Prediction Changes: Round 4 Vs Adelaide Crows + prematch discussion.

[greatgatsby]

How the * can we go forward when we can't pick skilled players who are the future

Sturt might as well ask for a trade

Both he and Treacy would be crazy not to have their manager looking at this right now.

 

[Scham]

They recruit them. Just absolutely refuse to play them unless there is no other option and will have to play short.

Key word - quality. They clearly think BB is our next best after Schultz, Freddy, Walters and Switta so those not being played must be pretty ****ing useless (in their opinion). Freddy shows potential but Walters is our only A grade small forward on the list and he's 30 odd! They've ****ed it up. And why keep Sturt if he's no good?

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I think Walker is going to make a big difference, like Noddy, he runs fast and he runs towards goals, not sideways. That's why we always seem to play with those guys in the team, even if Walker ****s up a couple times too many.

We really just need it in there against Adelaide. Tabs looked like Plugga the half he played against them in the scratchie

 

[FreoRicci]

What’s the injury for Frederick ? One week lay-off and return for Gold Coast

 

[Outshined]

Eh, remains the same, win the clearances, win the game IMO

Basically this. Lose the midfield battle and it doesn't matter who we've got up front, Adelaide's forwards will annihilate us.

Hoping we get through this one and then we actually start to build a form line at Peel for others to mount their case. I'm over despairing about the conservative selection panel since that's evidently not changing any time soon. At least if Sturt, Erasmus, Treacy etc are consistently playing well it (might) get slightly harder to justify in: Banfield

I'm with Tony though - we really need Emmett to come good as well.

 

[Purple Jesus]

It's a pretty simple question - is Bailey Banfield

41

Bailey Banfield

Age

27

Ht

190cm

Wt

88kg

Pos.

D/F

Career

Season

Last 5

D

13.6

3star

K

7.2

3star

HB

6.5

4star

M

2.9

3star

T

3.9

5star

MG

175.5

3star

D

9.5

2star

K

5.3

2star

HB

4.3

3star

M

2.0

2star

T

2.8

4star

MG

109.5

2star

D

14.4

4star

K

7.6

3star

HB

6.8

5star

M

3.8

4star

T

3.2

5star

MG

200.4

4star

ever going to be a premiership forward?

Answer is just as simple: **** no.

 

[Dockeroo]

Overestimating Adelaides defence, it's really really bad down there. Amiss to kick 3, Tabs 2, the rest of the team to chip in

It would have to be pretty desperate. We looked toothless against a north defence without their best KPD and Freddie is a big loss with his pace.
Relying on the likes of Jaeger o meara to kick 3 or 4 to keep us in this one.
I see Adelaide kicking at least 80 points so we need to score probably 13-14 goals to win this game and I just do not trust those players to do that. We will need everything to go right.
List of potential goal scorers on a RELATIVELY good day for each player in 2023:
Switta - 1 goal
Schultz - 2 goals
Tabs - 2 goals
Amiss - 2 goals
Banfield - 1 goal
Walters - 2 goals

Maybe 1-2 more goals from the mids.
That’s an optimistic outlook to be honest, as a multi I would guess that it would be over $100 for all I have listed above.

 

[Fat Nyfe]

The entire mindset of the people running this club, from selections through to gameplan is zero-risk. In a sport that requires risk taking to win it all. It’s infuriating and non sensical.

Crap selections, once again.

 

[Deathly]

Banfield for Frederick.

Vanilla and scared.

 

[Purple Jesus]

Banfield for Frederick.

Vanilla and scared.

That about sums up JL's entire personality.

scratches back of neck

 

[FreoRicci]

Both he and Treacy would be crazy not to have their manager looking at this right now.

Think Treacy is gone tbh.

 

[Deathly]

If we lost both Treacy & Sturt in the off-season of a year where we don't make finals and have Banfield playing more games than both of them I think that'll be the thing in all these years of supporting this club where I'd finally go ****ing mental.

 

[Scham]

How many goals do we restrict the Crows to?

