The real Real ladder of success

[superfraser]

This is an easy one guys.

It starts when you started watching footy. Everyones will be different.

Me being a Collingwood fan born in 1983, we've won zero premierships.

Of course, I was alive in 1990.

Hell, I was parked infront of the TV for the first bounce wearing my Collingwood knit with 35 of the back and sporting a fine mullett and missing a couple of teeth..

But by half time I was riding my bike out in the street.

Collingwood has lost 2 grandfinals.

Brisbane is my leader with 3.

Sure, when I was 13 I'd mouth off the Collingwood had won this and that and we were the best team... But reality is, none of that ment anything to me...

I'd happily trade in all of Collingwoods Premierships to win the 2008 Flag. I'd be 25 on the big day and I think anywhere between about 23-35 would be the ages that you would most enjoy a premiership win. ...of course, thats just speculaiton.

 

[magman]

http://afl.allthestats.com/statistics/alltime.php

Just adjust it to your start year

 

[Hawkk]

My ladder - Since 1994

1 Port Adel
2 Nth Melb/Kangaroos
3 West Coast
4 Bris Lions
5 Essendon
6 Geelong
7 Sydney
8 Adelaide
9 Bris Bears
10 Footscray/W Bulldogs
11 St Kilda
12 Carlton
13 Melbourne
14 Collingwood
15 Richmond
16 Hawthorn
17 Fremantle
18 Fitzroy

 

[tjpeg_44]

My Ladder - Since 1991

1. West Coast
2. Port Adelaide
3. Essendon
4. Geelong
5. Brisbane Lions
6. North Melbourne
7. Adelaide
8. Western Bulldogs
9. Hawthorn
10. St. Kilda
11. Sydney
12. Collingwood
13. Carlton
14. Melbourne
15. Richmond
16. Fremantle
17. Brisbane Bears
18. Fitzroy

 

[ManWithNoName]

Essendon
WC
Port
Brisbane
Geelong
North
Hawthorn
Adelaide
Collingwood
Melbourne
Dogs
Carlton
Sydney
Saints
Fremantle
Richmond
Bears
Fitzroy

Since 1988.

 

[Spook]

Since 1970

1 Hawthorn 8
2 Carlton 7
3 Nth Melb/Kangaroos 4
4 Essendon 4
5 West Coast 3
6 Richmond 3
7 Bris Lions 3
8 Adelaide 2
9 Sth Melb/Sydney 1
10 Geelong 1
11 Collingwood 1
12 Port Adel 1

 

[lions_den]

Since 96

Brisbane
North
Essendon
Port
Adelaide
WC
Sydney

 

[WaltzingMatera]

Since 96

That's not fair, we won two premierships just before '96.

 

[ManWithNoName]

Since 96

Brisbane
North
Essendon
Port
Adelaide
WC
Sydney

How'd you get that? I just did it since 1996 and got a completely different ladder

 

[Warwick]

How'd you get that? I just did it since 1996 and got a completely different ladder

Maybe because Brisbane won 3 premierships since 1996 and Essendon, West Coast, and Port all won 1 each.

Sounds like common sense to me.

 

[Warwick]

Me being a Collingwood fan born in 1983, we've won zero premierships.

Of course, I was alive in 1990.

I'm sorry. I have read this post about 10 times and I am still confused...

 

[Pie In Da Sky]

I'm sorry. I have read this post about 10 times and I am still confused...

Im with you champ! i have read 4 times already and cant seem to lay my finger on it!!!

top4 Since 2007

Geelong
Coll
Port
Kangas

yes i kno port played in the grand final... but think about it... did they really play?

 

[Chris who]

Heres a stupid fact
West Coast has played 8 more games than anyone else since its inception in 1987
498

 

[patsmith]

I'm sorry. I have read this post about 10 times and I am still confused...

Read the whole thing. Makes perfect sense.

