McCartin has most of the skills and supposedly has trained well, lost weight and hardened up. I agree he would need to start in Ressies but I reckon we'd know in 3 or 4 games if he's up to it. Then it's a question of if he's better than Reid, Sinkers or McLean which is a possibility.I’d get both but McCartin needs a year in the new VFL comp to see how he goes.