Rate your 2017 list in terms of draft picks

[HeHateMe]

Not writing Lovell off. Pick 40 is around the mark where we've previously drafted Hardwick, Stratton, Sicily... Its around about the compo pick we got for Suckling. It's a decent enough pick for a decent enough prospect.

It is unlikely anyone would offer us the pick 22 we originally paid for Lovell.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Nope that's unders.

Edit: what makes hardwick, 20 picks better. Both look the goods imo. No idea why you rate 1 higher then the other. Delusional.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[Bokonon_]

Probably exaggerating like most people:

Picks 1 or more
None

Pick 2 - 5
None

Picks 6 - 10
Goldstein
Cunnington
Tarrant
McDonald

Picks 11 - 20
Ziebell
Wood
Brown
Higgins
Dumont
Simpkin

Picks 20 - 30
M Williams (based on this year's form)
Garner
Macmillan

Picks 30 - 40
EVW
Hansen
Jacobs
Thomas
Clarke
Mullett
Pruess
Hrovat

Picks 40 - 50
Daw
Swallow (probably worth less)
Atley
Anderson
Turner
Gibson
Durdin
Thompson

Pick 50+
None

Think you'd have about 17 options to trade Preuss at that range. I get it's potential but still. Daw is interesting as well.

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Think you'd have about 17 options to trade Preuss at that range. I get it's potential but still. Daw is interesting as well.

Honestly, who knows with Daw, more likely a bust, but he cops injuries at bad times in terms of good form. Pruess is still raw as anything, but I doubt we will trade him. Goldstein, Pruess and maj, our ruck stocks are bare after them.

 

[Bokonon_]

Honestly, who knows with Daw, more likely a bust, but he cops injuries at bad times in terms of good form. Pruess is still raw as anything, but I doubt we will trade him. Goldstein, Pruess and maj, our ruck stocks are bare after them.

I think Daw looks the goids, but get what you mean. He has freinds on our biard but I think if you see him at his best you'd want him.
I get you wouldn't want to trade Pruess, just he is a bit undervalued in the 20-30 range I thought. Early days I get.

 

[Golden_6]

Picks 1 or more
Bont

Pick 2 - 5

Picks 6 - 10
T Boyd
Dahlhaus
JJ
Macrae
Stringer

Picks 11 - 20
Wood
Libba
Adams
Dunkley
English
Hunter


Picks 20 - 30
Wallis
McLean
Cordy
Daniel
Jong
Lipinski
Picken
Roughead

Picks 30 - 40
Biggs
Collins
Dickson
Roberts
Suckling
Williams
Crameri

Picks 40 - 50
Webb
Campbell
Dale
Redpath
C Smith

Pick 50+
Young
Greene
Honeychurch

Left off older guys that wouldn't have much/any calue - M Boyd, Morris, Murphy
Following guys would hold essentially no value - Prudden, Hamilton, Tweedie, Mullenger-McHugh, R Smith

 

[RedWhite&Blue]

For the Bombers:
Joe Daniher (1 - 3)
Zach Merrett (1 - 4)
Andy McGrath (1 - 5)
Dyson Heppell (2 - 6)
Orazio Fantasia (2 - 6)
Darcy Parish (3 - 7)
Michael Hurley (4 - 10)
Aaron Francis (6 - 14)
Cale Hooker (8 - 15)

He he he he he....

 

[HeHateMe]

He he he he he....

the premership list that one.

 

[Old Stuckup]

Bump for 2018 lists. I’ve probably overrated a lot but oh well.

Picks 1 or more
Daniher
McGrath

Pick 2 - 5
Z Merrett
Parish
Hurley

Picks 6 - 10
Heppell
Fantasia

Picks 11 - 20
Hooker
Zaharakis
Smith
Stringer

Picks 20 - 30
Francis
McKenna
Saad
McDonald-Tipungwuti
Laverde
Langford
Begley
Ridley

Picks 30 - 40
Myers
Stewart
Bellchambers
Hartley
Ambrose

Picks 40 - 50
Houlahan
Mutch
Brown
Clarke
Colyer

Pick 50+
Zerk-Thatcher
Goddard
J Merrett
Long
Green
Baguley
Guelfi
Dea
Leuenberger
Draper
McKernan

 

[Mitchell54]

Did this again. Didn’t include anyone yet to debut

1 or more:
T Mitchell

2 - 5:
R Burton

6-10:
Rioli
O’Meara
Gunston

11-20:
Roughead
Bruest
Sicily
McEvoy
Frawley
Howe

21-30:
Birchall
Shiels
Hardwick
O’Brien
Smith


31-40:
Brand
Stratton
Lovell

41-50:
Ceglar
Puopolo
Duryea
Whitecross
Schoenmakers
Morrison
O’Rourke
Henderson
Langford

