List Mgmt. 2019 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals Thread

[Tesla Tenet]

And pick 4 could be the next Tambling. So what?

Or the next Gary Ablett Snr or Jnr.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[dosser]

First round picks Convo is interesting. Correct me if I'm wrong, but with Gary gone last year and mcveigh retiring the only genuine first rounders (excluding the academy blokes) on the list are florent and Hayward.

Bringing in a new era of successful first rounders? What a dream.

On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app

You can also add Ling, Jones, Buddy and Menzel.

 

[Membling]

For a fun look at draft, following player picked 4,5,6:

2012
Toumpas
Stringer
Macrae

2013
Bont
KK
Scharenburg

2014
Pickett
De goey
Marchback

2015
Oliver
Parish
Francis

2016
Ainsworth
Setterfield
SPS

2017
LDU
Cerra
Stephenson

2018
King
Rozee
King


Looking at that list, very few misses

 

[SSwans2011]

For a fun look at draft, following player picked 4,5,6:

2012
Toumpas
Stringer
Macrae

2013
Bont
KK
Scharenburg

2014
Pickett
De goey
Marchback

2015
Oliver
Parish
Francis

2016
Ainsworth
Setterfield
SPS

2017
LDU
Cerra
Stephenson

2018
King
Rozee
King


Looking at that list, very few misses

I'd take Daniher even with his injury troubles over most of those.

 

[Membling]

I'd take Daniher even with his injury troubles over most of those.

Off the back of the last two years, would take one player in every draft before him with exception for 2016 - can argue SPS though

 

[Dan87]

For a fun look at draft, following player picked 4,5,6:

2012
Toumpas
Stringer
Macrae

2013
Bont
KK
Scharenburg

2014
Pickett
De goey
Marchback

2015
Oliver
Parish
Francis

2016
Ainsworth
Setterfield
SPS

2017
LDU
Cerra
Stephenson

2018
King
Rozee
King


Looking at that list, very few misses

Really?

if I'm being a prick I count maybe 6 and some question marks still

 

[SSwans2011]

Off the back of the last two years, would take one player in every draft before him with exception for 2016 - can argue SPS though

No way I would take SPS. Particularly with his baggage. Talk of him leaving Port and not for a particularly lucrative return for them either.

Essentially we're a 1/3 chance of getting someone you'd take before Daniher? I'd rather just take Daniher than end up with a Toumpas, KK, Pickett or Scharenberg.

 

[Membling]

Really?

if I'm being a prick I count maybe 6-7

Looking at it Toumpas, sharenburg (injury) and pickett. Kk player to standard then concussions

No way I would take SPS. Particularly with his baggage. Talk of him leaving Port and not for a particularly lucrative return for them either.

Essentially we're a 1/3 chance of getting someone you'd take before Daniher? I'd rather just take Daniher than end up with a Toumpas, KK, Pickett or Scharenberg.

You are thinking SPP... SPS is carlton winger. Silky.

Yup. I would say we are maybe a 60/40 chance of getting Daniher right and maybe 25/75 chance of getting him to 2017 form again.

Most above would be at least best 22 in our line up.

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Don’t overplay your hand, Mick.

Different strokes for different folks Tick!

 

[SSwans2011]

Looking at it Toumpas, sharenburg (injury) and pickett. Kk player to standard then concussions


You are thinking SPP... SPS is carlton winger. Silky.

Yup. I would say we are maybe a 60/40 chance of getting Daniher right and maybe 25/75 chance of getting him to 2017 form again.

Most above would be at least best 22 in our line up.

Oops, my bad. SPS is a jet.

Difference is though, most of them would be best 22. Daniher would be a game-changer. Even in the ANZAC Day match this year he was close to the most important player on the ground.

 

[Membling]

Oops, my bad. SPS is a jet.

Difference is though, most of them would be best 22. Daniher would be a game-changer. Even in the ANZAC Day match this year he was close to the most important player on the ground.

If he was proven fit, agree. Rate him as a player

Just have a really, really off feeling about getting him in. No idea why, gut feel that his injuries have cooked him.

 

[Dan87]

Looking at it Toumpas, sharenburg (injury) and pickett. Kk player to standard then concussions

...Parish, Setterfield

Ainsworth, LDU still have a point to prove and King is an unknown

 

[Tedeski]

bottom 4 next year then

Bottom two.
Hopefully the AFL can get us a priority pick should we finish bottom so that we can recruit two gun mates 1 & 2 which should keep tgem at our club for a few years while we dig ourselves out of the hole we'll be in.

 

[Membling]

...Parish, Setterfield

Ainsworth, LDU still have a point to prove and King is an unknown

Parish has been solid for ess. 10-16 list player.
Setterfield had injury two years ago IIRC and tagged at Carlton. Was weird choice for him as tagger.

Flip side is Bont, De Goey, Rozee, Macrae, Oliver, Marchback Cerra, etc.

 

[Tedeski]

I love all of this and would give my left nut for it too pan out that way hope your man is on the money

You could trade your left nut for two lower right nuts with a Carlton supporter.

 

[Bandicoot]

For a fun look at draft, following player picked 4,5,6:

2012
Toumpas
Stringer
Macrae

2013
Bont
KK
Scharenburg

2014
Pickett
De goey
Marchback

2015
Oliver
Parish
Francis

2016
Ainsworth
Setterfield
SPS

2017
LDU
Cerra
Stephenson

2018
King
Rozee
King


Looking at that list, very few misses

I would have thought there were more misses than great choices.

 

[Bandicoot]

Bottom two.
Hopefully the AFL can get us a priority pick should we finish bottom so that we can recruit two gun mates 1 & 2 which should keep tgem at our club for a few years while we dig ourselves out of the hole we'll be in.

I love your optimism.

 

[Wolfgang West]

Your not making the pick so I wouldn't care that much. Pick 4 is fine to give up

Exactly. I trust the club enough to know where the list is at in regards to what we should be looking at with pick 4 and the worth of it. The status of your list from year to year does not dictate you have to keep taking pimply faced 65kg stick men who may not see an AFL Arena if there up to it for the best part of 3 years.

 

[Wolfgang West]

Morning wood for a second round?
Sign me up

So that's a golf club you use in the morning on the second 18 holes ? Or am I missing something ?

 

[Wolfgang West]

Or the next Gary Ablett Snr or Jnr.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

The club in its draft history of Top 10 picks have never picked an Ablett Snr or Jnr so its long odds against that pick 4 won't be either of those.

 

[Wolfgang West]

You could trade your left nut for two lower right nuts with a Carlton supporter.

North would take your left nut in a heartbeat and remunerate it with around 800-900k.

 

[The King!]

everyone Always offers the left night

is the right worth more

i get equal thrust from both,

 

[robbieando]

The club in its draft history of Top 10 picks have never picked an Ablett Snr or Jnr so its long odds against that pick 4 won't be either of those.

and in the history of the draft neither an Ablett Snr or Jr was picked in the Top 10 so trading our pick is fine if that is the goal as well

 

[tombomb]

I would have thought there were more misses than great choices.

you can read that list of players multiple ways.

Dalrymple's 3 selections have been Macrae, stringer, and bont.

Several of the misses are injury related.

Toumpas is the only straight up bust. And Pickett obviously has off field issues.

 

[Tedeski]

everyone Always offers the left night

is the right worth more

i get equal thrust from both,

This thread is nuts.