Toast 2016 Best and Fairest (& Other Awards) Congratulations - Jack Viney

Who do you think will win the Best and Fairest

  • Jack Viney

    Votes: 12 21.4%
  • Max Gawn

    Votes: 41 73.2%
  • Bernie Vince

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Tom McDonald

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Nathan Jones

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Dom Tyson

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Jessie Hogan

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Jack Watts

    Votes: 3 5.4%
  • Jayden Hunt

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Christen Petracca

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Neville Jetta

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • James Harmes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Oscar McDonald

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    56

Remove this Banner Ad

The 2016 Best and Fairest (Keith 'Bluey' Truscott) has completed. Congratulations to Jack Viney for coming first in the count. A strong season after falling 'just' short last year in the tally.
Stay tuned for other awards possible in this thread

CrrGkP9UkAA5xZ6.jpg


2015 Results
(https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2015-best-and-fairest-vince-by-1-vote-from-viney.1111177/)

This Year (2016)

Awards
Troy Broadbridge Memorial Trophy - Jack Grimes
(Best Melbourne listed player in the VFL)

Ian Ridley Memorial Trophy - Neville Jetta
(Club Ambassador Award)

Harold Ball Memorial Trophy - Jayden Hunt
(Best young Talent)

James Mcdonald Trophy - Max Gawn
(Heart and Spirit)

Ron Barrassi Jnr Memorial Trophy - Jack Viney
(Leadership Award)

Norm smith Memorial Trophy - Max Gawn
(Coaches award)

Best Female Player - Rested for 2016
(Awarded to the best female player)

Best and Fairest
1st - Jack Viney (Keith 'Bluey' Truscott)
2nd - Nathan Jones (Syd Anderson Memorial Trophy)
3rd - Max Gawn (Ron Barrassi Snr Memorial Trophy)
4th - Dom Tyson (Ivor Warne Smith Memorial Trophy)
5th - Jack Watts (Dick Taylor Memorial Trophy)

426 Memorial Trophy Leaderboard
(https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/annual-426-memorial-trophy-leaderboard-2016.1127381/)
2016 - Max Gawn

Other Non Club awards (AA, AFLCA Votes... ect)
All Australian Squad - Max Gawn
 
Last edited:
Great stuff!!

Awards
Troy Broadbridge Memorial Trophy - ANB
(Best Melbourne listed player in the VFL)

Ian Ridley Memorial Trophy - No idea
(Club Ambassador Award)

Harold Ball Memorial Trophy - Christian Petracca
(Best young Talent)

James Mcdonald Trophy - Jack Trengove
(Heart and Spirit)

Ron Barrassi Jnr Memorial Trophy - Jack Viney
(Leadership Award)

Norm smith Memorial Trophy - Neville Jetta/Billy Stretch
(Coaches award)

Best Female Player - Daisy Pearce
(Awarded to the best female player)

Best and Fairest
1st - Max Gawn (Keith 'Bluey' Truscott)
2nd - Nathan Jones (Syd Anderson Memorial Trophy)
3rd - Jack Watts (Ron Barrassi Snr Memorial Trophy)
4th - Jack Viney (Ivor Warne Smith Memorial Trophy)
5th - Dom Tyson (Dick Taylor Memorial Trophy)
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Sorry to butt in here but aren't you lot still a slight chance to make the eight?
Still held on September 6th. We would have to win our remaining games and north loose theirs
 
Troy Broadbridge Memorial Trophy -
(Best Melbourne listed player in the VFL) : Hullet

Ian Ridley Memorial Trophy -
(Club Ambassador Award) :Watts

Harold Ball Memorial Trophy -
(Best young Talent) :Oliver

James Mcdonald Trophy -
(Heart and Spirit) : Trengove

Ron Barrassi Jnr Memorial Trophy -
(Leadership Award) Viney

Norm smith Memorial Trophy -
(Coaches award) Jetta

Best Female Player -
(Awarded to the best female player) I only know Daisey

Best and Fairest
1st - Max Gawn (By the length of the Flemington straight (Keith 'Bluey' Truscott)
2nd - Jack Viney(Syd Anderson Memorial Trophy)
3rd - Jack Watts (Ron Barrassi Snr Memorial Trophy)
4th - NEv Jetta (Ivor Warne Smith Memorial Trophy)
5th - Dom Tyson (Dick Taylor Memorial Trophy)
 
VFL - Michie
Ambassador - Daisy if she's eligible. Otherwise Watts
Young Talent - Petracca
Heart and Spirit - Viney
Leadership - Gawn
Coaches - Watts
Female - Daisy

B&F
Gawn
Viney
Watts
Jones
Vince
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Can someone explain what the difference between the Coaches award and the actual best and fairest is? Isn't the BNF awarded by the coaches?

Coaches award generally refers to someone who might not be best player and accumulate votes but does little things or performs their role that is unrecognised by most but the coach notices.
 
How does voting in the BnF work?

I honestly can't call it. If it rewards consistency, Watts could win it, he'd be in our best 3-5 players each week. For rewarding BOG performances, Viney or Gawn.
 