I like Walker and think he's going to be good but I'm not sharing the confidence that he's capable of shutting down Rankine. Pearce is struggling big time, the rest of the defence will do their jobs but we're going to have to dominate the midfield to win this one, not just win the midfield battle, but dominate!

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

It would have to be pretty desperate. We looked toothless against a north defence without their best KPD and Freddie is a big loss with his pace.
Relying on the likes of Jaeger o meara to kick 3 or 4 to keep us in this one.
I see Adelaide kicking at least 80 points so we need to score probably 13-14 goals to win this game and I just do not trust those players to do that. We will need everything to go right.
List of potential goal scorers on a RELATIVELY good day for each player in 2023:
Switta - 1 goal
Schultz - 2 goals
Tabs - 2 goals
Amiss - 2 goals
Banfield - 1 goal
Walters - 2 goals

Maybe 1-2 more goals from the mids.
That’s an optimistic outlook to be honest, as a multi I would guess that it would be over $100 for all I have listed above.

I'm not sure Adelaide are kicking at least 80 points but it's going to be really interesting to see what wins out, Adelaides attack, or our defence. Adealaide already have close to 100 points more scored against them compared to us. It will be interesting to see what wins out on the averages, their attack, or our defence.

I can promise everyone this, we will kick more goals than everyone thinks, purely because it's Adelaide. They are literally averaging over 100 points against where Richmond and GWS have literally scored half their total for the year against them...

 

[kingswood71]

So Banfield isnt a like for like, but he isnt that bad.....
2022, 8th for total goal assists, 5th for total marks inside 50, 5th for total tackles inside 50 and 6th for total goals....
Only played 13 full games.

 

[Perfect Purple]

Seems to me that the Selection Committee are chasing a repeat of last year’s game against Brisbane where Bailey kicked four goals. Those four were part of the 18 goals he kicked from eleven games played last year.

Just saying…

 

[Square Peg]

Banfield for Frederick.

Vanilla and scared.

I wish I could like this more. Scared is the perfect word. The first thought that enters his head is how can I stop the other team.

 

[Square Peg]

Eh, remains the same, win the clearances, win the game IMO

Nah I liked the old snuff better that realised Banfield is a crab.
That isn't half of it. You have to give the opposition something to think about, make them react to you. No AFL coach is reacting to Bailey Banfield, not one. Corbett, Sturt, Treacy - you need to react to that, each brings a different challenge. A blancmange is not a challenge

 

[freo1997]

The entire mindset of the people running this club, from selections through to gameplan is zero-risk. In a sport that requires risk taking to win it all. It’s infuriating and non sensical.

Crap selections, once again.

This. Good post.

 

[s_wd6]

I think Walker is going to make a big difference, like Noddy, he runs fast and he runs towards goals, not sideways. That's why we always seem to play with those guys in the team, even if Walker *s up a couple times too many.

We really just need it in there against Adelaide. Tabs looked like Plugga the half he played against them in the scratchie

He could make a big difference both good or bad. Hope to god he recaptures some of his pre-collingwood form last year.

 

[greatgatsby]

The team selection is that of a coach who is looking to keep his job, not build a premiership side.

 

[Deathly]

So Banfield isnt a like for like, but he isnt that bad.....

This is the thing and I want to make it clear. I don't hate Banfield the person or Banfield the selfish player - I just hate the ****ing process that he's rewarded from.

Banfield has always been a professional checkbox ticker for the MC and is perennial validator to JLos' weak mindset and this gets him picked over an untried Sturt after clearly needing to be dropped the week before? Just tiring and safe predictable bullshit.

 

[Kram]

After about the worst ever finals performance in a Freo jumper man Walker back in for a chance at redemption.

Banfield meh would prefer they went someone else but he's not as bad as people make out.

As awful as Henry was last week he was good in rd 1, fine with one more go before putting a line through him.

 

[FUS_RO_DAH]

These melts... Glorious.

King Bailey to kick 3 and deliver i50 bullets onto Amiss's thicc barrel chest

 

[muzzington]

Does Bailey even know what a backflip is!?