Preview Round 3: Changes/prematch discussion vs Hawthorn

[The acurate one]

Jesus we miss Anderson. Jacobs & Majak.

Yep while I agree 100%. if you scratch the surface; one hasn't played since July 8 2018 and the other two had their breakout years in 2018. So that leaves me with just one question....


What the **** have we been doing with our list for the last 9 ****ing years?

 

[Nick5025]

I would rather have all the young players have a go and start a proper rebuild not this Brad Scott saving his job rebuild.

 

[TheKanga]

Out： Mcdonald & Simpkin
In： Murphy & Ahern

 

[The Nostradamus]

Out: Macmillan, Thomas, jy
In: Murphy, Ahern, Dumont

Zurhaar and Curtis could also come in

 

[Kimbo]

Jesus we miss Anderson. Jacobs & Majak.

And how.

 

[Liam Boy]

Out: Macmillan, Thomas, jy
In: Murphy, Ahern, Dumont

Zurhaar and Curtis could also come in

 

[Phillyroo]

Just read 3 pages of proposed omissions, and struggle to see how no one puts Goldy in the discussion. Was abysmal today, got monstered, bullied and showed zero fight.
Would be the first one out with Luke and I guess Jy going with him.

 

[The acurate one]

Just read 3 pages of proposed omissions, and struggle to see how no one puts Goldy in the discussion. Was abysmal today, got monstered, bullied and showed zero fight.
Would be the first one out with Luke and I guess Jy going with him.

I just posted in the TG thread.......... head over there.

 

[Kanga Glory]

ON a positive it looks like Shiel and Burgoyne have done hammys

 

[Clarke is King]

Not seeing anywhere near enough out Atley in here

 

[Waussie]

We we're soft out there, struggled to hold tackles, didn't put the body in and our disposal was below poor. Our vision up field was not good.
Granted brissy beat WCE last week, but GC looked to be pushing the Dockers, at this rate if some things don't change we are going to win the kitchen tool this year.

 

[Waussie]

Who replaces him?

 

[the flying ham]

Just read 3 pages of proposed omissions, and struggle to see how no one puts Goldy in the discussion. Was abysmal today, got monstered, bullied and showed zero fight.
Would be the first one out with Luke and I guess Jy going with him.

Please.

On SM-G950F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[rickety]

The problem with that tho

Just read 3 pages of proposed omissions, and struggle to see how no one puts Goldy in the discussion. Was abysmal today, got monstered, bullied and showed zero fight.
Would be the first one out with Luke and I guess Jy going with him.

The problem with that though is that there is then nobody to help Campbell ruck. Brown shouldn't go anywhere near the square, and Larkey, well, may as well use Zurhaar in there. They will need to see how Marley pulls up, and Turner as he was hobbled early. The VFL is pretty much threadbare, Murphy would be right to come in, and maybe after yesterday Wilkinson and Taylor. And Ahern. Dumont hopefully has not succumbed to the black hole that snared so many of our players. But yeah, Lmac and Simpkin can be omitted for mine

 

[The Ardent Army]

Just read 3 pages of proposed omissions, and struggle to see how no one puts Goldy in the discussion. Was abysmal today, got monstered, bullied and showed zero fight.
Would be the first one out with Luke and I guess Jy going with him.

Not his best. Martin et al controlled the ruck, and the air. Colours lowered today.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Out: LDU, Thomas
In: Wood, Hrovat

 

[darko]

In: Ahern, Dumont, Taylor
Out: LMac, Simpkin, Turner

J-Mac on thin ice.

 

[The Ardent Army]

Out： Mcdonald & Simpkin
In： Murphy & Ahern

Agree.

Both ineffective (for weeks in a row) and disposal poor - to the point of liability via turnover and instant rebound.

Tommy M apparently playing well and a beautiful kick / handy size.
Ahern one of the most gifted mid / fwds on the list. Hopefully has done enough to work on his defensive side.

 

[G0ther00s]

Zurhaar has to play.
You can’t keep playing Simpkin, Turner and Atley as our small forwards and getting nothing out of them.

Give the kid an extended go at it.

Are you challenging Brad Scott?

 

[The Ardent Army]

Out: LDU, Thomas
In: Wood, Hrovat

Can’t like.
Funny though.

 

[Mjs94]

Out: Simpkin, Tyson
In: Dumont, Ahern

 

[jclei]

Out: Simpkin, Atley, McDonald
In: Ahern, Dumont, Murphy

 

[Long Live the King]

I would rather have all the young players have a go and start a proper rebuild not this Brad Scott saving his job rebuild.

Interesting comment......Norths rebuild started by moving on some key veterans..a variety of reasons for that...salary, showing intent etc....Im wondering if we should have potentially kept those guys and punted guys like Macdonald and Macmillan, Atley etc guys who have been in the system and not taken that next step and are not leaders...

 

[Mordecai]

How far off is anderson

 

[nicko74]

The sooner we hopefully get Jed and Jacobs back the better. Then hacks like McDonald can **** off back to the VFL. And Tyson