51+:
Pittonet
Glass
Cousins
Heatherley
Burgoyne
Willsmore
Vickery
Miles

 

[Beer n Skittles]

Pick 1 or more
C.Curnow
Cripps

2-5
Petrevski-Seton
Docherty
Weitering
Dow

6-10
Marchbank

11-20
O'Brien
McKay
Kennedy
Kreuzer
Plowman

21-30
Murphy
Jones
Wright
Pickett
J.Silvagni
Cuningham
Macreadie
Fisher

31-40
E.Curnow
Casboult
Byrne
Garlett
Polson
Kerr

41-50
Lang
Simpson
Kerridge
Phillips

50+
Thomas
A.Silvagni
Rowe
Lobbe
Shaw
Mullett
O'Shea
Lamb
Graham
Glass-McCasker
LeBois

This years draftees marked down a little due to the weak draft.
So so many players in that 50+ group

 

[year of the cat]

C.Curnow is not commanding a no.1 pick. Has potential but that’s about it at the moment.

 

[Mitchell54]

Pick 1 or more
C.Curnow
Cripps

2-5
Petrevski-Seton
Docherty
Weitering
Dow

6-10
Marchbank

11-20
O'Brien
McKay
Kennedy
Kreuzer
Plowman

21-30
Murphy
Jones
Wright
Pickett
J.Silvagni
Cuningham
Macreadie
Fisher

31-40
E.Curnow
Casboult
Byrne
Lang (?)
Garlett
Polson
Kerr

50+
Simpson
Thomas
A.Silvagni
Rowe
Lobbe
Phillips
Shaw
Mullett
O'Shea
Lamb
Kerridge
Graham
Glass-McCasker
LeBois

This years draftees marked down a little due to the weak draft.
So so many players in that 50+ group

No 41-50 zone.

 

[Beer n Skittles]

No 41-50 zone.

Thanks, I'll edit & split that big group up a bit.

C.Curnow is not commanding a no.1 pick. Has potential but that’s about it at the moment.

I think he showed a decent chunk of quality & consistency in the 2nd half of the year. Others might rate Weitering higher, but I think most people would have one of those two in at pick 1.

 

[Jade]

Bump for 2018 lists. I’ve probably overrated a lot but oh well.

Picks 1 or more
Daniher
McGrath

Pick 2 - 5
Z Merrett
Parish
Hurley

Picks 6 - 10
Heppell
Fantasia

Picks 11 - 20
Hooker
Zaharakis
Smith
Stringer

Picks 20 - 30
Francis
McKenna
Saad
McDonald-Tipungwuti
Laverde
Langford
Begley
Ridley

Picks 30 - 40
Myers
Stewart
Bellchambers
Hartley
Ambrose

Picks 40 - 50
Houlahan
Mutch
Brown
Clarke
Colyer

Pick 50+
Zerk-Thatcher
Goddard
J Merrett
Long
Green
Baguley
Guelfi
Dea
Leuenberger
Draper
McKernan

Daniher or McGrath could probably get pick 1.

However I don't think Michael Hurley, as good as he is, would fetch a pick in the top 5 considering his age.

And I'd be VERY confident the club would be very hard pressed to trade Draper.

 

[Mitchell54]

However I don't think Michael Hurley, as good as he is, would fetch a pick in the top 5 considering his age.

He’s only 27. I’d say he worth a top 5 Pick. Especially after what Gibbs & Weller fetched.

 

[Trav 20]

He’s only 27. I’d say he worth a top 5 Pick. Especially after what Gibbs & Weller fetched.

I agree.

I reckon Hurley is almost underrated. Only one defender has made Hogan look silly and it was Hurley.

 

[Mitchell54]

Probably exaggerating like most people:

Picks 1 or more
None

Pick 2 - 5
None

Picks 6 - 10
Goldstein
Cunnington
Tarrant
McDonald

Picks 11 - 20
Ziebell
Wood
Brown
Higgins
Dumont
Simpkin

Picks 20 - 30
M Williams (based on this year's form)
Garner
Macmillan

Picks 30 - 40
EVW
Hansen
Jacobs
Thomas
Clarke
Mullett
Pruess
Hrovat

Picks 40 - 50
Daw
Swallow (probably worth less)
Atley
Anderson
Turner
Gibson
Durdin
Thompson

Pick 50+
None

Sign me up for Brown, Garner & Preuss please

 

[Ambrosia]

I agree.

