton miss the top 8, he will be the first to say that the bet was on many many months ago, check out my post on may 5th or whatever date it was. Blah blah blah. Full of shit.

 

[Fadge]

Any "astute" punter wouldn't have made the bet . It is just a dumb bet. But a sure as the earth is round, if by the odd chance that Carlton miss the top 8, he will be the first to say that the bet was on many many months ago, check out my post on may 5th or whatever date it was. Blah blah blah. Full of shit.

Why not?

Carlton's mediocrity over the course of my adult life has been extremely fruitful for me, so it's an easy call when you're playing with 'their money'.

The fact my mentioning of it seems to have such an effect on you has come as an added bonus.

 

[Arr0w]

Any "astute" punter wouldn't have made the bet . It is just a dumb bet. But a sure as the earth is round, if by the odd chance that Carlton miss the top 8, he will be the first to say that the bet was on many many months ago, check out my post on may 5th or whatever date it was. Blah blah blah. Full of shit.

Stated that odds were too good to pass up in 2023 that we would miss the 8, and or he went "double or nothing on previous winnings"

So, I don't need to see a betting slip, to know a mug gambler

 

[Fadge]

Stated that odds were too good to pass up in 2023 that we would miss the 8, and or he went "double or nothing on previous winnings"

So, I don't need to see a betting slip, to know a mug gambler

Oh, imagining again?

 

[Arr0w]

Oh, imagining again?

No actually, it's posted by you for all to see

 

[Fadge]

No actually, it's posted by you for all to see

Wouldn't be the first time I've caught you misrepresenting a comment of mine, and won't be the last.

A trait of stalkers is they have good imaginations.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Don't tell me Fudgey is trying to claim he's some sort of hotshot punter again? $5 bets isn't winning big Fudgey, especially when ur bets are Carlton finishing 16th in 2024

 

[CCurnow3picks]

Oh looky here, an honest discussion point for the day.
Let me say, I tend to disagree

I concur !

 

[Arr0w]

Wouldn't be the first time I've caught you misrepresenting a comment of mine, and won't be the last.

A trait of stalkers is they have good imaginations.

All there to see, mug gambler

 

[Aphrodite]

we all love you fadge that's the only thing that matters

You don’t speak for me or on my behalf.

Speak for yourself!

 

[Fadge]

These Carlton posters continue to tie themselves in knots, trying to work out what is their ideal version of reality.

In the same way that Nick Daicos falls somewhere between a soft squib who can't handle a tag and was fortunate to be drafted to a strong team, and a player whom Collingwood stole under the father/son rule and would be all at sea without... I am somewhere between a bloke who places $1 bets but talks himself up on an internet forum, and a problem gambler who can't put food on the table for his family.

Boy oh boy wowee!

 

[Aphrodite]

^^^^^^^

WOW

 

[CCurnow3picks]

we all love you fadge, that's the only thing that matters

Love … is a strong word.

OK let’s explore.

There are many kinds of love;

The love for your wife - ewwww nope.

The love for your family - errrr nope.

The love for a pie at the footy - not quite.

The love for a loyal dog - nope nope nope.

The love for the annoying noise that brings out in you the best/dodgiest kind of banter - .

 

[Worm4]

Why not?

Carlton's mediocrity over the course of my adult life has been extremely fruitful for me, so it's an easy call when you're playing with 'their money'.

The fact my mentioning of it seems to have such an effect on you has come as an added bonus.

I don't mind a bet, hence it raised my eyebrows. Simple as that.
You had a chance of some credibility by proving the bet, I knew you didn't put it on because maybe you are smarter than that

 

[CCurnow3picks]

These Carlton posters continue to tie themselves in knots, trying to work out what is their ideal version of reality.

In the same way that Nick Daicos falls somewhere between a soft squib who can't handle a tag and was fortunate to be drafted to a strong team, and a player whom Collingwood stole under the father/son rule and would be all at sea without... I am somewhere between a bloke who places $1 bets but talks himself up on an internet forum, and a problem gambler who can't put food on the table for his family.

Boy oh boy wowee!

Nailed it.

 

[Arr0w]

"Candy"

 

[Fadge]

I don't mind a bet, hence it raised my eyebrows. Simple as that.
You had a chance of some credibility by proving the bet, I knew you didn't put it on because maybe you are smarter than that

Again, why do I need to garner credibility with you?

 

[manicpie]

You don’t speak for me or on my behalf.

Speak for yourself!

I was talking about us collingwood supporters. I would just naturally assume that you guys wouldn't love him

 

[Worm4]

Don't bunch me in with others. I won't bunch you in with other Carlton fans.

The Blues look great this year and have an excellent nucleus for success over the next 2-3 years.

Believing to this point that you are in any way "in front" of Collingwood over the past 25 years is fantasy land. Collingwood have been in the top 5 performed teams and Carlton would be bottom 3, if not bottom.

Be humble, or be a worm. Either way, we knocked you out of the finals in 2022. Everyone knows it.

Carlton are good , but have been shit for 25 years lol there's a narrative if ever I've seen it .
Point out where I have ever said that Carlton have been in front of collingwood over the past 25 years. Actually, who, if anyone, has said that ?
Never change pie supporters.
Again, this is 2024 thread. Right now as I sit here typing away, Carlton are better.
Now , stick to the title of the thread, please.

 

[RPCB]

Um that would be 28 YEARS

For me, Collingwood aren’t on 16 flags. I feel like beating St Kilda in a GF doesn’t count, that’s something anyone should be able to do. And Collingwood needed two Grand Finals to do it in 2010.

Collingwood would have “officially” been on 16 flags if they won the 1966 Grand Final. But you know…

 

[PieBeast]

St Kilda will always have the mantle of the biggest failure in modern era no matter what but then it's touch and go between Freo and Carlton. Very esteemed company indeed.

To answer OP's question who knows, as there's still half a season to play out.

But given the recent history any rational person would be leaning to Carlton shitting the bed once again.

 

[JustaBattler]

St Kilda will always have the mantle of the biggest failure in modern era no matter what but then it's touch and go between Freo and Carlton. Very esteemed company indeed.

To answer OP's question who knows, as there's still half a season to play out.

But given the recent history any rational person would be leaning to Carlton shitting the bed once again.

Given recent history the only shitting the bed going on is in Collingwood supporters' minds about the dreaded prospect of playing Carlton in a GF - and we all know how that will end.

Still- you've got the prospect of Geelong beating Carlton this Friday night to look forward to with a hope and a prayer - and if not - well that is only two games and percentage you can make up knowing you've got teh AFL and the umps in your corner every match - #theaxesofevil

 

[Worm4]

St Kilda will always have the mantle of the biggest failure in modern era no matter what but then it's touch and go between Freo and Carlton. Very esteemed company indeed.

To answer OP's question who knows, as there's still half a season to play out.

But given the recent history any rational person would be leaning to Carlton shitting the bed once again.

Gold Coast- 14th year in comp. Given extraordinary draft assistance . Yet to play finals. Are they your second team or something. Never changed pie supporters