VFL VFL 2023 - [Rnd11 vs * - Sunday June 4 - 1:35pm @NEC Hangar]

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Hmm trying to not get excited about something that may not have happened, but maybe his performance in this phantom scratchie was used as another part of the basis for the 'Charlie Comben is smashing the door down' comment in the AFL in the mix article this week.
 
Hmm trying to not get excited about something that may not have happened, but maybe his performance in this phantom scratchie was used as another part of the basis for the 'Charlie Comben is smashing the door down' comment in the AFL in the mix article this week.
Was my first thought too.
 
Another bit of evidence there might have been a scratchie on the weekend from the article about our interest in Weideman:

"They have been buoyed by the progression of second-year tall forward Charlie Comben in recent scratch matches having returned from a serious leg injury earlier this month."

Note the use of the plural matches. Interesting that there's been no details emerge about it.
 
Another bit of evidence there might have been a scratchie on the weekend from the article about our interest in Weideman:

"They have been buoyed by the progression of second-year tall forward Charlie Comben in recent scratch matches having returned from a serious leg injury earlier this month."

Note the use of the plural matches. Interesting that there's been no details emerge about it.
covered in another thread; there was a scratch on the weekend, presumably top secret for covid reasons
 
covered in another thread; there was a scratch on the weekend, presumably top secret for covid reasons
Which thread, mate? Honestly though, the only player I'm really that interested in at this point is Comben. Any idea how he went?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)


North Melbourne suffered a blow of its own with captain Flynn Appleby (wrist) and forward Mat Walker (shoulder) ruled out for the season, with the Kangaroos making 11 changes to the team that pushed Footscray in Round 12.

AFL players Shaun Atley, Aiden Bonar, Kyron Hayden and Will Walker have been named, while key forward Charlie Comben and mid-season No.1 draft pick Jake Edwards will debut alongside Tyler Roos and Ben Speight.

Jed Anderson, Jared Polec and Atu Bosenavulagi have been promoted since Norther last played at VFL level

NORTH MELBOURNE v PORT MELBOURNE
Saturday, July 31, 12pm @ Arden St (www.youtube.com.au, search VFL, 11.55am)

NORTH MELBOURNE
B: 64. L. Cunningham, 81. H. Murphy, 37. K. Hayden
HB: 34. C. Ham, 16. A. Bonar
, 52. J. Heron
C: 33. P. Walker, 56. K. Answerth, 17. L. Young
HF: 31. C. Menadue, 30. C. Comben, 70. B. Speight
F: 53. C. Byrne, 32. J. Edwards, 85. H. Dick
R: 63. M. Baker, 57. H. Jones, 27. W. Walker
Inter: 18. S. Atley, 42. T. Campbell, 35. C. Lazzaro, 54. T. Roos, 36. P. Spicer

Emerg: 60. C. Brown

*AFL emergencies underlined

In: Atley, Bonar, Comben, Cunningham, Edwards, Hayden, Murphy, Roos, Speight, Spicer, W. Walker
Out: J. Anderson, A. Bosenavulagi, J. Polec (AFL), F. Appleby (wrist), A. Hare, S. Clifford, T. Donnelly, A. Polidoros, E. Reardon, J. Watkins

PORT MELBOURNE
B: 6. F. Roberts, 34. K. Reid, 16. C. Searle
HB: 11. C. Jansen, 30. E. Phillips, 22. L. McKenna
C: 14. N. Holmes, 4. T. O'Sullivan, 37. H. Hooper
HF: 42. M. Kane, 15. P. Kerr, 29. C. Walker
F: 19. A. Anastasio, 17. M. Signorello, 18. M. Wooffindin
R: 36. J. Hotchkin, 3. E. Templeton, 13. C. Wagner
Inter: 10. M. Arnot, 9. C. Hodges, 21. B. Jolley, 38. J. O'Sullivan

Emerg: 27. L. Delahunty, 12. D. Koenen, 28. J. May, 20. D. Watson

In: Hooper, McKenna, Signorello
Out: F. Flockart, P. Lewis-Smith, D. Watson

Prediction: North Melbourne by 15
 
Last edited:

North Melbourne suffered a blow of its own with captain Flynn Appleby (wrist) and forward Mat Walker (shoulder) ruled out for the season, with the Kangaroos making 11 changes to the team that pushed Footscray in Round 12.

