Ranking the list: LAST

[footyman]

Who do you think currently is the worst player on our senior list? ie. If you had to rank the list in order, who finishes last on your list?

 

[lamby29]

Luke Williams, with Broadbridge a close second.

 

[lamby29]

FWIW, here is how I rank the list, from best to worst:

1. David Neitz
2. Adem Yze
3. Clint Bizzell
4. Travis Johnstone
5. Jeff White
6. Cameron Bruce
7. Ben Holland
8. Russell Robertson
9. Chris Heffernan
10. Brad Green
11. Matthew Whelan
12. Steven Armstrong
13. James McDonald
14. Darren Jolly
15. Brad Miller
16. Peter Vardy
17. Simon Godfrey
18. Chris Lamb
19. Nathan Brown
20. Scott Thompson
21. Alistair Nicholson
22. Daniel Ward
23. Mark Jamar
24. Guy Rigoni
25. Ryan Ferguson
26. Nathan Carroll
27. Paul Wheatley
28. Peter Walsh
29. Troy Broadbridge
30. Luke Williams

I didn't include Hunter, Rivers, Smith, Bell, Sylvia, McLean and CJ.

 

[dees_best]

Walsh, Broadbridge & Williams are all on par with each other as the worst player at the MFC.

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Im going to do two lists, a pecking order and my personal ratings.

Im also assuming we take Read in the pre season.


List 1 - The Pecking Order

1. David Nietz
2. Adem Yze
3. Clint Bizzell
4. Cameron Bruce
5. Travis Johnstone
6. Jeff White
7. Russell Robertson
8. James McDonald
9. Darren Jolly
10. Ben Holland
11. Matthew Whelan
12. Chris Heffernan
13. Alastair Nicholson
14. Simon Godfrey
15. Phil Read
16. Brad Green
17. Nathan Brown
18. Daniel Ward
19. Peter Vardy
20. Steven Armstrong
21. Brad Miller
22. Scott Thompson
23. Peter Walsh
24. Luke Williams
25. Nathan Carroll
26. Paul Wheatley
27. Ryan Ferguson
28. Troy Broadbridge
29. Mark Jamar
30. Guy Rigoni
31. Chris Lamb


List 2 - My ratings, based on ability, importance to the team, what theyve shown so far and whether or not I'd like them in my ideal side.

1. David Nietz
2. Adem Yze
3. Clint Bizzell
4. Travis Johnstone
5. Cameron Bruce
6. Matthew Whelan
7. Alastair Nicholson
8. Simon Godfrey
9. Jeff White
10. Darren Jolly
11. Daniel Ward
12. Nathan Brown
13. Phil Read
14. James McDonald
15. Scott Thompson
16. Brad Miller
17. Steven Armstrong
18. Peter Vardy
19. Brad Green
20. Ben Holland
21. Paul Wheatley
22. Russell Robertson
23. Peter Walsh
24. Luke Williams
25. Ryan Ferguson
26. Chris Lamb
27. Troy Broadbridge
28. Nathan Carroll
29. Guy Rigoni
30. Chris Heffernan
31. Mark Jamar

 

[lamby29]

What's wrong with Jamar?

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Originally posted by lamby29
What's wrong with Jamar?

Nothing wrong, I just think he's shown less than the players above him, mainly through lack of oppurtunity.

I should really have left him off the list and placed him in the same category as Smith, Hunter and Rivers etc.

 

[demon21]

broadbridge, close second carroll

 

[BT]

Originally posted by lamby29
What's wrong with Jamar?

What's wrong with Whoppa?

Some of you have short memories...

1. Neitz
2. Yze
3. Bizzell
4. White
5. Bruce
6. Johnstone
7. McDonald
8. Brown
9. Robertson
10. Jolly
11. Vardy
12. Nicholson
13. Godfrey
14. Heffernan
15. Green
16. Holland
17. Ward
18. Whelan
19. Armstrong
20. Rigoni
21. Walsh
22. Thompson
23. Wheatley
24. Broadbridge
25. Miller
26. Lamb
27. Ferguson
28. Williams
29. Carroll
30. Who have I forgotten???

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Originally posted by BT
What's wrong with Whoppa?

Some of you have short memories...

30. Who have I forgotten???

You missed Jamar and Read.

I like Walsh I just reckon our other half backs have more to offer.

He would slot in at half back in most sides though.

 

[BT]

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
You missed Jamar and Read.

I like Walsh I just reckon our other half backs have more to offer.

He would slot in at half back in most sides though.

Read! lol.

Slot Russian in @ #25.

 

[Supermercado]

Being a bit harsh on Ward here aren't we? I'd definately have him above Brown.

 

[Demon3]

1. David Neitz
2. Cameron Bruce
3. Clint Bizzell
4. Adem Yze
5. Travis Johnstone
6. J.White
7. B.Green
8. R.Robertson
9. D.Ward
10. N.Brown
11. C.Heffernan
12. P.Vardy
13. J.McDonald
14. M.Whelan
15. B.Holland
16. L.Williams
17. P.Walsh
18. S.Thompson
19. P.Wheatley
20. S.Armstrong
21. B.Miller
22. S.Godfrey
23. G.Rigoni
24. D.Jolly
25. M.Jamar
26. N.Smith
27. C.Lamb
28. A.Nicholson
29. R.Fergerson
30. N.Carroll
31. T.Broadbridge

 

[X_box_X]

With the exceptions of BT and B20, how could you not have McDonald in your club's top ten?

 

[demondavey]

Whats it like now fellas?

 

[Sylvia Saint]

Johnstone, Moloney, Miller, Neitz, Bruce, White, Green, Yze, Rivers, McLean top 10.

Williams and Heffernan last.

BTW seeing Broadbridge on those lists makes me sad.

 

[Marns]

Johnstone, Moloney, Miller, Neitz, Bruce, White, Green, Yze, Rivers, McLean top 10.

Williams and Heffernan last.

BTW seeing Broadbridge on those lists makes me sad.

I know, when I saw that (without looking at the date, assuming it was written today) I was about to let a few expletives off at those guys who said it.

Dont think I can argue with your top 10 SS. Its hard to gauge now if I was to do a full list, seeing as there would be a lot of guys on = 30, but the top 10 looks about right to moi.

Also, its funny how luke williams was no.30 for a lot of people back two years ago. Nothing has changed.

 

[melbournemartin]

sylvia saint, you forgot robertson

 

[Bentleigh]

Luke Williams, with Broadbridge a close second.

i felt cold reading that.

 

[Marns]

i felt cold reading that.

Wow, I saw your name as the last reply to this thread and I thought you were gonna be trolling. But instead I get this response from you? Does this mean that bentleigh might have a heart afterall?

 

[CowboyFromHell]

This is what our Top 10 SHOULD look like:

Neitz
White
Bruce
Yze
Johnstone
Green
Rivers
Bizzell
Brown
Robertson

Rivers gets in through being a consistent player at CHB, Miller would probably be 11. McLean is Top 15 but not 10 yet, Sylvia Top 20.

That's how it should go, although a fair stack of those players are doing nothing.

 

[BT]

I agree that seeing Troy on those lists wasn't great, but it was an honest reflection of people's opinions at the time. I for one would've ranked him in our best 22 by the end of 2004.