Preview Changes: R4 vs Brisbane

[mattymac]

In the squad, not the 22

So manslaughter, not murder?

 

[Cockwomble]

Would keep Tex,drop Matt, if Hartigan n Gibbs come in, we need to give the coach the flick.

 

[Murray2503]

Bench is M. Crouch, Gibbs, Poholke, Walker, Hartigan, Frampton, McAdam and Himmelberg

Out: Walker Gibbs Frampton Poholke
In: MCrouch Hartigan Mcadam Himmelberg

Very disappointing no Schoenberg, Davis, Gallucci. Lynch is cooked.

 

[mattymac]

How does Gibbs get named even on an extended bench.

Two wingers in Atkins and Seedsman out... who else on the bench fits those roles?

What a clownish outfit we have representing us.

 

[BACCS]

Wow! Don’t remember ever seeing Tex named on the bench on team selection night, I think he’s out. McAdam and Himmelberg have been pretty much stated as ins by Nicks during the week. Who are the other two to make the final cut?

 

[Dank Academy]

LOL that it’s considered ‘courageous’ at this club to name an underperforming player on the bench, rather than actually drop them.



On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Cockwomble]

Out: Walker Gibbs Frampton Poholke
In: MCrouch Hartigan Mcadam Himmelberg

Have you ever watched Hartigan play?

 

[BACCS]

How does Gibbs get named even on an extended bench.

Two wingers in Atkins and Seedsman out... who else on the bench fits those roles?

What a clownish outfit we have representing us.

Smith and Hamill are fine for those roles. I would think this is the most positive team we have seen in quite a while, there are some massive players getting dropped this week.

 

[Scorpus]

I'll reserve judgement until final call.

However, if Gibbs, Walker and Mrouch are all in, I think that'll just about do me for Nicks.

Our squad is so raw and unexposed to AFL football (18 players with less than 10 games) we can't realistically have 4 debutants each week.

Picking Gibbs would be unacceptable, but I feel if we can get McAdam in the side, drop two senior players (Seedsman and Walker), Atkins is also out, and can give Poholke/Himmelberg/Frampton another chance, that would be a good result.

Two out this week, another two next week, continue rolling in the changes and debutants. It's the best we can hope for

 

[Idontpullout]

Never thought I'd say this but hartigan needs to come in. Our defence is an absolute shit show and I think his inclusion may only mean a 50 point loss, instead of a 70 point loss.

 

[BACCS]

I'll reserve judgement until the 4 are cut but if it's McAdam and Gibbs for Seeds and Rat I'll be very disappointed.

Himmelberg is coming in too based on the Nicks dialogue this week. Tex never gets named on the bench, I would say that’s as good a indicator that he’s out barring any mishaps at the main training tomorrow.

 

[Murray2503]

Have you ever watched Hartigan play?

Yeah one of his biggest critics but would play McAsey forward and feel Butts not ready yet.

 

[Crowstar]

How Murphy keeps his spot after that diabolical display I'll never know but atleast there is some sort of accountability being shown.
In a perfect world Lynch and Murphy also would be out but as long as McAdam and Frampton come in I'll be happy.

 

[GreyCrow]

Hamill on the wing, I like it, I like it a lot.

I would like to see Sloane there

 

[Tex200]

I’d wager Gibbs, McAdam for Atkins and Seedsman

 

[Cockwomble]

Feel for tex even though he’s slow, it’s like cause n effect, cause Lairds kicking effect Tex not marking, just saying..

 

[BACCS]

Almost certain it’ll be:

Out: Tex, Seed, Atkins
In: Himmelberg, McAdam, Poholke

 

[Scorpus]

How Murphy keeps his spot after that diabolical display I'll never know but atleast there is some sort of accountability being shown.
In a perfect world Lynch and Murphy also would be out but as long as McAdam and Frampton come in I'll be happy.

Murphy is keeping Stengle's spot warm. Straight swap once he's back

 

[hey shorty]

How does Gibbs get named even on an extended bench.

Two wingers in Atkins and Seedsman out... who else on the bench fits those roles?

What a clownish outfit we have representing us.

I think he's been in amongst the best in the 2s, and given they've been belted it's probably a "well done" selection..... Which I don't like.

I reckon it's a good opportunity to push Lynch to a wing and McAdam slots straight into the forward line

 

[BACCS]

I’d wager Gibbs, McAdam for Atkins and Seedsman

Tex is out, he’s never named on the bench

 

[Anzacpaul]

Our squad is so raw and unexposed to AFL football (18 players with less than 10 games) we can't realistically have 4 debutants each week.

Picking Gibbs would be unacceptable, but I feel if we can get McAdam in the side, drop two senior players (Seedsman and Walker), Atkins is also out, and can give Poholke/Himmelberg/Frampton another chance, that would be a good result.

Two out this week, another two next week, continue rolling in the changes and debutants. It's the best we can hope for

Atkins is a forced change.

So if after the last 2 weeks effort, we lose 1 senior player by choice, and bring king of the plod squad Gibbs in to fill one of those positions, no thanks.

 

[Scorpus]

I’d wager Gibbs, McAdam for Atkins and Seedsman

I think you're close but Nicks has been speaking all week about getting marking power into the forward line. Would be surprised if one of the ruck/forwards doesn't make the cut.

Classic Crows would be Gibbs straight in

 

[Scorpus]

Atkins is a forced change.

So if after the last 2 weeks effort, we lose 1 senior player by choice, and bring king of the plod squad Gibbs in to fill one of those positions, no thanks.

Nah I'm saying we need to drop two players minimum (Seedsman, Walker) and not pick Gibbs for it to be acceptable

 

[hey shorty]

I think you're close but Nicks has been speaking all week about getting marking power into the forward line. Would be surprised if one of the ruck/forwards doesn't make the cut.

Classic Crows would be Gibbs straight in

And Harto for McAsey, citing "he's going to be a player for us, but he needs a break"

 

[mattymac]

Smith and Hamill are fine for those roles. I would think this is the most positive team we have seen in quite a while, there are some massive players getting dropped this week.

Seedsman and McHenry?