A big thank you to Hawthorn and St Kilda
- Thread starter RPCB
- Start date
- Tagged users None
just so you know mate we collected hodge who after 2008 will be regarded as far better than judd. The only reason judd is said to be so good is because he has great players around him (kerr, cousins).
One last thing no matter how much you think that judd will do something great for your club you are wrong he wont change at that thing you call a club.
don't take that to badly.
its only the truth
One last thing no matter how much you think that judd will do something great for your club you are wrong he wont change at that thing you call a club.
don't take that to badly.
its only the truth
I would also like to thank the Hawks and the Saints.... what massive blunders. They missed a once in a generation player.
Fevalinko25
Rookie
Isnt the reason Judd left WCE the same reason he didnt consider Hawks
. Being a Blue blue was always going to happen regardless of wether he went to the Hawks..Kreuzer to Judd to FEVALINKO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RPCB
Community Leader
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #6
Isnt the reason Judd left WCE the same reason he didnt consider Hawks
Kreuzer to Judd to FEVALINKO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I dont know if he would've left the Hawks had they drafted him in 2001 as he already would've been in Melbourne.
- Oct 16, 2006
- 4,897
- 11,933
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Melb Victory, Storm, Juve
As good as Juddy is
i think that Hawthorn a quietly content with the hodge selection
St. Kilda on the other had may be a bit dissapointed, but being a mate of Bally through school and playing footy against Juddy at draft time Bally was clearly a better player.
Its unfortunate that Bally's body hasnt stood the test in time.
i think that Hawthorn a quietly content with the hodge selection
St. Kilda on the other had may be a bit dissapointed, but being a mate of Bally through school and playing footy against Juddy at draft time Bally was clearly a better player.
Its unfortunate that Bally's body hasnt stood the test in time.
HBF
Flying Scotsman
- Sep 24, 2002
- 156,177
- 101,042
- AFL Club
- Carlton
You must be pleased Phil. Judd joining the mighty Blues.
No offence but if u can find one commentator that thinks Hodge is in Judds class then I will tip my hat to you.
One is a very good player the other is a human god
Who exactly will be tapping the ball down to Judd over the next 3 years... You all say Kreuzer... he is only a kid and will not be a developed ruckman until atleast the end of 2009...
West Coast had Cox you will have Acklnad and Cloke next year....
yes you got Judd, but you also have the richest man in the country, who has and will continue to give your club the worst name in the game to buy you success...
you all forget, you have NO DEFENCE, NO RUCK and NO STAR KPP players- Waite does not count because he is far from a star
West Coast had Cox you will have Acklnad and Cloke next year....
yes you got Judd, but you also have the richest man in the country, who has and will continue to give your club the worst name in the game to buy you success...
you all forget, you have NO DEFENCE, NO RUCK and NO STAR KPP players- Waite does not count because he is far from a star
I think u will find WCE were a rabble until Judd got there!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
3-4 yrs later theyre winning flags!!!
'We are Carlton Fcuk the rest'!!!!!!!!!!!!! and u!!!!!!!
Flukey!
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 23, 2005
- 10,309
- 11,093
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Toronto BlueJays
As good as Juddy is
i think that Hawthorn a quietly content with the hodge selection
QUOTE]
Quietly is not the word.
Couldnt be happier
kreuzer-to-judd
Senior List
BrownDog#20
Cancelled
- Banned
- #15
Surely you are kidding here?
I rate hodge very highly but surely even you know that he is not in Judds class.
Judd takes the best tag every week and still finds the footy himself.
Hodge does not even get the best tag, mitchell does.
BrownDog#20
Cancelled
- Banned
- #16
Never heard of a bloke called Brendan Fevola.
Hawks have a very ordinary defence and no rucks as well so what is your point.
Look at the stats from last season and you will see Hawthorn were ranked in the top 5 in ruck partnerships and our defense was in the top 5 for least points scored against.
Fevola is a FF, and is a star. However, his attitude will always be questioned and until that improves will never be one of the games best players... who exactly do you have to play CHF and CHB in the coming 3-5 years???
Fevola is a FF, and is a star. However, his attitude will always be questioned and until that improves will never be one of the games best players... who exactly do you have to play CHF and CHB in the coming 3-5 years???
u dont understand the only reason judd is any good at all it because of kerr and cousins.
he is coming to you guys now and wont do a thing.
u dont understand the only reason judd is any good at all it because of kerr and cousins.
he is coming to you guys now and wont do a thing.
16 votes to rnd 8 this year (no cousins)
Sydney pre Plugger
1991 - 12th out of 15
1992 - wooden spoon
1993 - wooden spoon
1994 - wooden spoon
Sydney with Plugger
1995 - 12th (2 games out of the finals)
1996- Runners up
Lucky one superstar can't make a difference
1991 - 12th out of 15
1992 - wooden spoon
1993 - wooden spoon
1994 - wooden spoon
Sydney with Plugger
1995 - 12th (2 games out of the finals)
1996- Runners up
Lucky one superstar can't make a difference
Sydney pre Plugger
1991 - 12th out of 15
1992 - wooden spoon
1993 - wooden spoon
1994 - wooden spoon
Sydney with Plugger
1995 - 12th (2 games out of the finals)
1996- Runners up
Lucky one superstar can't make a difference
so you are saying you guys are relying on judd next year, give up son.
This whole thread is stupid.
Judd is awesome, any club would love to have him.
Hodge is awesome, any club would love to have him.
No one man can fix a club, but it's better to have the best players than not.
Judd is awesome, any club would love to have him.
Hodge is awesome, any club would love to have him.
No one man can fix a club, but it's better to have the best players than not.
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #23
Actually I think you should give up. You are on the wrong board and annoying me.
Cousins was out for the first half of the year and Kerr was in and out of the side with suspensions and injury and Judd still got votes without Kerr and cousins.
Similar threads
- Locked
