Unofficial Preview Changes and pre-match discussion vs Collingwood

[shinboner magic]

you're not bringing in a tall defender to replace Corr?

They have some height with Mihocek, Cox, Cameron when floats forward. Membrey isn't small either.

Corr doesn’t play like a tall - so no loss
More worried about their smalls
Chom on the yank
Pink on miochek
Lmac or ford on membrey

 

[Passmore]

McRae is like most coaches, apart from the Scott brothers and Mitchell, he's comes across as a nice guy when things are running his way. Hit a few bumps and he becomes a whining sook.

 

[Mr north man]

Corr doesn’t play like a tall - so no loss
More worried about their smalls
Chom on the yank
Pink on miochek
Lmac or ford on membrey

Membrey will be too good for both of them you have to play Corr on him.

 

[shintemaster]

One of the 2 other teams I do watch because I like how they play. They play as a team, something I want us to play as.

Maybe we would play better if we only had to travel 4 times a year for 3 decades.

 

[shintemaster]

I hate Collingwood . Players, supporters, the self entitlement. But I also hate Hawthorn Carlton Essendon and Geelong

No. Collingwood are super brave. Do you know they once travelled to Adelaide for an away game?

 

[Makeshift Park]

Are Moore and Schultz still likely outs? Reckon we would've beaten them last year if they weren't playing, particularly Lachie.
Agree with the others that the McCreery, Hill and Elliott match-ups will be key. Bloody shame we don't have Arch available. Hardeman, Lmac, and FOS will have their work cut out.

If its just Howe and Frampton as their tall defenders, then keeping Moose in might have some merit. Getting him to play deep while Larkey and Darling draw their opponents up the field would make for some favourable mismatches.

Problem is if Curtis is ready to go we'd have to change some rotation structure to accommodate for both him and the mailman.

So Scott out for Curtis. Then Kerch and Powell play a little more wing time to compensate. Meaning LDU and the Warlord have more on-ball time than last week.

Do we tag Daicos like last time?

 

[HongKongRoo]

I"d love to see Konstanty play a negating role on Josh Daicos if he starts off half back

I'd love to see Konstanty, Moose and X bury both the Daicos boys nice and early in the game.

 

[zoomba23]

It's pretty insane arrogance for them to just toss around the idea of resting players given the unlikelihood that any Collingwood fan was overjoyed with their performance in any of their last three wins over us. Yes, they have more firepower this time. But I don't know if that means you just discount an opponent that strangely reserves decent quarters/halves for you.

Same arrogance as when they were posting 'LDU. Get him,' as if it was their divine right. Insufferable campaigners. They're lucky Carlton fans exist

 

[Harris 10]

 

[HongKongRoo]

If Curtis is fit he comes in for Duursma. The Maley set-up has been perfect for Zhurhaar and his defensive pressure for a big man is very good. Duursma can go put some pressure on in the VFL and play full games there. He is not a sub. If Duursma stays in he starts.
Ford comes in for Scott and goes to the bench. Scott has plateaued and needs to get some confidence back. He can fight those demons in the ressies. Get better at hitting targets and learn how to tackle effectively. Ford can play front or back and will make something happen when he comes on.
K. Dawson for Corr. Need a genuine big bastard for some of their talls. Can't have Pink giving 20cm to the yank. Realistically Corr will probably stay in.

 

[shintemaster]

If Curtis is fit he comes in for Duursma. The Maley set-up has been perfect for Zhurhaar and his defensive pressure for a big man is very good. Duursma can go put some pressure on in the VFL and play full games there. He is not a sub. If Duursma stays in he starts.
Ford comes in for Scott and goes to the bench. Scott has plateaued and needs to get some confidence back. He can fight those demons in the ressies. Get better at hitting targets and learn how to tackle effectively. Ford can play front or back and will make something happen when he comes on.
K. Dawson for Corr. Need a genuine big bastard for some of their talls. Can't have Pink giving 20cm to the yank. Realistically Corr will probably stay in.

I don't see Dawson coming in, most especially not as a true KPD.

 

[Caracas]

If Curtis is fit he comes in for Duursma. The Maley set-up has been perfect for Zhurhaar and his defensive pressure for a big man is very good. Duursma can go put some pressure on in the VFL and play full games there. He is not a sub. If Duursma stays in he starts.
Ford comes in for Scott and goes to the bench. Scott has plateaued and needs to get some confidence back. He can fight those demons in the ressies. Get better at hitting targets and learn how to tackle effectively. Ford can play front or back and will make something happen when he comes on.
K. Dawson for Corr. Need a genuine big bastard for some of their talls. Can't have Pink giving 20cm to the yank. Realistically Corr will probably stay in.

