Preview Changes vs Pies

[tazaa]

B: Rawlings Delaney Firrito
HB: Wells Tarrant Thompson
C: Anthony Ziebell Greenwood
HF: Harvey Pederson Edwards
F: Thomas Petrie Adams
R: Goldstein Swallow Bastinac
I: Atley Harper Campbell Speight
E: Cunnington McMahon Garlett

IN: Delaney Tarrant Atley Harper Campbell Speight
OUT: Grima Hansen Pratt McKinley McMahon Cunnington

If Delaney and Tarrant dont get picked i can persist with Narni and Lachy but both are really having poor years. Atley Harper Campbell and Speight will do damage at the feet of Petrie Pederson and Edwards.
Delaney on Cloke and Tarrant on Dawes is the way to go. Dont think Narni and Lachy will be able to do a better job.

 

[Roo-Boy]

Out: Grima Hansen Pratt McKinley McMahon
In: Delaney Harper Speight Atley Tarrant

 

[Tas]

I don't want anyone forward who I would rather take the kick instead of them, they are meant to be professionals.

FF: Edwards Petrie Harper
HF: Campbell Pedersen Harvey
C: Wells Ziebell Bastinac
HB: Grima Hansen Thompson
HF: Rawlings Delaney/Tarrant McMahon
R: Goldstein Swallow Greenwood
I: (from) Adams Anthony Atley Speight Garlett

I dunno how many changes that is going to be, likely a shitload as we have to undo the crap we did this week and then some. We were out-run by the slowest team in the competition.

 

[chrissy]

McKinley offers nothing , after being at the game today i cant understand why all our forwards try to get to all the contests , all they manage to do is drag their man to spoil Drew

 

[Artichoke]

Out: Scott
In: Laidley.

 

[ozzyoslo]

Hansen must go too. He was useless today. As soon as MacIntosh is ready he should come in.

Did you watch the same game today?? Useless NO.

Lachie didnt play VFL last week and came straight back into the team....what does that tell you??

My outs are Pratt.....(might be his last depending on injuries)
Grima..what happened there?? I missed that,injured or out of soughts??
McKinley (his inclusion still has me puzzled when our tall marking options were playing well as a group) He didnt play in his traditional position simple as that. Azza has this spot at present but doesn´t deserve to be dropped.

Ins :- Atley after a spell
Delaney ( fingers crossed he is our best performing defender)
Need another mid, one that wants to get into the action this week. leave that one to you guys hahaha

 

[groo]

I don't want anyone forward who I would rather take the kick instead of them, they are meant to be professionals.

FF: Edwards Petrie Harper
HF: Campbell Pedersen Harvey
C: Wells Ziebell Bastinac
HB: Grima Hansen Thompson
HF: Rawlings Delaney/Tarrant McMahon
R: Goldstein Swallow Greenwood
I: (from) Adams Anthony Atley Speight Garlett

I dunno how many changes that is going to be, likely a shitload as we have to undo the crap we did this week and then some. We were out-run by the slowest team in the competition.

Swap Adams, let Harper go and commit to Delaney and you have the team. Richo the emergency.

 

[Benno_900]

IN: Delaney (missed him today), Atley
OUT: McKinley, Pratt

 

[awesome wells]

OUT: McKinley & Pratt (BOTH NEVER TO BE SEEN AGAIN!!!!)

 

[GarnerSmash]

McKinley is out for a half forward that can rotate through the midfield. One of Pratt, Rawlings and McMahon must go for team balance.

Delaney must come in to take one of Cloke or Dawes and Atley should play.

 

[The Big H]

On further reflection, I'd bring in Speight for McKinly and Tarrant or Delaney for Pratt. We need to really consider who we play, and how we play at half forward this week. Collingwoods half backs create soo much run.

 

[Rod Stroker]

The defence needs a shake up but...mcmahon?

Surely Firrito and Pratt are gone before Mcmahon. Personally I hope by this time next year all 3 have been replaced and are no longer in the best 22.

IN: Speight, Harper, Atley, Mcintosh (??)
OUT: Firrito, Mckinley, Narni, Hansen

Right, and who will all 3 be replaced with next year?
I agree that Pratt should go but I can't see Firrito and McMahon gone next year, largely because we don't have players ready to replace them. I still believe they can add value to the team.

 

[Rod Stroker]

Not necessarily suggesting he should be dropped, but gee Grima is struggling. I know he's had an injury interrupted year but he's been back for a while now and just doesn't seem to have come on like we hoped he would. Hasn't been able to hold down a key defensive post.

 

[Flawed Genius]

Right, and who will all 3 be replaced with next year?

Richardson, MacMillan & Mullett.

 

[Rod Stroker]

Richardson, MacMillan & Mullett.

They have only played a total of 10 games between them. Not sure we're in a position to play them all together, we're already putting young teams on the park as it is.

 

[Flawed Genius]

They have only played a total of 10 games between them. Not sure we're in a position to play them all together, we're already putting young teams on the park as it is.

MacMillan - Grima - Mullett
Richardson - Delaney - Thompson

Inexperienced, but with an eye to the future..

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Out: McKinley, Pratt (definitely) Grima, Cunnington (maybe to get some form in the 2's)
In: Atley, Harper, Speight, Delaney - and after given McKinley a chance Warren must feel a little left out.

 

[The Big H]

As we've seen, getting a few kicks and being in the best in the vfl doesn't automatically mean you are going to tear it up at AFL level.

 

[Flawed Genius]

Warren is injured. Oops.

 

[Roosurgence]

Out: Pratt - game has passed him by. McKinley - was rubbish, but not sure what you could expect with that forward structure. Thomas - his goal kicking is killing us.

In: A defender other than Scott Thompson who is capable of taking the game on and breaking a line. Atley - breakaway pace. Harper - forwardline creativity.

 

[AngryLittleMan]

Right, and who will all 3 be replaced with next year?
I agree that Pratt should go but I can't see Firrito and McMahon gone next year, largely because we don't have players ready to replace them. I still believe they can add value to the team.

Richardson, Macmillan, Speight, Urquarht, Ross are all posibilities of playing that running role out of defence. And then you got possible trades or the draft. Im not saying we should delist them all but you cant have all 3 in the same side along with Brady.

Rawlings - Hansen/Tarrant - Grima
Macmillan - Delaney - Thompson

Why is something like this not possible at the same time next year?

 

[benbanjo]

i would like to see

Out: Grima, Pratt, Mckinley
In: Tarrant/Delany(if fit), Atley, Speight/Campbell(if fit)

 

[Liam Boy]

Out: Grima/In: Tarrant
Out: Pratt/In: MacMillan
Out: McKinley/In: Warren

 

[The Other Dean]

I know these Changes threads are e-ventful in the wake of a loss, but I'd reckon the chances of Lachie being dropped for the Pies game would be pretty much zero and none. Doubt Lindsay will be going anywhere either. Just my opinion.

 

[BlueandWhiteElf]

Out: McKinley (WTF), Pratt (not the future), Grima (needs fitness)
In: Delaney (if fit), Tarrant (if Delaney not fit), Atley, Speight

What about Speight running off the half back flank???? He is a very good use of the ball.