He would if he could stay on the park. There's not many HFF ahead of him.Sorry but Martin is not close to AA quality.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
He would if he could stay on the park. There's not many HFF ahead of him.Sorry but Martin is not close to AA quality.
Petrevski-Seton... isn't a player to look sideways when in possession – he likes to get it going goal-bound as soon as possible.
Charlie Curnow. Could be the best player in the comp if he gets fit and lives up to his potential
The thing is, we don’t need him to be. With Harry’s ascension, the pressure is off. It’s exciting to thinkabout he could contribute without having to be first banana.
I have a few ahead of him unfortunately, he is a bit too flimsy for me.He would if he could stay on the park. There's not many HFF ahead of him.
Well if you want to talk about small forwards then that brings the stay at home smalls in.I have a few ahead of him unfortunately, he is a bit too flimsy for me.
Walters, Gray, Petracca, Zorko, Sidebottom, Danger, Bont, Greene, Dusty, Heeney, Flyin Ryan, Edwards, Tippa, Billings, Shai Bolton, Gresham and maybe De Goey when in form.
I also think JSos offers us more but that is just me.
Agree he isn’t durable, never has been.Well if you want to talk about small forwards then that brings the stay at home smalls in.
Really I have him against the HFF/mid hybrids.
And I said if healthy he would be. On talent hes ahead of many on your list...just non durable
I'd assume that Charlie would be our CHF with McKay FF. Mainly because I see them using Charlie up the field more. They could swap them multiple times within a match though as they are both athletically gifted.The conundrum will be who lines up as FF, where Charlie was to be positioned with H @ CHF.
Dan mcstaySorry I bored.Everyone knows we lack talls on every line. Here are some names that I feel that may help fill the holes in our list.
Tom Fullerton, Dan Mcstay, Connor Ballenden, Sam Dekoning, Esava Ratugolea, Charlie Ballard, Caleb Graham, Sam Weideman, Harrison Petty, Toby Nankervis, Cal Coleman Jones, Mabior Chol, Jarrod Brander, Bailey Williams and Harry Edwards. It's a mixed bunch. Any thoughts who we should look at in trade time.
If you had to look at Collingwood's list and Carlton's list, you would definitely go with Carlton. Once Pendlebury retires, they are stuffed. The thing that worries me about Lyon is that he is very similar to Malthouse in his approach, and is very defence orientated which is why he has never won a flag. Not sure Liddell would want Lyon around the club spruiking up SOS. If Carlton does not persevere with Teague then who do they go to?
Voss & Leppitsch as his assistant? Lots of experience at PA & Richmond
Do we go after Buckley if he gets the boot?
Throw 1.2 million per season at Lyon?
Perhaps go after Pike who did get Adelaide to a GF.
Get Ange Postecoglou back from Japan and give him the job.
Walters - diff positionAgree he isn’t durable, never has been.
So of the hybrid types that push into the midfield such as
Walters, Bont, Petracca, Gray, Sidebottom, Dusty, Danger, Heeney, Edwards, Bolton, Zorko & DeGoey who does Jack have covered on talent in your opinion ?
There's a bunch of mids though. Since when do they pick forwards for hff?He would if he could stay on the park. There's not many HFF ahead of him.
We will have to agree to disagree on most of those.....Walters - diff position
Bont Petracca Danger - more midfield and often get spots there
Gray sidebottom zorko - old
So youre really left with Heeney Edwards Bolton and DeGoey - Hes about as good or better than all 4 when fit
The conundrum will be who lines up as FF, where Charlie was to be positioned with H @ CHF.
The thing is, we don’t need him to be. With Harry’s ascension, the pressure is off. It’s exciting to thinkabout he could contribute without having to be first banana.
Sorry I bored.Everyone knows we lack talls on every line. Here are some names that I feel that may help fill the holes in our list.
Tom Fullerton, Dan Mcstay, Connor Ballenden, Sam Dekoning, Esava Ratugolea, Charlie Ballard, Caleb Graham, Sam Weideman, Harrison Petty, Toby Nankervis, Cal Coleman Jones, Mabior Chol, Jarrod Brander, Bailey Williams and Harry Edwards. It's a mixed bunch. Any thoughts who we should look at in trade time.
Left field one, could the Blues look at a player like Josh Schache. Was the second best KPP behind Weitering in 2015 Draft. Hasnt made it as a forward, would he have the potential to switch to defence??
Wouldn't cost alot either with Bulldogs likely to give more oportunity to Ugle-Hagan.
Agree with all of this but just wanted to point out that we have at least 4 AA-quality players on our list currently:
Any of these 4 could be picked for the AA squad in a year where they avoid injury. That's more quality players than we've had since the Fev/Judd days. The rest of list lacks depth, but we have found some quality at least.
- Weitering
- Walsh
- Cripps
- Saad
Sorry but Martin is not close to AA quality.
I feel like we should stay away from the big name recruits moving forward and embrace a culture of building internally which hopefully leads to players taking slight unders to keep the group together. Now we’ve invested in Williams, Saad and our young guns coming through. I’d rather keep our group together than chase a Kelly or Merrett type. Focus on recruiting lesser known gems to plug holes like Fogarty, Newman, Newnes, Matty Wright types.
Martin has the ability to be, but never had the performances to be
Anyone thinking about Schache needs to watch Friday night's game against the tigers closely. Looked completely out of it all night, both forward and ruck, couldn't get near it, and worse, looked like not even the effort was there. Think he got a lucky goal late but otherwise an absolute shocker. There is no way we could be interested. On the back of that performance, he would be lucky to play 5-10 more senior games and will be delisted at end of next year. Been wrong before, but don't think so this time. He looks done.Schache just doesn’t want it enough from the look of things.