News Gone: Alex Keath wants to be traded to the Bulldogs

[Golumless]

you are assuming we will keep the picks we currently have - plenty of time to pick trade and we have good currency for next year when a heap of clubs will be scrapping for points for NGA and F/S players

The other thing, and I forgot to account for this a moment ago - if our NGA does bust, we do have a lot of potential to trade upwards next year with this.

 

[Cadillac]

Nor was settling for a 3rd rounder

Happy to give up our second for your third

 

[matty p]

Pretty fair trade, yes we'd have wanted to get their first round pick but if this situation is reversed I doubt we'd be wanting to pass it over even with a 2nd coming back. Maybe if he was 2 years younger.

If he was two years younger we’d be keeping him.

 

[BRL121]

Half of you guys are pathetic: you just wanted to rant regardless of the result. It's a marginal result, but
Reid hardly folded. Anyway, look on the bright side: we can now start a WB deathwatch thread.

 

[Scorpus]

If we want value for players they have to be contracted.

We need to trade Atkins now or we'll get ****ed again next year

 

[CutAboveTheRest]

2nd rounder for an out of contract player who's played less than 50 games. Again we had no bargaining power with him being out of contract and nominating one club. Reckon we'll be using some futures to do some pick trading back into this draft.

Really hope so spexau

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Dumb post . Second rounder is not a packet of chips

Next year it is ....maybe study next years draft B4 you comment

 

[Golumless]

The big issue was getting f’ed with Greenwood.

He was worth more than Keath

Yup, he was the one you dig in on.

That was the main failing of this trade period, everything else has been acceptable.

 

[CutAboveTheRest]

Half of you guys are pathetic: you just wanted to rant regardless of the result. It's a marginal result, but
Reid hardly folded. Anyway, look on the bright side: we can now start a WB deathwatch thread.

Hardly folded?

 

[Scorpus]

I reckon some people here have massively overrated a 30 game 28 year old

 

[mattymac]

Well at least we didn't receive bum sex with pick 45.

I sense a lot of people don't realise how valuable picks are next year given how many academy and FS players are in that draft.

Still feels a bit lame though. Its always next year with us.

 

[Crow till I die]

Happy to give up our second for your third

I think the 3rd rounder this year and our 3rd next year will mostly cancel each other out in terms of value - the 2020 2nd rounder will be valuable to us either to on trade or use for points

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Anyway, look on the bright side: we can now start a WB deathwatch thread.

Please no.

 

[Doc_]

So St Kilda get 32 and we get s**t?

 

[mattymac]

The big issue was getting f’ed with Greenwood.

He was worth more than Keath

In no universe is Greenwood worth more than Keath

 

[CutAboveTheRest]

Isn't the rule of thumb that next year's trade worth one round less? Know with Edwards and Borlase a bit different but this period has been a big fail.
At least we'll always have the CEY 49 compensation.

Thankfully the AFL helped us on that one - imagine if we had to deal with trading CEY? It'd be a 5th rounder.

 

[Cadillac]

I think the 3rd rounder this year and our 3rd next year will mostly cancel each other out in terms of value - the 2020 2nd rounder will be valuable to us either to on trade or use for points

Agree. A win for both sides.

 

[Scorpus]

In no universe is Greenwood worth more than Keath

Better player with more exposed form. He was worth more.

 

[Crow_68]

Half of you guys are pathetic: you just wanted to rant regardless of the result. It's a marginal result, but
Reid hardly folded. Anyway, look on the bright side: we can now start a WB deathwatch thread.

Agree, the success/failure of this deal won’t play out until the 2020 season is over


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[VictorianCrow85]

Half of you guys are pathetic: you just wanted to rant regardless of the result. It's a marginal result, but
Reid hardly folded. Anyway, look on the bright side: we can now start a WB deathwatch thread.

There's so many people that seriously over rate our players here. I'm not going to say we've 'won' any trades because we haven't but the net losses overall are fairly minimal for what we are doing. I think people just got it in their heads we'd get a serious haul of high picks off what? A cooked Betts/Sauce? A not wanted Jenkins? Mature age guys with 50 games or so in Greenwood/Keath, one who struggles to run out games and one whose body has proven fairly fragile? Sorry guys these are not players other clubs are giving up high picks for.

 

[Golumless]

So St Kilda get 32 and we get s**t?

Well, odds are we got 32-34 + 45. Just for Keath + probably 43

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I reckon some people here have massively overrated a 30 game 28 year old

Who was #5 in the club Best & Fairest

 

[Mutineer]

Weak as piss, both Greenwood and Keath gone for a packet of chips, with no gaurentees that our F/S and NGA will actually be 1st rounders or any good at all, talk about all our eggs in one basket.

Bullshit, Luke Edwards looks every bit a 1st rounder, likely to transition from half back to the midfield in 2020, already 187cm and 78kg. Borlase already 191cm and 88kg and capable forward and back. Both announced as members of the 30 player AFL SA Academy Hub today.

2020 AFL Academy SA Hub

Set to be guided by SANFL's Talent Department headed by Brenton Phillips and Tony Bamford, the talented teenagers will undertake their first camp in late November-early December, with an indigenous cultural experience the focus of the journey to Port Augusta and Wilpena Pound.

sanfl.com.au

 

[GameofSloanes]

Next year it is ....maybe study next years draft B4 you comment

Maybe look at borlase and edwards possibly being drafted using points next year before you do

 

[Scorpus]

Who was #5 in the club Best & Fairest

Atkins and Mackay made our top 10