worthy
Cancelled
Find me any other ranking that has him that high. In fact, find me any ranking that had him in the ND based on his games at the championships or games in the NEAFL before he ran fast at draft camp. With about as much respect as is due, you don't know s**t from clay when it comes to academy players. You probably couldn't even name them off the top of your head but you read one over enthusiastic response from one observer based on athletic results and you're taking it as gospel because it suits your argument.
What a load of shite, as usual.
Sheahan rated him top 40, and when it comes to young talent, you in fact don't know "s**t from clay" in comparison to Sheahan.
Sheahans view is supported by the Fremantle football club who offered pick 32 for Hiscox.
Now, if you're obtuse enough to think that Freo only offered pick 32 to make Syd use pick 36, then there's no helping you.
You do realise that if Freo offer pick 32 and Syd don't use their next pick, that Freo are committed and can't back out ????
To summarise:
Sheahan rates Hiscox top 40.
Freo rate him high enough to use pick 32
Sydney rate him high enough to use pick 36
You rate him a Rookie pick
Which one sounds ridiculous to you ?????????
Who doesn't know "s**t from clay" ? Sheahan, Freo, Syd or Kummerspeck ???