Pick 1 2023 Trade value - What would it take?

[peetoo]

There's a certain club in a premiership window that would find Darling pretty handy. Pick 6 coming back would value Jack at pick 20. Possibly overs at this point in his career but Darling would have got Melbourne over the line against Carlton.

NQR forward number 10 on that list

 

[Chadwiko]

Why are other clubs so interested in our drafting strategy?

An Eagles fan started this thread.

 

[Barrybran]

NQR forward number 10 on that list

Not sure what this means but Melbourne don't have a forward line

 

[eaglevision]

Melbourne

Pick 1, Darling (half salaryish) WC F2

West coast

6,11, JVR

Clayton called. He wants some of whatever you’re smoking.

 

[peetoo]

Not sure what this means but Melbourne don't have a forward line

Casey have lots

 

[Barrybran]

Casey have lots

How does that help Melbourne? They need AFL-quality forwards NOW.

 

[Mute Point]

Play 5 good games a year each
Is a bust
Headcase delisted by the end of this year

Just to confirm if I'm reading your post correctly, are you saying LDU is a bust?

 

[Wild Bill]

Not sure why there's North supporters being smug in here after their club's disastrous drafting over the past decade.

One draft, where they had picks 2 & 3 and charity from the AFL isn't really grounds for thinking your s**t doesn't stink.

Still need to get a hell of a lot right in this draft and the next couple to have any chance of contending

Also, nobody else actually cares how many picks North have in the top 20, it's irrelevant to other clubs unless they're trading with them.

The fellation over them is embarrassing.

Your mixing smug up with excitement to get 5 of the best 20 kids in. Give us something to look forward to.

WCE are is the exact same boat as us. Need to nail the next couple of drafts - especially before the Tassie team start to take all the early draft picks.

 

[eaglevision]

Your mixing smug up with excitement to get 5 of the best 20 kids in. Give us something to look forward to.

WCE are is the exact same boat as us. Need to nail the next couple of drafts - especially before the Tassie team start to take all the early draft picks.

We’ll both be fine. I wouldn’t want to be finishing bottom 2 in 2026-2028 though… 2026 mini draft and 2027 will be what we copped when GCS came in. Fortunately we nailed our picks.

 

[peetoo]

Your mixing smug up with excitement to get 5 of the best 20 kids in. Give us something to look forward to.

WCE are is the exact same boat as us. Need to nail the next couple of drafts - especially before the Tassie team start to take all the early draft picks.

Do the Tassie govt get to vote on which players they draft? It’s almost like that now

 

[Kangas_11]

Just to confirm if I'm reading your post correctly, are you saying LDU is a bust?

Nah, he's saying he only plays 5 good games a year, which is still pretty idiotic tbh.

 

[amazingjoshy]

[/QUOTE]

Hodge was from Fremantle’s Pick 1 but Hawthorn traded it for Croad and McPharlin and got 1,20,36 back. Which they drafted Mitchell with the number 36 pick in the 2001 draft.

7 was Collingwood’s pick, Hawthorn had 10 which they did a trade with the pies with Bo Nixon from the 2004 draft.

The pick 10 and 37 was from North who Hawthorn got for Nathan Thompson.

So apart from the 2,5 which were PP the rest were traded in.

My point was they are all high (top 10) picks

Where's the evidence that a bunch of late 1sts/early 2nds in one draft lead to a successful rebuild, which is what North has offered for 1?

Far better to take the top quality while you have the chance, which is why WC is asking for 2&3 or they'll keep it

 

[RanaNaved]

It's almost like some people don't understand that there will be drafts after this one, and that WC will probably be down the bottom for a while....may even get AFL assistance.....

There are going to be plenty of high draft picks for WC to play with over the next few years

 

[bzparkes]

Your mixing smug up with excitement to get 5 of the best 20 kids in. Give us something to look forward to.

Yeah, so do it in another thread.

Also, there's that one idiot who's been bragging about it for the last 3 pages.

WCE are is the exact same boat as us. Need to nail the next couple of drafts - especially before the Tassie team start to take all the early draft picks.

This is draft number 3, so yes, 2 more and then we should be looking at trades/FA to fill the last holes.

Zero need to split pick 1 this year though, after splitting our first rounder in the past 2 drafts.

 

[big_e]

Honestly, nothing would make me happier than seeing West Coast's first two picks in the draft being 1 and 23.

 

[My_Username]

Honestly, nothing would make me happier than seeing West Coast's first two picks in the draft being 1 and 23.

nothing would make you happier than that?

Seriously? Nothing?

You really need to get a life.

 

[bzparkes]

Honestly, nothing would make me happier than seeing West Coast's first two picks in the draft being 1 and 23.

Great, we're in agreement then.

 

[Wild Bill]

Yeah, so do it in another thread.

Also, there's that one idiot who's been bragging about it for the last 3 pages.



This is draft number 3, so yes, 2 more and then we should be looking at trades/FA to fill the last holes.

Zero need to split pick 1 this year though, after splitting our first rounder in the past 2 drafts.

Every club have nuffy posters - including the Eagles.

You also have the option on putting posters on ignore.

 

[LB2Snake]

Hodge was from Fremantle’s Pick 1 but Hawthorn traded it for Croad and McPharlin and got 1,20,36 back. Which they drafted Mitchell with the number 36 pick in the 2001 draft.

7 was Collingwood’s pick, Hawthorn had 10 which they did a trade with the pies with Bo Nixon from the 2004 draft.

The pick 10 and 37 was from North who Hawthorn got for Nathan Thompson.

So apart from the 2,5 which were PP the rest were traded in.

Not having a crack at you, but “apart from 2 and 5” is actually the funniest bit of that.
However the narrative on here is “North got given way too much”.
We would’ve been happy with just 2, let alone and 5.

 

[pantskyle]

Please do not use the West as a credible source.
You may as well cite a Facebook page.

 

[Ura]

View attachment 1830764

Great movie

 

[Barrybran]

It's almost like some people don't understand that there will be drafts after this one, and that WC will probably be down the bottom for a while....may even get AFL assistance.....

There are going to be plenty of high draft picks for WC to play with over the next few years

I'd like to think we'll only have one more top 5 pick beyond this year. 2025 should be top 10 but not top 5.

 

[Psicosis]

Rhino is a merely a PR extension of the WCE. Only thing certain about what he shares is that it is what WCE want the public to believe.

 

[Nutjob]

Username to content spot on

Explain how the Hawks dynasty in anyway backs up WC trading pick 1 for a bunch of late 1st rounders as a good idea

Was it Hodge at pick 1?

Or Roughead, Franklin and Lewis at 2,5 and 7

If North want to offer 2, 5 and 7 I'm pretty sure WC will take it

You didn’t reference early first rounders in your original post. You said a ‘volume of first rounders.’ So yeah, you’re wrong


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[bzparkes]

Rhino is a merely a PR extension of the WCE. Only thing certain about what he shares is that it is what WCE want the public to believe.

Darling isn't going to North in a deal for #1.