McCartin is making multiple leads. He works a lot harder than people give him credit for. But the Saints have had Riewoldt, Membrey and Bruce which have presented higher up the ground and are more attractive options than McCartin who is often cramped for space and leads more into the pocket. He does work very hard though. Defensive pressure is the big concern and I agree that it's a huge weakness. But I think that he's still worth a top 5 pick.
Most of it is directed at his football and conditioning.
No he wasn't a clear number 1. Petracca was number 1 on most draft boards and people expected him to go number 1 up until a few days before the draft.
Only because St Kilda and Melbourne both were desperate for KPPs.
Incorrect, he was touted as a potential number 1 but not clear number 1.
Your club was so desperate for a key forward you gave up a first round pick for Chris Dawes.
Ah yes because your recruiting department isn't in charge of recruiting at your club. Now it all makes sense.
Yep 5 years ago, terrible call.
I can take pot shots at whoever I like. The accuracy of someones statements isn't determined by the performance of their football club.
I think you're confused. Lovett never went to Carlton.
