Opinion Who DON'T you want your team to draft? 2022 Edition

[citizen-erased]

Not so much a player, but id rather not combine 22 and f2 to move up unless we can nab hollands or tsatas slips crazily to a pick we can get.

Rather move it into an f2.
Ideally though it stays intact before a davey bid

 

[weltschmerz]

Not so much a player, but id rather not combine 22 and f2 to move up unless we can nab hollands or tsatas slips crazily to a pick we can get.

Rather move it into an f2.
Ideally though it stays intact before a davey bid

He's exactly the type the Dogs need and we've got 21, so I'm not sure it'll stay intact.

 

[citizen-erased]

He's exactly the type the Dogs need and we've got 21, so I'm not sure it'll stay intact.

George may still be there and likely the better player.
Bit of hope, but if the bid comes, we ideally have a way of moving the pick to next year.

 

[FB19]

George may still be there and likely the better player.
Bit of hope, but if the bid comes, we ideally have a way of moving the pick to next year.

Seemingly 3 threats Sydney gws and dogs all need a Davey type would be surprised if 22 lasts hopefully we are ready to take it

 

[KnaveyBlue]

Has anyone blown up a defender since Nick Riewoldt in the 00’s?

Pre-knee C. Curnow. Nobody else I can think of tho.

Do not want Tsatas.

 

[#1_pigeonracer]

It’s all fun and opinion I think he’s going to be a star in the Gunston mould but who knows…anyway hawks relocating their base to Mornington peninsula so they can start to grab 20 years olds who want the beach life away from the cats.

True, a lot of aspiring surfers hail from the Dingley area.

 

[Orange Agent]

Hayes. Im fine with taking KPD, just not this one.

 

[weltschmerz]

I want us to not trade three firsts for pick 4.

 

[Mojorisin]

I want us to not trade three firsts for pick 4.

I second this especially if it's to get tsatas (polec)

 

[Membling]

A few:

Hotton - good player but I feel we have enough playera of his type at swans. Be good at other clubs but do not need another like him currently

Konstanty - see above

Keeler - super talented but our track record of developing talls with all potential and inconsistent performance is not good.

Welcome aboard Konstanty

Least Clarke has competition for pressure small forward

 

[WilloTree]

Cam Mckenzie

Nothing stands out

oh no

 

[BIGHAWK23]

Cam Mckenzie

Nothing stands out

Im more keen now

Maybe thats because we drafted him

 

[GrInPoWdErDiAh]

Mine was Matt Jefferson, so hopefully I'm just very wrong on him.. Taylor and his team do have a good record so I guess there's that!

 

[RUNVS]

Welcome aboard Konstanty

Least Clarke has competition for pressure small forward

You watch us draft Hotton today.

 

[Atavistic]

I didn't want Tsatas. Don't think he can kick very well at all and we have a dearth of mids who are good kicks.

 

[citizen-erased]

Not so much a player, but id rather not combine 22 and f2 to move up unless we can nab hollands or tsatas slips crazily to a pick we can get.

Rather move it into an f2.
Ideally though it stays intact before a davey bid

Huzzah

 

[doug85]

Huzzah

We have a full draft hand for next year which is very handy.

 

[Judd2Sewell]

Not so much that I didn't want them exactly, but I really preferred Humphrey, Mackenzie and Phillipou at our first pick over Tsatas, Ginbey and especially Clark. Mostly based on needs.

I think Tsatas is an average kick for a predominantly outside midfielder who needs to work on his inside game. His kicking and decision making in the Metro v Country final was really poor.

Good size and athleticism though based on the eye test. His combine was fairly average, but surely that's in part to his foot injury.

Clark is on the smaller side for a contested midfielder that has a lack of exposed versatility, and is not the most athletic or quick.

And I just didn't know enough about Ginbey and hadn't had any chance to watch footage of him.

Keep in mind these criticisms are only in relation to them being top picks, so it's all relative there. And I think these weaknesses could be worked on.

 

[Coach_Required]

All of them do, stop drafting so many WA players and you'll be fine.

We must choose the strong independent WA boys then

 

[WilloTree]

Anyone from WA who misses his mummy and his mates.

You should probably stay away from this guy then...