No no no no. You only want to count Grand Finals on the traditional last Saturday in September so of course this means you can only count the traditional Grand Final ground the G and traditional opponents. Therefore your win at the Gabba is void as are your soft kills against non traditional opponents. By your metrics the Tigers have not won a flag since 1980. The drought continues.
Who am I to argue with you SOTY? Just a mere male.
And so it is shown folks that Collingwood, who have not won a Grand Final for 32 years, nor for another 32 years prior to that, and have not won a Grand Final on the day it was scheduled for all 64 of those years, are NOT jealous of Richmond's famous recent dynasty 3 Grand Final victories in 4 seasons all delivered on time, on budget, without drug cheats or coke heads on our list, and save for the odd clip over the ear, without controversy. Because these Grand Final victories do not count it seems.
Harsh.
I think we'll count them anyway. So in the last 64 years it remains:
Grand Final victories delivered on time, on budget - Richmond 8, Collingwood nil.
Just so as not to upset my many Collingwood supporting ex-friends and my ex-nephew, Premierships in that period:
Richmond 8, Collingwood 2. Still looks quite a disparity.