List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2017/2018 - Refreshed (cont in part 2)

[Mukesh]

Smith has a certain vanilla-ness but after only two years in the system deserves to stay and is a better punt than a late pick.

I suspect they want to keep all our QLD boys around to play their part in a mooted big trade from up north next year...personally, I'll be amazed if it happens..

 

[TheSierBear]

Not many posts recently, but this thread is LOUD!!! With 161 watching. COLL-INGGGGGG-WOOOOOOOOOODD
Chant together bretheran!!!

 

[mike123]

Smith has a certain vanilla-ness but after only two years in the system deserves to stay and is a better punt than a late pick.

Should have been delisted over Ramsay

 

[jackcass]

Should have been delisted over Ramsay

That's certainly how I would have gone. Ramsay has shown he can lock down on a player and can take the game on.

 

[nahnah]

very much in the delist Smith and take a chance on pick 70 camp but doubt it will happen now

 

[Darkyprotector]

Ahh damn

Every one seems certain he's on the list
My question is why no contract?
Seems a bit strange imo

 

[Darkyprotector]

That's certainly how I would have gone. Ramsay has shown he can lock down on a player and can take the game on.

Maybe smith agreed
Ramsay didn't
But as pointed out its all speculation
A few have posted rules re delistings ect
No ones posted a link

 

[nahnah]

Every one seems certain he's on the list
My question is why no contract?
Seems a bit strange imo

maybe he had a trigger like Blair we just didn't know about? Only thing I can think of

 

[Darkyprotector]

Not many posts recently, but this thread is LOUD!!! With 161 watching. COLL-INGGGGGG-WOOOOOOOOOODD
Chant together bretheran!!!

Thought I'd get some discussion going
Lots of questions
Smith no contract
Thomas 1 year
Commitment to brown
Commitment to rookie oxley
All speculation like everything else on here

 

[Darkyprotector]

maybe he had a trigger like Blair we just didn't know about? Only thing I can think of

Blair signed up last year on chips
1 year with triggers
Mainly due to his work Ethic and club loyalty
Hit his triggers got another year
Smith ?

 

[Hardas]

Just finished reading LOU - My Wonderful Life.

I know it's not going to happen but how good would it be for the Pannam & Richards name to continue out our wonderful Club.

R.I.P Lou Richards what a legend.

Too right!
Hopefully comes home after a couple of years of development elsewhere.

 

[Darkyprotector]

I suspect they want to keep all our QLD boys around to play their part in a mooted big trade from up north next year...personally, I'll be amazed if it happens..

Well at least that makes some sense
Weird he hasn't got a contract yet though
Wonder if we're looking at flexiabity / options
Who's available ect , who's nominated for draft
ANOTHER HINE SPECIAL?

 

[Darkyprotector]

Would rather smith than pick 70

If and when he's rookied
It won't matter , upgrades are done and dusted

 

[Darkyprotector]

Because it suits his narrative of pick 70 being somehow useful.

Heard of speculation
Lets see

 

[Mukesh]

Well at least that makes some sense
Weird he hasn't got a contract yet though
Wonder if we're looking at flexiabity / options
Who's available ect , who's nominated for draft
ANOTHER HINE SPECIAL?

Yeah... I guess so. Looks like Mr Smith's future rests with whoever is still left in the in the pond come our last pick..

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Should have been delisted over Ramsay

Either of them would have been unlucky. Ramsay definitely, hopefully he gets a rookie chance somewhere.

We may lack top end talent but certainly the list bats pretty deep with very little genuine dead wood.

 

[Darkyprotector]

Either of them would have been unlucky. Ramsay definitely, hopefully he gets a rookie chance somewhere.

We may lack top end talent but certainly the list bats pretty deep with very little genuine dead wood.

If he's still got the drive and staying in vic , my advice is go to willy
Best coach outside afl
Best developer
Good club

 

[left at home]

I suspect they want to keep all our QLD boys around to play their part in a mooted big trade from up north next year...personally, I'll be amazed if it happens..

Then why was keeffe not kept then.

 

[Mukesh]

Then why was keeffe not kept then.

Well spotted... well I guess they can’t keep ALL of them for that obscure reason..

 

[mike123]

Either of them would have been unlucky. Ramsay definitely, hopefully he gets a rookie chance somewhere.

We may lack top end talent but certainly the list bats pretty deep with very little genuine dead wood.

I'd count Smith as dead wood.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Blair signed up last year on chips
1 year with triggers
Mainly due to his work Ethic and club loyalty
Hit his triggers got another year
Smith ?

Like Simon Wiggins.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I'd count Smith as dead wood.

I figured that already

 

[grayza2018]

That's certainly how I would have gone. Ramsay has shown he can lock down on a player and can take the game on.

Smith's first instinct when he gets the ball to either kick backwards or switch diagonally backwards versus Ramsay running the lines a bit more, Smith very lucky if you ask me

 

[sr36]

Smith's first instinct when he gets the ball to either kick backwards or switch diagonally backwards versus Ramsay running the lines a bit more, Smith very lucky if you ask me

What you are describing with Smith, appeared to be team instructions last year.

 

[jackcass]

Maybe smith agreed
Ramsay didn't
But as pointed out its all speculation
A few have posted rules re delistings ect
No ones posted a link

Not sure what they're meant to have agreed to but both training with the club according to training reports.