Scott selwood vs joel selwood

[vivien]

Scott selwood limited judd to just 13 disposals last night? But, whose better?

 

[Churros]

Scooter is a gun, and one of my favourite players in the comp. However, he's more of a Ling type of player (tagging, tackling, getting the ball, kicking occasional goals) and I didn't think too much of him until this year.

I'm going to have to say Joel by a mile though. This kid has got himself an almost certain 2012 captaincy. He could have been a contender for the Charlie had he not been suspended V Hawthorn. He's made AA twice I think (including this year), and there are not many 23 year olds who have played in two premierships (although that's more of a team thing). Will win many B&Fs in the future.

A lot of people will vote Scotty because he 'ducks' to a lesser extent

 

[kaiserchief13]

Joel is clearly a better player though Scott Selwood is a player every team needs.

 

[Lotch]

Accidentally clicked on Scott but I think Joel is better now and after they both retire.

Even though they play different roles.

 

[Igloo]

Joel. Pretty easily.

Scooter is a very good player though. But Joel is a gun.

 

[alex 17]

Joel by a country mile.

 

[saintsrfreak]

LOL not even a question.

 

[dajesmac]

Scott is brilliant, underrated and an A grader.

Is not at Joel's level though.

 

[Le Class]

Joel.

This is going to get messy.

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Not even the most one eyed west coast supporter would try and seriously argue Scott is better, stupid poll.

 

[Alexwce]

is this a joke? this isn't poll worthy - Joel by a country mile

 

[jonoman89]

Joel will have claims to be the best player in the AFL soon enough.

Joel. Easily.

 

[ndot]

joel > scott >>>>>>>> adam > troy

 

[HurleyTheFuture]

This poll is stupid

 

[kane249]

Sympathy vote for Scott

Seriously this poll is a non contest

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Scott Selwood will likely never be as good as Joel Selwood was in his first year, so the chances of him ever being as good as Joel is now are approximately 3/5ths of f**k all.

 

[jod23]

Joel is the better player. Scooter is quality though and keeps getting better and better.

 

[DapperDon]

Who's better Brad Lloyd or Matthew Lloyd

**** I hate school holidays.

 

[tigerpain92]

joel is more elite and has more influence over big games