 

[wally funk]

I'm sorry. I have read this post about 10 times and I am still confused...

probably saying that at such a young age, he/she didnt care so much about footy, and the pies haven't won a flag since he/she started actively supporting the club.

 

[Simon_Nesbit]

It's from when you took a real interest in the game (for most people I'm guessing somewhere between 6-12).

Mine, from 1986-2007 (based on Premierships, then Minor Premiership, Grand Final, Win %)

Hawthorn
West Coast
Brisbane Lions
Essendon
Carlton
Kangaroos
Adelaide
Port Adelaide
Geelong
Sydney
Collingwood

 

[Judd4PM]

Heres a stupid fact
West Coast has played 8 more games than anyone else since its inception in 1987
498

Thats a great stat, nothing stupid about that at all

 

[SirJimi05]

Thats a great stat, nothing stupid about that at all

True. It shows they have played in plenty of finals.

 

[cradle of filth]

In terms of amount of premierships won......

In the last 40 years?
1st Hawthorn

In the last 30 years?
1st Hawthorn

In the last 20 years?
1st Hawthorn + Brisbane

In the last 10 years?
1st Brisbane

Of all time?
well normally you would say Carlton but we all know they cheated so i'll have to say it's a tie between Essendon and Collingwood.

 

[Flukey!]

Here's mine. A a Hawk fan I have been spoilt..
This is from 1971 when I was a regular footy goer.
1 Hawthorn
2 West Coast
3 Port Adel
4 Carlton
5 Bris Lions
6 Essendon
7 Nth Melb/Kangaroos
8 Collingwood
9 Adelaide
10 Geelong
11 Richmond
12 Footscray/W Bulldogs
13 Sth Melb/Sydney
14 Melbourne
15 Fremantle
16 St Kilda
17 Fitzroy
18 Bris Bears

 

[Cuzz09]

In the last 20 years?
1st Hawthorn + Brisbane

West Coast have won as many as Brisbane in the last 20 years... 3 each.

 

[Cuzz09]

My first game of AFL was 1991.

My ladder of success is....

1 West Coast
2 Port Adel
3 Essendon
4 Geelong
5 Bris Lions
6 Nth Melb/Kangaroos
7 Adelaide
8 Footscray/W Bulldogs
9 Hawthorn
10 St Kilda
11 Sydney
12 Collingwood
13 Carlton
14 Melbourne
15 Richmond
16 Fremantle
17 Bris Bears
18 Fitzroy


Sweeeeet

he he he

 

[marcus]

Since 1970

1 Hawthorn 8
2 Carlton 7
3 Nth Melb/Kangaroos 4
4 Essendon 4
5 West Coast 3
6 Richmond 3
7 Bris Lions 3
8 Adelaide 2
9 Sth Melb/Sydney 1
10 Geelong 1
11 Collingwood 1
12 Port Adel 1

Port have won more than 1 senior premiership since 1970 mate.
Please see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_Adelaide_Football_Club for more info.

1977, 1979, 1980, 1981, 1988, 1989, 1990, 1992, 1994, 1995, 1996, 2004 = 12

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Port have won more than 1 senior premiership since 1970 mate.
Please see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_Adelaide_Football_Club for more info.

1977, 1979, 1980, 1981, 1988, 1989, 1990, 1992, 1994, 1995, 1996, 2004 = 12

True, he should have been more specific. In his defence he put it on the Australian Football League board and the VFL ties in with that. I think they should start one on the regional board.

For me:

Carlton 5
Hawthorn 5
Essendon 4
Brisbane 3
West Coast 3
Adelaide 2
North Melbourne 2
Geelong 1
Richmond 1
Sydney 1
Port 1
Collingwood 1

The rest 0

 

[marcus]

True, he should have been more specific. In his defence he put it on the Australian Football League board and the VFL ties in with that. I think they should start one on the regional board.

Thats one interpretation, another is to say my club currently plays in the AFL and has won those senior premierships in that time frame.

I'll stick with 12 thanks but its such a subjective argument that it really doesnt matter.