lemon chicken
Cancelled
Surely Hinkley would be in the best position to know what he is worth, If he rates him then he should have no problem giving up a pick 10.
Gorringe, Nicholls and Smith; Who's interested and what are they worth?
- Thread starter TheTigerEffect
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Unless Hinkley thinks he's only a pre-season away from becoming the next Dean Cox, Port (namely Peter Rohde, Footy Ops manager) won't be trading our first pick.
Ablett2Jaeger
Debutant
- Jul 16, 2013
- 67
- 35
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Banned
- #28
Nicholls is close to untouchable. I would say Gorringe would cost a pick around 20.
I would be interested in getting Gorringe to Hawthorn. He will really be the perfect age to get a ruckman into your club and providing he would be injury free or no chronic issues. If so would have no issue handing over a first rounder.
Not convinced Lowden or Ceglar will prove themselves to be AFL standard. Grimley is a forward/ruck, Bailey is injury-prone and really just a solid contributor IMO. Hale is 30 and best as a 2nd ruck.
Not convinced Lowden or Ceglar will prove themselves to be AFL standard. Grimley is a forward/ruck, Bailey is injury-prone and really just a solid contributor IMO. Hale is 30 and best as a 2nd ruck.
- Nov 24, 2007
- 13,156
- 949
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Gorringe will be off, 100%.
Just depends who can offer the most. Would expect a South Australian club to go relatively hard for him.
Just depends who can offer the most. Would expect a South Australian club to go relatively hard for him.
Sydswans0512
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jun 25, 2013
- 6,260
- 1,805
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Banned
- #31
Nicholls was with Tippets sister not sure if he still is maybe get Tippo in his ear 
Super Hans
marcus proudson
10k Posts
Pokemon is Life
SuperCoach Club Board Championship League Member
- Apr 27, 2009
- 23,370
- 28,292
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- TrailBlazers, Juventus, Raiders
Nicholls and Smith won't be going anywhere. Gorringe to Port.
Gorringe to Port or Adelaide for a first rounder
There was a recent article about the genius of Peter Rhode! It was a fun read, but he has developed a fool proof plan for building a great list which includes 'don't trade your first round picks'. I don't think we are going to break the master rule for Gorringe.
I think Gorringe will be at Port next year. I wanted him at Port until I say him play a few games for GC this year. Is he really better than he has shown this year? He doesn't look like he wants to get the ball?
I think Gorringe will be at Port next year. I wanted him at Port until I say him play a few games for GC this year. Is he really better than he has shown this year? He doesn't look like he wants to get the ball?
dlanod
Moderator
- Sep 14, 2006
- 52,399
- 81,190
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- GWS; CCMariners; NQCowboys; Ravens
- Moderator
- #36
Why would Port want Gorringe with Lobbe, Renouf and Redden in the ruck, and Schulz, Butcher and Stewart up forward? Not even mentioning Westhoff given he doesn't play a conventional tall role. Honest question, as while I've seen a few Port games this year I'm guessing I'm missing something?
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
Because Renouf and Stewart are ****ing useless.
What positions would the Suns be looking to fill on their list?
They would probably require a steak-knives ruckman thrown in to any trade for depth. Or instead they could draft a mature guy late. Other than that what else? With Smith, Nicholls, Thompson, Day, Lynch, May and Dixon as their tall brigade for a decade, O'Meara, Prestia, Lonergan, Ablett and Swallow shovelling the ball out to Bennell, Martin, Matera, McKenzie and Harbrow they don't want for much
They would probably require a steak-knives ruckman thrown in to any trade for depth. Or instead they could draft a mature guy late. Other than that what else? With Smith, Nicholls, Thompson, Day, Lynch, May and Dixon as their tall brigade for a decade, O'Meara, Prestia, Lonergan, Ablett and Swallow shovelling the ball out to Bennell, Martin, Matera, McKenzie and Harbrow they don't want for much
Stewart will be gone end of year, and Renouf is really only going to be used as backup in case Lobbe and Reddo go down. Westy is playing some great footy floating around the ground too, so having a ruck that can genuinely go down forward frees Westy up to do his thing.
Third round is a bit nothing, and I'm not sure GC would have a huge interest in Mackay. Deal might come close though.
Asgardian
Bigfooty Jedi
Wouldn't get it done coz GC are unlikely to be using draft picks beyond the 2nd round.
They have their 1st round pick, a compo pick & their 2nd round pick, remember they still have to reduce their senior list. They'll probably just use 3 picks, if they want a 4th pick, theirs will be at about the same level as the crows, so your 3rd round is of no use to them.
manny100
Team Captain
Probably a decent 2nd round pick would be about right for Corringe. Depends on demand. He has not shown a lot to date. GC could then look to package their 2nd rounders and swap them for an upgrade pick - not necessarily a big upgrade. As a poster mentioned earlier they will probably only use 3 picks anyway as they have to trim their list. So they probably try to trade their way up the picking order as they trim.
BrockBlitz
Club Legend
People are forgetting this guys has done absolutely bugger all since being on a list. "oh but he was pick 10" , well, GC had a bunch of prelisted 17 year olds and a few other bits n bobs. That included dixon, smith, Toy (who at the time was touted as a potential #1 pick), etc. So on an open market, he was worth maybe 15 at the time. At absolute most this year he is worth pick 20.
TradeDraft
Post-Human
Think it has to be for a 1st Round Pick for Gorringe
Sydswans0512
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jun 25, 2013
- 6,260
- 1,805
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Banned
- #46
Pick 14-18 would be around the mark.
supernova_
Premiership Player
Gorringe as everyone has said is likely to be moved on due to injuries and being behind a few other talls on our list.
I would suggest something like end of 1st round compensation pick which we've activated + Gorringe for Port's 1st round pick
So would be something like Pick 19 + Gorringe for Port's first pick...maybe around pick 9-11?
Would give the Suns pick 9-11 from Port + their first round pick maybe pick 6-8.
Would suggest that they may then be bundled together to upgrade even higher to a pick 2-4. Could be very tempting to a St Kilda or a Bulldogs club getting 2 top 10 picks in a rebuild?
I would suggest something like end of 1st round compensation pick which we've activated + Gorringe for Port's 1st round pick
So would be something like Pick 19 + Gorringe for Port's first pick...maybe around pick 9-11?
Would give the Suns pick 9-11 from Port + their first round pick maybe pick 6-8.
Would suggest that they may then be bundled together to upgrade even higher to a pick 2-4. Could be very tempting to a St Kilda or a Bulldogs club getting 2 top 10 picks in a rebuild?
Governor
Senior List
Solid trade for all parties 
Solid trade for all parties
Who you got IF you let one of these guys go - young ruckman arent good for more than 16? games each year, let alone pull their weight at the top level.
Golumless
A bigger deal out west.
Adelaide will go hard for him, we are pretty desperate in the ruck stocks, thankfully our PSD picks haven't been taken away from us yet so we will be in prime position to get him if he does want to leave and no trade sorted.
That said, none of us hopes that happens because we were pretty bitter with Tippet doing that and i'd rather work out a deal with the suns. Which means a massive complex trade is coming up with roughly 6 teams, similar to the guy who turned a paperclip into a house
That said, none of us hopes that happens because we were pretty bitter with Tippet doing that and i'd rather work out a deal with the suns. Which means a massive complex trade is coming up with roughly 6 teams, similar to the guy who turned a paperclip into a house
Similar threads
