Preview Round 14, 2019: St.Kilda v Brisbane - Marvel Stadium, Saturday 22nd June, 4:35PM AEST

[VDS66]

4-5 clubs interested.

Wow he's that crap that 4-5 clubs are interested...

 

[Mikka84]

With the special almost “Father and Son” relationship between the coach and Armo, still a fair chance #20 runs out again this weekend.

Changes?

You're still old, that's your fault,
There's so much you have to know
Find the ball, settle down,
If you want you can retire
Look at me, I am Cho, but I'm happy

 

[The Enemy Within]

Parker stays in he's a good size at 190 & has pace, by the way he isn't 18 or 19 he's a mature aged players at 23 back him in unpredictable,explosive, x-factor he could be a match winner he is the type you do carry for those reasons he is still growing in what he can give.

 

[The Enemy Within]

Wow he's that crap that 4-5 clubs are interested...

That's why i think he's struggling too much on his mind with FA he is still in our best 22.

 

[Joffaboy]

Thanks for that , so you think Hind should stay at Sandy next week

Meant Young. Hind obviously played in Townsville

 

[st_trav_ofWA]

My preferred changes (I know there's zero chance of it happening)

Out: Newnes, Kent, Armitage
In: Hannebery, Paton, Carlisle


B: Marsh, Brown, McKenzie
HB: Savage, Wilkie, Battle
C: Hannebery, Ross, Billings
HF: Sinclair, Bruce, Paton
F: Parker, Carlisle, Membrey

Foll: Marshall, Gresham, Acres
Int: Dunstan, Clark, White, Hind

Leave Carlisle as a deep option for the entire game - we saw a limping Brandon White get the footy in dangerous positions just because he was forced to play deep. Carlisle could do serious damage in that role and would give us so much more structure going forward. Brown stays in to take one of Hipwood/McStay/Smith. For the love of god please just give Acres a full game in the middle. Mids to rotate through the forward line instead of persisting with small forwards who aren't up to it.

dont understand your hate for Kent ... bit like your hate for Clint Jones back in the day i find it puzzling .. there were certainly players not performing their role worst than Kent who should be on the block more

 

[bird_man]

David King thinks the Armitage move to half back was a master stroke and we have found a role for him back there.....

 

[The Punter]

I think Paton comes in for White, and Hannebury comes in for some unlucky schmuck who doesn't deserve to be dropped but isn't as good as Hannebury.

 

[CaptainRisky]

Meant Young. Hind obviously played in Townsville

No worries ,i just never know with you if your taking the P155 or being serious

 

[st_trav_ofWA]

the only think i would look at is what was up with Josh Bruce? Derm said on the telecast that in the week leading up to the game it was the best he had seen him move this year but come game time he looked like he is hobbled by something ... i know its not effort cause Bruce brings that in spades.. its not likely to be confidence cause i dont think Bruce has any doubts in his ability so it must be his body ... for a guy who is so very important to us i would hate to think we are playing him underdone and risking further injury just to keep a structure ...

 

[CaptainRisky]

If you go through the various threads, various people want :
White, Brown, Bruce, McKenzie , Parker, Sinclair , Armitage, Newnes, Clark, Kent, Dunstan and Acres dropped.

On Kent, why, when we were struggling to kick goals, would we drop someone who kicked 2?

Parker goes way before Kent does , Lets hope Parker doesnt turn out to be a flash in the pan

 

[CaptainRisky]

If you go through the various threads, various people want :
White, Brown, Bruce, McKenzie , Parker, Sinclair , Armitage, Newnes, Clark, Kent, Dunstan and Acres dropped.

On Kent, why, when we were struggling to kick goals, would we drop someone who kicked 2?

Sinclair could do with a kick in the butt as much as Newnes TBO , for a bloke that plays part mid - wing -half forward he doesnt get it enough

 

[t_94]

Sinclair could do with a kick in the butt as much as Newnes TBO , for a bloke that plays part mid - wing -half forward he doesnt get it enough

That centring kick in the last quarter on Saturday was so good. If he knew how to find the ball more often he'd be a great player.

 

[Pardon me]

One game it'll click for us and we'll look like back to back premiers...

 

[BigPowerForward]

Sinclair could do with a kick in the butt as much as Newnes TBO , for a bloke that plays part mid - wing -half forward he doesnt get it enough

Sinclair could do with a bit more consistency but I would give him a leave pass this week because IMO his possession in the last minute of the game was instrumental in us having a "W" against our name. Also we don't know what his role is from week to week. Some weeks his role might not allow him to get a lot of possessions.

 

[st_trav_ofWA]

Parker goes way before Kent does , Lets hope Parker doesnt turn out to be a flash in the pan

personally dropping him would be exactly that ... the guy looks to run on the positive reinforcement dropping him i reckon would do more harm than good long term... thats not to say he isnt above being dropped but i think you need to weigh up the pro's and cons of dropping him.. if there is a player beating down the door to take his spot then yeah , if he stops doing the non-negotiables of the team then yeah, if he is not bringing the pressure and the chase then yeah...
at the moment his goal output is poor , his turnover rate is high but therse no small forward that is killing it at Sandy, he does the team thing during games and is doing the right things at training, he also is chasing hard bringing second and third efforts so i wouldnt drop him

 

[FQFjt]

Wouldn't mind trialling Sinclair in the Steele run with role. Has the fitness, and it might teach him how to find the ball.

 

[st_trav_ofWA]

Sinclair could do with a bit more consistency but I would give him a leave pass this week because IMO his possession in the last minute of the game was instrumental in us having a "W" against our name. Also we don't know what his role is from week to week. Some weeks his role might not allow him to get a lot of possessions.

i agree i think Sinc is often tasked with roles that perhaps sacrifice his game for the sake of the team .. to us dumdum fans in the crowd we would look at it thinking hes not performing but internally he may be holding his role exactly as what is being asked of him ...
its an indication of where our team are at we dont always have the luxury of playing the guys in the roles that best suit them as we need them in the rolse to best suit the team

 

[Browny2Carlisle]

Wow he's that crap that 4-5 clubs are interested...

Well Weller got picked up by Richmond

 

[borderbarry]

Patton needs to be picked. Dont know why he was dropped, unless for injury.

 

[VDS66]

Well Weller got picked up by Richmond

Oh shut up...

 

[borderbarry]

When Carlisle eventually plays, move Battle back to the forward line. His 50metre+ goal on Saturday shows he still has a forwards instincts.

 

[BangersAndMash]

Apart from Kent and Membrey, none of our forwards look remotely like doing much on the scoreboard, so maybe time for Parker to have a run at Sandy, bring Steven in for Armo, but in a forward pocket role rather than onball, Paton in for Parker. Hind stays and whoever else for White if he's injured.

 

[AirWinmar]

Hopefully not....we don’t want another player close to goal who can’t kick goals!
( sorry Whitey, I know you were injured.)

To be fair i doubt he has had much goal kicking practice. Be spewing about that now

 

[BrutThough]

Wouldn't mind trialling Sinclair in the Steele run with role. Has the fitness, and it might teach him how to find the ball.

Probably too small to tag most midfielders but is big enough for Neale this week. Would be an interesting move from the coaches but I wouldn't mind seeing it.