Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

[Strapping Young Lad]

North will get Reid and likely Duursma or Watson.

How?

Eagles will make them pay up 2&3.

If they don’t, they’re incompetent.

 

[user33]

With less than what we’ve offered.

At the moment, yes

 

[The Jet From Poowong]

North now have 2,3,15,18,21,25

Clarko's begging ensured they be treated as a start up club. How embarrassing.
Nowhere to run now, no one left to blame.

 

[Blahsta]

Don’t GCS need a open spot on the list for every pick they take to the draft?

They'd wanna get Chol off their list then!

 

[RobHawk]

North now have 2,3,15,18,21,25

And 17 clubs that are totally disgusted with them

 

[theiaofseed]

Hawthorn still have the best hand if North wont do 2+3, Pick 4+ Future first is the best deal.

Despite what the w***ers on trade radio think.

 

[hardway]

They can easily de-list players before draft night and then re-rookie them afterwards

If they are any good other clubs also are capable of picking these players up prior to the GC!

 

[Mercy Seat]

How?

Eagles will make them pay up 2&3.

If they don’t, they’re incompetent.

With the picks North currently have, surely they'll be able to get something done using 15,18,21,25. North know that they WC will only deal with them so they'll have to wilt at some point.

 

[Gohawks16]

Barrett and Jenkins making out it was genius for the Roos to trade out their two compo picks for next year.
They were always going to without any clauses attached to them. You would've been disgusted as a Roos supporter if they hadn't done this.

A top four side making all the right moves in getting in extra picks. Will have a better draft hand than a side that finished 16th.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

With the picks North currently have, surely they'll be able to get something done using 15,18,21,25. North know that they WC will only deal with them so they'll have to wilt at some point.

North hold 2&3. Eagles aren’t going to take a bunch of picks at the back end of the first round.

 

[Billyc]

North hold 2&3. Eagles aren’t going to take a bunch of picks at the back end of the first round.

It will probably compromise with pick 2 and a bunch of other good picks. That's very good for a rebuilding club like the Eagles. Can see North throwing away all of their gifts for one player. And then asking the AFL for more picks in a year or two.

 

[Hawk the Talk]

Our only chance of getting Duursma is if North trade picks 2 and 3 to the Eagles.

I hate the idea of Reid getting to North but it might be the best result we can hope for at this stage unfortunately

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Can see North throwing away all of their gifts for one player. And then asking the AFL for more picks in a year or two.

It’s their way.

 

[theiaofseed]

With the picks North currently have, surely they'll be able to get something done using 15,18,21,25. North know that they WC will only deal with them so they'll have to wilt at some point.

Question what would you rather

4 + Hawthorns Future First or
3 + 15+18+21+25

Theyre not giving up Reid for some random picks

 

[Arrogant Frog]

North's big advantage over us (other than the 50 first round draft picks) is that they can threaten to take Curtain with pick 2 or 3 if Eagles don't deal with them. I think a deal like 2, 15 & 18 will probably get it done for pick 1.

It might become a game of bluff.

 

[The Messenger]

What will the AFL do if North make the finals next year. I know it won't happen but giving a club extra picks in a season they haven't even played yet is absurd. They have good young talent and if they make a bit of a leap next year the AFL will look like fools.

 

[theiaofseed]

It will probably compromise with pick 2 and a bunch of other good picks. That's very good for a rebuilding club like the Eagles. Can see North throwing away all of their gifts for one player. And then asking the AFL for more picks in a year or two.

Well this is the side that traded Pick 1 x 2 for 2+3+15*

 

[daniel23]

North now have 2,3,15,18,21,25

Outside of 2+3 in a terribly weak/even draft it really isn't that impressive

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

North's big advantage over us (other than the 50 first round draft picks) is that they can threaten to take Curtain with pick 2 or 3 if Eagles don't deal with them. I think a deal like 2, 15 & 18 will probably get it done for pick 1.

It might become a game of bluff.

Eagles aren’t dumb enough to fall for that. North won’t take a WA kid when they just lost JHF.

 

[butlers hawks]

What will the AFL do if North make the finals next year. I know it won't happen but giving a club extra picks in a season they haven't even played yet is absurd. They have good young talent and if they make a bit of a leap next year the AFL will look like fools.

turn their head and whistle

 

[Mercy Seat]

Question what would you rather

4 + Hawthorns Future First or
3 + 15+18+21+25

Theyre not giving up Reid for some random picks

I think they'll get 2 + some later picks.

They want Curtin, and 2 is the only way of guaranteeing that. Think it will be tough for us now, and the club know that hence McCartney's comments earlier.

 

[Colloquy]

North now have 2,3,15,18,21,25

Sounds like our 2004,2005 picks

 

[Judd2Sewell]

My guess is the Concessionroos will offer 2 or 3, plus 15 and 18.

 

[KermitJagger]

I think they'll get 2 + some later picks.

They want Curtin, and 2 is the only way of guaranteeing that. Think it will be tough for us now, and the club know that hence McCartney's comments earlier.

Surely North wouldn't risk Curtin.

Doubt it matters to West Coast whether they get him now or a few years down the track, and West Coast have a talent for retaining Victorians so you figure they'd back themselves in to keep Reid if North don't stump up and they do draft him.

 

[theiaofseed]

Eagles aren’t dumb enough to fall for that. North won’t take a WA kid when they just lost JHF.

People forgetting even before losing JHF they wouldn't touch DBG and McDonald for that exact reason