I reckon Hurley is almost underrated. Only one defender has made Hogan look silly and it was Hurley.

His body doesn't seem to hold up too well for a full season which doesn't bode well for his longevity. Big Hurley fan but I can't see a club giving up a top 5 pick for him.

 

[drama5]

Ok ill give it a go:

Gold coast:

1: lynch
First round: ainsworth, scrimshaw, brodie, martin, weller, may, wright, bowes, swallow (borderline)
Second round - hall, ah chee, miller, koladashnij, lyons
Third round - hanley, sexton, fiorini, thompson,
Fourth round - rosa, nichols, harbrow, day, leslie, schoenfeld, lemons, witts,
No value/ too old - rischitelli, joyce, scheer, lonergan, barlow

 

[BPikkers]

Did this again. Didn’t include anyone yet to debut

1 or more:
T Mitchell

2 - 5:
R Burton

6-10:
Rioli
O’Meara
Gunston

11-20:
Roughead
Bruest
Sicily
McEvoy
Frawley
Howe

21-30:
Birchall
Shiels
Hardwick
O’Brien
Smith


31-40:
Brand
Stratton
Lovell

41-50:
Ceglar
Puopolo
Duryea
Whitecross
Schoenmakers
Morrison
O’Rourke
Henderson
Langford

51+:
Pittonet
Glass
Cousins
Heatherley
Burgoyne
Willsmore
Vickery
Miles

Most of those players you have 31+ should be more like 50+

 

[Donakebab]

Ok ill give it a go:

Gold coast:

1: lynch
First round: ainsworth, scrimshaw, brodie, martin, weller, may, wright, bowes, swallow (borderline)
Second round - hall, ah chee, miller, koladashnij, lyons
Third round - hanley, sexton, fiorini, thompson,
Fourth round - rosa, nichols, harbrow, day, leslie, schoenfeld, lemons, witts,
No value/ too old - rischitelli, joyce, scheer, lonergan, barlow

Would pay a second for Hall and Miller in a heartbeat. Also not sure how Witts has lost a ton of value after having a great year, should be up in the second round imo.

 

[1990crow]

Pick 1 or more


2-5
Sloane

6-10
M.Crouch
Walker
Laird

11-20
B.Crouch
Jenkins
Gibbs
Galluci
Talia
Betts
Milera
Fogarty
Smith

21-30
Greenwood
Hartigan
Atkins
Jacobs
Lynch
Doedee

31-40
Knight
Kelly
Brown
Himmelburg
McPherson
Keath

41-50
Poholke
Seedsman
Mackay
Douglas

50+
Hampton
Gibson
Otten
Cheney
Dear
Davis
Signorello

 

[cecil]

Picks 1 or more
Bont

Pick 2 - 5

Picks 6 - 10
T Boyd
JJ
Macrae

Picks 11 - 20
Wood
Adams
Dunkley
English
Hunter
Daniel
Dahl
Schache

Picks 20 - 30
Wallis
McLean
Cordy
Lipinski
Roughead
Libba
Trengove
Dale
Young
Williams

Picks 30 - 40
Crozier
Biggs
Suckling
Jong
Picken
Redpath

Picks 40 - 50
Dickson
Webb
C Smith
Robers
Collins

Pick 50+
Campbell
Greene
Honeychurch

 

[drama5]

Would pay a second for Hall and Miller in a heartbeat. Also not sure how Witts has lost a ton of value after having a great year, should be up in the second round imo.

Exactly but would you do a first round? I think miller could sneak into first but hall isnt. And im not sold on witts but could sneak a second round. And few of first rounders i dont reckon will hold the first round value (bowes and scrimshaw my questionmarks). Miller has potential to rise as does fiorini

 

[PMBangers]

Pick 1
Josh Kelly
Jeremy Cameron

Pick 2-5
Dylan Shiel
Zac Williams
Callan Ward

Pick 6-10
Toby Greene
Tom Scully
Stephen Coniglio

Pick 11-20
Adam Tomilson
Jonathon Patton
Phil Davis
Rory Lobb
Tim Taranto
Jacob Hooper

Pick 20-29
Will Setterfield
Harry Perryman
Nick Haynes
Aidan Corr
Lachie Whitfield
Adam Kennedy
Harry Himmelberg

Pick 30-39
Heath Shaw
Matt Buntine
Issac Cumming
Zach Sproule
Dawson Simpson

Pick 40-49
Matt De Boer
Lachlan Tizani
Matthew Flynn
Jeremy Finlayson
Ryan Griffin

Pick 50 +
Daniel Lloyd
Tim Mohr
Jake Stein


All 2017 draftees are too early to tell