Review Good bad and ugly vs the dees

[Carmo]

go

 

[Jcpdragonx]

good: top 6 pick

 

[nummy217]

Ugly:The green flogs giving Melbourne free goals

 

[Cap]

Good - we can't make finals, no excuse not to play the kids.

Bad - our game for patches, only rocking up for 1 qtr again.

Ugly - umpiring and my call it might get to 100.

 

[El Doederino]

Good: all the blokes we’ve been screaming for Nicks to play all season

Bad: all the blokes we’ve been screaming at why they keep getting pickes

Ugly: MilerA

 

[Scorpus]

6.13 at three quarter time

Bad kicking is bad football

 

[The Perfect Stranger]

Retire now Sloane.

 

[TRP1996]

Ugly: Rankine hammy.

 

[Crom1995]

Look what happens when we reward good SANFL form, Nankervis is going to be a very good player. Gutted about Rankine.

 

[Samcro24]

It’s a been well worn script over the years.

Play away, look like s**t for periods, play like millionaires for parts, either get in front early and choke, or come from behind and still fall short.

Sick of it.

 

[dogs105]

Good: Nank's touches, Schoey's second half, that we never gave up, Tex on the last. Murray.

Bad: Sloane, Hinge, Butts

Ugly: wasting opportunities

 

[The Perfect Stranger]

good: top 6 pick

The Bad.

No South Australian talent in the top 6.

 

[ABAB]

Good - we can't make finals, no excuse not to play the kids.

Bad - our game for patches, only rocking up for 1 qtr again.

Ugly - umpiring and my call it might get to 100.

Given all the set shot misses in the first 3 quarters, I wouldn't say we rocked up for a quarter but we played an exceptional quarter similarly against Collingwood and Carlton.

 

[pjcrows]

I thought we'd get smacked today. That game sums us up really - poor at the crunch (when it counts), pretty good when not expected to be/allowed to be, ultimately not good enough. Season ended this time two weeks ago - play the kids.

Good: Nankervis, Murray and Rankine. Schoey and Cook play the next 6 games.

Ugly: Within the space of a fortnight we've gone from a potential home final to potential Top 5 pick. Our squad has a very weak underbelly (yes, it lacks experience) but our current midfield simply cannot compete over four quarters at the crunch yet. We need to add to it, quickly - if we want to turn these growing "honourable losses" into 4 points.

Very ugly: Smith and Milera at key moments. Yikes

 

[Crow till I die]

Ugly: Rankine hammy.

Shocking timing with the showdown this week

 

[Crows I Am]

Nank looks a player. Not overawed at all playing his first game. Crazy that it has taken this long for him to debut!

 

[MrBarry]

Schoenbergs game demonstrates several things.

1. The coaches need to put more faith in the kids.

2. Our supporters need to stop writing young players off when they are given no oppurtunity.

 

[Crom1995]

The Bad.

No South Australian talent in the top 6.

Rachele wasn't South Australian either.

 

[FR0GGY]

Nank tick
Cook tick

Goal kicking x
Forward entries x
Umpiring x

 

[Scorpus]

Coaches: "We must play experience in the middle"

Schoenberg: "F*** that" - ends up leading disposal winner

Soligo: "F*** that" - 27 touches and a goal in the SANFL.

It's time

 

[The Perfect Stranger]

Good: Nank's touches, Schoey's second half, that we never gave up, Tex on the last. Murray.

Bad: Sloane, Hinge, Butts

Ugly: wasting opportunities

There were a few bads out there today but Sloanes fumble completely destroyed our momentum. Unacceptable from a 250 game "legend" at a crucial moment in the game.

Has to go but we know we will carry him to 300 games.

 

[Moonwatcher]

The good is if we start winning the games decided by less than a goal we are a top 6 team (I can't actually see that looking at our list).

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Although we lost and had shocking accuracy. We didn’t give up and fought to the death. That’s something to be proud of. We’ve lost by under a goal to Pies and Dees at the G.

 

[GROTTO]

Rankine most likely missing the rest of the season with his hamstring just is like a kick to the guts.

 

[Carmo]

I thought to myself at the start of the last, if we get to within 2 goals, the difference will be because of the umpires. When its 3 points and the umpiring was that bullshit it was definitely the umpires.

Good to see as play some reckless abandon attacking footy there in the last. Pity because we do that so rarely we make some howler mistakes at it but anyways.

Umpiring. F me. They throw, with double handed scoops all game and pedlar gets called for it in the last. The most simple open blatant obvious holding the balls, no whistle, we get two and theyre straight on to it. The call the block on sloane, then when there's some borderline blocks in front of melbs goal in the last no whistle. That 50m penalty with the late whistle and crouch played on straight away was extremely harsh.

Most of the team played ok. Yes, even Crouch, Sloane, Smith, Murphy and Fog and all the usual most hated on players. We did a pretty good job, it was a pretty good game, we show ourselves we can match it with these guys, especially if they don't get help from the umpires and we still get a superior draft pick.

Hopefully with Rankine's injury Newchurch gets a game. Like McAdam he has superior speed which is a very helpful attribute at the top level.