Can someone explain what the difference between the Coaches award and the actual best and fairest is? Isn't the BNF awarded by the coaches?
Training award i'm pretty sure. Or which one is their favourite
 
Sorry to butt in here but aren't you lot still a slight chance to make the eight?
We're pretty much a certainty to make the eight if the AFL believe the materials I sent them alleging systemic doping programs in 4 teams :)
 
I think Viney will win it.

Missed 6 games last year and only lost by 1 point to Bernie (who had an awesome year). Plus, Viney has improved even further this season.
 
This could be fun

Awards
Troy Broadbridge Memorial Trophy - I reckon I go with Terlich because I met him and he seemed nice and had dimples (and literally no confidence that he would be seen in AFL in 2016 - with good reason it transpires)
(Best Melbourne listed player in the VFL)

Ian Ridley Memorial Trophy - Got to be Lamumba for getting the thinking chair out there, even if most sane people wished he hadn't. Also he's bound to be the next UN Secretary General or something so we would look stupid to neglect him.
(Club Ambassador Award)

Harold Ball Memorial Trophy - Christian Petracca
(Best young Talent)

James Mcdonald Trophy - Viney or maybe Trenners would be a nice story. So I think it should be Matt Jones just to get everyone puzzled therefor engaged.
(Heart and Spirit)

Ron Barrassi Jnr Memorial Trophy - Should definitely be Viney, so I think obviously it goes to T-Mac once he has signed on.
(Leadership Award)

Norm smith Memorial Trophy - One last Roos gag before Hawaii sees this go to Vince with reference to the recent game against Gold Coast
(Coaches award)

Best Female Player - Daisy Pearce because the alternative means I have to look up names
(Awarded to the best female player)

Best and Fairest (I'm just copying Sando here because I can't be stuffed thinking)
1st - Max Gawn (Keith 'Bluey' Truscott)
2nd - Nathan Jones (Syd Anderson Memorial Trophy)
3rd - Jack Watts (Ron Barrassi Snr Memorial Trophy)
4th - Jack Viney (Ivor Warne Smith Memorial Trophy)
5th - Dom Tyson (Dick Taylor Memorial Trophy)
 
This could be fun

Awards
Troy Broadbridge Memorial Trophy - I reckon I go with Terlich because I met him and he seemed nice and had dimples (and literally no confidence that he would be seen in AFL in 2016 - with good reason it transpires)
(Best Melbourne listed player in the VFL)

Ian Ridley Memorial Trophy - Got to be Lamumba for getting the thinking chair out there, even if most sane people wished he hadn't. Also he's bound to be the next UN Secretary General or something so we would look stupid to neglect him.
(Club Ambassador Award)

Harold Ball Memorial Trophy - Christian Petracca
(Best young Talent)

James Mcdonald Trophy - Viney or maybe Trenners would be a nice story. So I think it should be Matt Jones just to get everyone puzzled therefor engaged.
(Heart and Spirit)

Ron Barrassi Jnr Memorial Trophy - Should definitely be Viney, so I think obviously it goes to T-Mac once he has signed on.
(Leadership Award)

Norm smith Memorial Trophy - One last Roos gag before Hawaii sees this go to Vince with reference to the recent game against Gold Coast
(Coaches award)

Best Female Player - Daisy Pearce because the alternative means I have to look up names
(Awarded to the best female player)

Best and Fairest (I'm just copying Sando here because I can't be stuffed thinking)
1st - Max Gawn (Keith 'Bluey' Truscott)
2nd - Nathan Jones (Syd Anderson Memorial Trophy)
3rd - Jack Watts (Ron Barrassi Snr Memorial Trophy)
4th - Jack Viney (Ivor Warne Smith Memorial Trophy)
5th - Dom Tyson (Dick Taylor Memorial Trophy)
Could do worse than that PG!
 
Awards
Troy Broadbridge Memorial Trophy - ANB
(Best Melbourne listed player in the VFL)

Ian Ridley Memorial Trophy - Lumumba
(Club Ambassador Award)

Harold Ball Memorial Trophy - Christian Petracca
(Best young Talent)

James Mcdonald Trophy - Jack Trengove
(Heart and Spirit)

Ron Barrassi Jnr Memorial Trophy - Jack Viney
(Leadership Award)

Norm smith Memorial Trophy - Jetta
(Coaches award)

Best Female Player - Daisy Pearce
(Awarded to the best female player)

Best and Fairest
1st - Max Gawn (Keith 'Bluey' Truscott)
2nd - Jack Viney (Syd Anderson Memorial Trophy)
3rd - Nathan Jones (Ron Barrassi Snr Memorial Trophy)
4th - Dom Tyson (Ivor Warne Smith Memorial Trophy)
5th - Jack Watts (Dick Taylor Memorial Trophy)
 
Anyone from here going this year?
Have tickets been made available yet? I never go into my email if possible because I'm relentlessly spammed by the bloody Australian Ballet now
 
Back
Top