List Mgmt. The 2017 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals Thread (cont. in Part II)

[The King!]

If Reid is really that much in demand that clubs are willing to actually pay him 750-800k a season then i hope the club lets him go i would gladly take band 1 compo for Reid.

Could at least offer those clubs a chance to view the Tippett model forward they could have for the same price

 

[RUNVS]

If Reid is really that much in demand that clubs are willing to actually pay him 750-800k a season then i hope the club lets him go i would gladly take band 1 compo for Reid.

Reid would look so much better if he got reasonable service from the midfield and if Longmire's first instinct when the Swans are not in control was to move Reid to defence.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Reid would look so much better if he got reasonable service from the midfield and if Longmire's first instinct when the Swans are not in control was to move Reid to defence.

He would but is that going to happen at the Swans?

 

[miggs]

He would but is that going to happen at the Swans?

Doubt it

 

[Cadsky]

I've said it before and I'll say it again, Jones > Reid. As long as we sign Jones I'll be happy. Reid would be a bonus, but I don't want to get stuck in a bidding war for him. If he wants to stay in Sydney he needs to take a sensible offer. Otherwise take the compo and get a good young KPF. Might have to package our two first rounders together to trade up to a point we can get one though.

 

[Deccas]

If Reid is really that much in demand that clubs are willing to actually pay him 750-800k a season then i hope the club lets him go i would gladly take band 1 compo for Reid.

Ive been thinking along the same lines, but compo picks will change with the new salary cap as well. Might not get a first rounder for him, which is what id want to be honest if we were to let him go.

On CPH1607 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[mtooler]

Happy to let Reid go. Not concerned if we lose him.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Word.

In my view one of Tippet or Reid should depart. I'd prefer the former. I'd trade him for a late 2nd rounder and agree to pay half his tab. If not Reid could go for an early 2nd rounder.

 

[McRobie]

Word.

In my view one of Tippet or Reid should depart. I'd prefer the former. I'd trade him for a late 2nd rounder and agree to pay half his tab. If not Reid could go for an early 2nd rounder.

Yep, we have to get rid of him somehow,


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Cadsky]

Word.

In my view one of Tippet or Reid should depart. I'd prefer the former. I'd trade him for a late 2nd rounder and agree to pay half his tab. If not Reid could go for an early 2nd rounder.

I agree but there's no way we would get a second round pick. Other teams know we have a salary cap squeeze and would offer us nothing knowing we'd take it just to clear our books. We'd be very lucky to get a third round pick for Tippett considering his age/form/injuries. I'd put my money on a forth round pick personally.

 

[Zephiisdaman]

Love the way Allir Allir plays. Is he tradeable? If so what cost? Obviously on the outer with Horse and Leadership Group. Hard to see him staying?

 

[miggs]

Love the way Allir Allir plays. Is he tradeable? If so what cost? Obviously on the outer with Horse and Leadership Group. Hard to see him staying?

He will only be going to the eagles if and when he leaves

 

[Zephiisdaman]

He will only be going to the eagles if and when he leaves

Why?

 

[miggs]

Why?

Coz he isn't brave enough and his tunnel ball skills aren't up to the brave dogs standard

 

[Ticky009]

Coz he isn't brave enough and his tunnel ball skills aren't up to the brave dogs standard

Damn you, miggs. I was sipping a cup of coffee when I read this.

 

[Cadsky]

Do we have a crack at josh schache with the increase in salary cap? Sign Jones. Let Reid go as free agent and take the first round compo. Offer Tippett and the compo pick and take Schache?

 

[Zephiisdaman]

Coz he isn't brave enough and his tunnel ball skills aren't up to the brave dogs standard

No I meant why would he only got to the West? I think the way the umpiring is going this year that any team needs tunnel ballers, umpires paying dropping or throwing the ball is barely non-existent.

 

[Keyter]

Alir is not on the outer. He is improving his defence before returning.

 

[scaryness]

Do we have a crack at josh schache with the increase in salary cap? Sign Jones. Let Reid go as free agent and take the first round compo. Offer Tippett and the compo pick and take Schache?

Schache won't be leaving.

Anyhow, Tippett is of no use to Brisbane.
Literally zero.

They are mid rebuild not in the need of a top up in Tippett. They have Martin in the ruck who is great, and even if Schache leaves, they have Hipwood, Freeman, Close as well as potentially Brander with the #1 pick and Ballenden not soon after Brander in the draft from their academy.

 

[Cadsky]

Schache won't be leaving.

Anyhow, Tippett is of no use to Brisbane.
Literally zero.

They are mid rebuild not in the need of a top up in Tippett. They have Martin in the ruck who is great, and even if Schache leaves, they have Hipwood, Freeman, Close as well as potentially Brander with the #1 pick and Ballenden not soon after Brander in the draft from their academy.

Fair enough. My knowledge on Brisbane's list is pretty limited. I think whatever happens though we need to get a young KPF somehow. It may just be compo for Reid and trade both first round picks up far enough to get our hands on one in the draft.

 

[king rising]

Have heard reliably that you guys are very keen on Kade Kolodjashnij from GC

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Have heard reliably that you guys are very keen on Kade Kolodjashnij from GC

Please be true.

Would cost an arm and a leg though

 

[miggs]

swap for tippet

 

[Punts]

Sydneys botched trading

What's that about on AFL.com?

 

[Tuco]

Sydneys botched trading

What's that about on AFL.com?

Lyon slapping Cale Hooker for being a waste of 3.75m, Reid as being only worth 200k or 300k the way he's playing and Tippo being a dud.

The usual.