I see Richmond had 4 premiership players from this draft. I will take it.
I count 10 premiership players in the top 42, compared with 8 and 5 in the two years either side.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I see Richmond had 4 premiership players from this draft. I will take it.
Pretty good draft.I count 10 premiership players in the top 42, compared with 8 and 5 in the two years either side.
Pretty good draft.
Silly call. Defies logic call. Give them a go.This years Toots is on par with the 2006 Draft.
Light on for talent
A lot on the list from 2006 have played a lot of games , Would not rate a bad draft at all , maybe for super stars a little lighter than some years but not badThis years Toots is on par with the 2006 Draft.
Light on for talent
No-one rates Westhoff hey. He can look a bit lazy at times but he definitely makes the 25 here. 200+ games, 200+ goals, and still actually on an AFL list unlike some of the spuds here.B: Bachar Houli - Nathan Brown - James Frawley
HB: Eric McKenzie - Ben Reid - Shaun Grigg
C: David Armitage - Josh Kennedy - Bryce Gibbs
HF: Robert Gray - Tom Hawkins - Kurt Tippett
F: Shane Edwards - Jack Riewoldt - Lindsay Thomas
R: Todd Goldstein - Travis Boak - Joel Selwood
INT: Lachlan Hansen - David MacKay - Will Schofield - Matthew Leuenberger
EMG: Mitch Brown - Chris Dawes - Andrejs Everitt
Don't really see who he would replace besides the emergenciesNo-one rates Westhoff hey. He can look a bit lazy at times but he definitely makes the 25 here. 200+ games, 200+ goals, and still actually on an AFL list unlike some of the spuds here.
I count 10 premiership players in the top 42, compared with 8 and 5 in the two years either side.
Pretty good draft.
Don't really see who he would replace besides the emergencies
OVer Tippett/Edwards yeah, but Ben Reid and James Frawley both have AA jumpers and Frawley has been an elite defender for years now.I'd argue he's had a better individual career than Brown, Reid, Frawley, Tippett and Edwards from that first 18.
He comfortably has everyone on the bench and emergencies covered. The idea that someone like Dawes is ahead of him is laughable.
Don't really see who he would replace besides the emergencies
Everyone bar David Mackay's mum would agreeDavid Mackay. Not half the player Westhoff has been (and Westhoff hasnt been that good)
I would have Brown, Reid and Frawley all over him Tippett I would agree with and Edwards plays a different positionI'd argue he's had a better individual career than Brown, Reid, Frawley, Tippett and Edwards from that first 18.
He comfortably has everyone on the bench and emergencies covered. The idea that someone like Dawes is ahead of him is laughable.
Compare to 2005 draft:B: Bachar Houli - Nathan Brown - James Frawley
HB: Eric McKenzie - Ben Reid - Shaun Grigg
C: David Armitage - Josh Kennedy - Bryce Gibbs
HF: Robert Gray - Tom Hawkins - Kurt Tippett
F: Shane Edwards - Jack Riewoldt - Lindsay Thomas
R: Todd Goldstein - Travis Boak - Joel Selwood
INT: Lachlan Hansen - David MacKay - Will Schofield - Matthew Leuenberger
EMG: Mitch Brown - Chris Dawes - Andrejs Everitt
I would have Brown, Reid and Frawley all over him Tippett I would agree with and Edwards plays a different position