Toast 2022 Australian Football Hall Of Fame

Remove this Banner Ad

Collingwood 4 eternity

Norm Smith Medallist
Mar 16, 2009
5,392
11,555
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
First inductee

Matthew Pavlich

 

Log in to remove this ad.

Brent Harvey

 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

It’s a shame that a lot of Victorians did see some of the greats who didn’t play VFL.

Looking at the vintage, it’s not just Victorians, it’s anyone born around colour television etc.

There is a huge bias to players of the same vintage and league as the inaugural selectors. Perhaps the balance is being re set marginally now
 
Why don’t the AFL just catch up, Bill Dempsey should of been inducted 20 years ago. Pavlich does not need to be inducted for another 20 years. As great an honour as it is I think it means more when the players are 55-60 years of age where their grown children can share the night with them. Why are we inducting them so quickly?
Pavlich was just an example by the way, please don’t think I am knocking him.
 
Why don’t the AFL just catch up, Bill Dempsey should of been inducted 20 years ago. Pavlich does not need to be inducted for another 20 years. As great an honour as it is I think it means more when the players are 55-60 years of age where their grown children can share the night with them. Why are we inducting them so quickly?
Pavlich was just an example by the way, please don’t think I am knocking him.

This page was put together a few years ago and even then there were many worthy of induction

 
Why don’t the AFL just catch up, Bill Dempsey should of been inducted 20 years ago. Pavlich does not need to be inducted for another 20 years. As great an honour as it is I think it means more when the players are 55-60 years of age where their grown children can share the night with them. Why are we inducting them so quickly?
Pavlich was just an example by the way, please don’t think I am knocking him.

110% agree, i believe that you have to let the players pre 1990 get in first, no matter what league they played in.

I was shocked about Winmar (like Trevor Barker a couple of years ago) I assumed that he was already in the HOF
 
110% agree, i believe that you have to let the players pre 1990 get in first, no matter what league they played in.

I was shocked about Winmar (like Trevor Barker a couple of years ago) I assumed that he was already in the HOF
Modra isn’t in either it’s insane
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top