Autopsy 2022 Round 1 - GWS Giants vs Sydney Swans, Accor Stadium, Saturday 19th March, 5.10pm

[Hendo_21]

Ash on the wing

Wonder if at some point they look to flip Whitfield and Ash we know Whitfield can play there really well and seems like thats where Ash has been at his most consistent

 

[GWS Goose]

Hogan and Haynes in.
Brander and ?? Out.

Id like to see Preuss come in too.

Keefe

 

[GWS Goose]

I think if Haynes played tonight we win.

Or Hogan.
Brander was badly beaten when he shouldn't have, plus the easy misses.

 

[GWS Goose]

Cogs needs to be on the flank, Tim in the middle whoever needs a rest rotates with Cogs

Not sure about that.
I like Cogs in the middle.
XOH didn't get much but presented well and created space. A couple nice entries. The one right on half time to Brander was a ripper. Bad miss that one.
I think long term Ash on the wing works.

 

[Giant Pete]

Brander needs to show consistent form at the lower level in a key forward role.

 

[Land of the Giants]

Brander needs to show consistent form at the lower level in a key forward role.

If Hogan stays fit he'll probably get the chance to do just that.

 

[T4P]

Hey Giants mob, any intel on why Cumming had a quiet game (SC-speaking)? New role or just a quiet match?

 

[GWS Goose]

Brander needs to show consistent form at the lower level in a key forward role.

he was really poor on Saturday

 

[GWS Goose]

Hey Giants mob, any intel on why Cumming had a quiet game (SC-speaking)? New role or just a quiet match?

hard to tell. Perryman seemed to take a few kick ins than last year at the expense of Cumming, cant tell you why or if it will continue

 

[Colonial]

 

[Colonial]

 

[scaryness]

An outside rando's rankings after watching the replay for anyone who cares.
Everyone starts at 0 and only goes up (i.e. most players average out to a 5 and below that doesn't necessarily mean a "bad" game. Not everyone can be a stand out.)

Green 10/10
-
Himmelberg 7/10
Taranto 7/10
Kelly 7/10
Ward 7/10
Perryman 7/10
Flynn 6/10
Idun 6/10
Cumming 6/10
-
Hopper 5/10
Taylor 5/10
Davis 5/10
Coniglio 5/10
O'Halloran 4/10
Whitfield 4/10
Lloyd 4/10
Hill 4/10
Brander 4/10
-
Riccardi 3/10
de Boer 3/10
Keeffe 3/10
Ash 2/10

Davis would have been higher had he not given the ball away as much with some bad kicks and free kicks against inside 50.

 

[GWS Goose]

An outside rando's rankings after watching the replay for anyone who cares.
Everyone starts at 0 and only goes up (i.e. most players average out to a 5 and below that doesn't necessarily mean a "bad" game. Not everyone can be a stand out.)

Green 10/10
-
Himmelberg 7/10
Taranto 7/10
Kelly 7/10
Ward 7/10
Perryman 7/10
Flynn 6/10
Idun 6/10
Cumming 6/10
-
Hopper 5/10
Taylor 5/10
Davis 5/10
Coniglio 5/10
O'Halloran 4/10
Whitfield 4/10
Lloyd 4/10
Hill 4/10
Brander 4/10
-
Riccardi 3/10
de Boer 3/10
Keeffe 3/10
Ash 2/10

Davis would have been higher had he not given the ball away as much with some bad kicks and free kicks against inside 50.

I think harsh on Davis and Ash particuarly. I thought Cogs was good, plenty of it, worked hard, a couple really important plays out of the middle that ended in goals. I would also have been a little more generous on Llyod and XOH as well, but they aren't too far away.

I'd have been harsher on Brander and Flynn. Might have even dropped Taranto and Ward by a point, both had a few costly fumbles, but did good things too, so can see why others have rated highly

Despite seeing it slightly differently to me, this is a good effort and a good representation of the game.

 

[Ichabod Noodle]

An outside rando's rankings after watching the replay for anyone who cares.
Everyone starts at 0 and only goes up (i.e. most players average out to a 5 and below that doesn't necessarily mean a "bad" game. Not everyone can be a stand out.)

Green 10/10
-
Himmelberg 7/10
Taranto 7/10
Kelly 7/10
Ward 7/10
Perryman 7/10
Flynn 6/10
Idun 6/10
Cumming 6/10
-
Hopper 5/10
Taylor 5/10
Davis 5/10
Coniglio 5/10
O'Halloran 4/10
Whitfield 4/10
Lloyd 4/10
Hill 4/10
Brander 4/10
-
Riccardi 3/10
de Boer 3/10
Keeffe 3/10
Ash 2/10

Davis would have been higher had he not given the ball away as much with some bad kicks and free kicks against inside 50.

Davis 5/10 after wiping the floor with Buddy for the umpteenth time, automatically makes this a joke.


also, they obviously didn’t watch Cogs off the ball, because his game was better than a 5 as well.