Brody M is a perfect size for Pink. He’s 2 cm’s shorter than Toby.

 

[kool kangas]

Are Moore and Schultz still likely outs? Reckon we would've beaten them last year if they weren't playing, particularly Lachie.
Agree with the others that the McCreery, Hill and Elliott match-ups will be key. Bloody shame we don't have Arch available. Hardeman, Lmac, and FOS will have their work cut out.

If its just Howe and Frampton as their tall defenders, then keeping Moose in might have some merit. Getting him to play deep while Larkey and Darling draw their opponents up the field would make for some favourable mismatches.

Problem is if Curtis is ready to go we'd have to change some rotation structure to accommodate for both him and the mailman.

So Scott out for Curtis. Then Kerch and Powell play a little more wing time to compensate. Meaning LDU and the Warlord have more on-ball time than last week.

Do we tag Daicos like last time?

Unless Phillips comes in then we wont have anyone in the side to tag Naicos with...

 

[Makeshift Park]

Unless Phillips comes in then we wont have anyone in the side to tag Naicos with...

Maybe Duursma and Scott out, Phillips and Curtis in.

No idea who plays the sub then tho.

Dare I say... Daniel?

 

[kool kangas]

Corr doesn’t play like a tall - so no loss
More worried about their smalls
Chom on the yank
Pink on miochek
Lmac or ford on membrey

Ford is still learning to play defence so l would stick with Lmac on Membrey or maybe Hardeman...

 

[The Nostradamus]

Lmac will get Elliott

Corr will get membrey

 

[Horizons_00]

In: PC and Ford (sub)
Out: Scott and Zane

That’s it. We are doing a disservice for Bailey if we play him. Destroying his confidence. Put him and Durs back in the VFL and let them build some form over there

 

[kool kangas]

If Curtis is fit he comes in for Duursma. The Maley set-up has been perfect for Zhurhaar and his defensive pressure for a big man is very good. Duursma can go put some pressure on in the VFL and play full games there. He is not a sub. If Duursma stays in he starts.
Ford comes in for Scott and goes to the bench. Scott has plateaued and needs to get some confidence back. He can fight those demons in the ressies. Get better at hitting targets and learn how to tackle effectively. Ford can play front or back and will make something happen when he comes on.
K. Dawson for Corr. Need a genuine big bastard for some of their talls. Can't have Pink giving 20cm to the yank. Realistically Corr will probably stay in.

Maybe Whitlock for Corr then he can line up on Cox when forward..

 

[Passmore]

Can't see us getting to funky with the changes.

Curtis in if fit. Scott out

Duursma out, maybe Fisher in.

 

[Event Horizon]

It's pretty insane arrogance for them to just toss around the idea of resting players given the unlikelihood that any Collingwood fan was overjoyed with their performance in any of their last three wins over us. Yes, they have more firepower this time. But I don't know if that means you just discount an opponent that strangely reserves decent quarters/halves for you.

Same arrogance as when they were posting 'LDU. Get him,' as if it was their divine right. Insufferable campaigners. They're lucky Carlton fans exist

Speaking of "divine right" - when they chose to go after Houston, the comment from Leppitch on day 1 was we are confident, despite some other clubs still feeling like they were offering more to Port. Collingwood really do think if they want someone and have made salary cap room it's a done deal. The other clubs don't matter.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Lmac will get Elliott

Corr will get membrey

Membrey to kick 4+.

Three from free kicks.

 

[shinboner magic]

Membrey will be too good for both of them you have to play Corr on him.

Limit the quality of the supply and it won’t matter

 

[HongKongRoo]

Ford is still learning to play defence so l would stick with Lmac on Membrey or maybe Hardeman...

LMac on Hill.
Hardeman on Elliot if he plays.
Pink to Mihochek.
Chom to the Yank.
Corr to Membrey.
McCreary for the Kerridge

 

[Hearts to hearts]

Speaking of "divine right" - when they chose to go after Houston, the comment from Leppitch on day 1 was we are confident, despite some other clubs still feeling like they were offering more to Port. Collingwood really do think if they want someone and have made salary cap room it's a done deal. The other clubs don't matter.

That’s what happens so - annoying as it is - they’re not wrong.

Bit of underrating Membrey in the discussion of defensive options.

 

[Rod Stroker]

Maybe Duursma and Scott out, Phillips and Curtis in.

No idea who plays the sub then tho.

Dare I say... Daniel?

there's no way that Clarko is making Daniel sub