AFL players Shaun Atley, Aiden Bonar, Kyron Hayden and Will Walker have been named, while key forward Charlie Comben and mid-season No.1 draft pick Jake Edwards will debut alongside Tyler Roos and Ben Speight.

Jed Anderson, Jared Polec and Atu Bosenavulagi have been promoted since Norther last played at VFL level

NORTH MELBOURNE v PORT MELBOURNE
Saturday, July 31, 12pm @ Arden St (www.youtube.com.au, search VFL, 11.55am)

NORTH MELBOURNE
B: 64. L. Cunningham, 81. H. Murphy, 37. K. Hayden
HB: 34. C. Ham, 16. A. Bonar, 52. J. Heron
C: 33. P. Walker, 56. K. Answerth, 17. L. Young
HF: 31. C. Menadue, 30. C. Comben, 70. B. Speight
F: 53. C. Byrne, 32. J. Edwards, 85. H. Dick
R: 63. M. Baker, 57. H. Jones, 27. W. Walker
Inter: 18. S. Atley, 42. T. Campbell, 35. C. Lazzaro, 54. T. Roos, 36. P. Spicer

Emerg: 60. C. Brown

*AFL emergencies underlined

In: Atley, Bonar, Comben, Cunningham, Edwards, Hayden, Murphy, Roos, Speight, Spicer, W. Walker
Out: J. Anderson, A. Bosenavulagi, J. Polec (AFL), F. Appleby (wrist), A. Hare, S. Clifford, T. Donnelly, A. Polidoros, E. Reardon, J. Watkins

PORT MELBOURNE
B: 6. F. Roberts, 34. K. Reid, 16. C. Searle
HB: 11. C. Jansen, 30. E. Phillips, 22. L. McKenna
C: 14. N. Holmes, 4. T. O'Sullivan, 37. H. Hooper
HF: 42. M. Kane, 15. P. Kerr, 29. C. Walker
F: 19. A. Anastasio, 17. M. Signorello, 18. M. Wooffindin
R: 36. J. Hotchkin, 3. E. Templeton, 13. C. Wagner
Inter: 10. M. Arnot, 9. C. Hodges, 21. B. Jolley, 38. J. O'Sullivan

Emerg: 27. L. Delahunty, 12. D. Koenen, 28. J. May, 20. D. Watson

In: Hooper, McKenna, Signorello
Out: F. Flockart, P. Lewis-Smith, D. Watson

Prediction: North Melbourne by 15

Dec Watson can't even get a game at Port Melbourne
 
OK, so Edwards not in is a shame, but Comben backing up with another game is good, glad to see Cham is ready to attack the last few weeks and it's lovely to see Will Walker managed to escape that hotel room in Queensland.
 
OK, so Edwards not in is a shame, but Comben backing up with another game is good, glad to see Cham is ready to attack the last few weeks and it's lovely to see Will Walker managed to escape that hotel room in Queensland.
From the afl website:


AFL players Shaun Atley, Aiden Bonar, Kyron Hayden and Will Walker have been named, while key forward Charlie Comben and mid-season No.1 draft pick Jake Edwards will debut alongside Tyler Roos and Ben Speight.
 
From the afl website:


AFL players Shaun Atley, Aiden Bonar, Kyron Hayden and Will Walker have been named, while key forward Charlie Comben and mid-season No.1 draft pick Jake Edwards will debut alongside Tyler Roos and Ben Speight.
If only the afl could at least write his first name correctly, is it too much to ask for afl media to get that right
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top