Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[manicpie]

They both play the same role for their teams . Are you making the rules now. Are you Fadge

You weren't very good at maths were you

 

[adammania9]

Cripps is averaging 0.07 possessions per game against Collingwood than Daicos is against Carlton.

Daicos is 2.5 years into his career.

Oh my.

'Domination'.

That’s crazy. For comparison, how many finals had Cripps played in at the same age, and how many premierships won?

 

[manicpie]

Cripps is averaging 0.07 possessions per game against Collingwood than Daicos is against Carlton.

Daicos is 2.5 years into his career.

Oh my.

'Domination'.

Just the fact that he's comparing a third year player to a 29yo says it all really

 

[Worm4]

Just the fact that he's comparing a third year player to a 20yo says it all really

So the new rules are that Cripps as carltons main midfielder can not be compared to collingwoods main midfielder because that player has only played 60 games. Righteo. I don't really care to be honest.
Was merely responding to the clown who said Cripps ONLY averages less than 10 kicks a game. Well, woopdephucendo ? He forgot the handballs how convenient.
How about this stat - Nick averages , oh wait, to have an average, you must register a particular stat. Oh well, can't bring that one up. Good night circle jerkers

 

[adammania9]

Collingwood shall be stripped of their premiership since Nick Daicos has never taken a contested mark

 

[manicpie]

View attachment 2024929

So the new rules are that Cripps as carltons main midfielder can not be compared to collingwoods main midfielder because that player has only played 60 games. Righteo. I don't really care to be honest.
Was merely responding to the clown who said Cripps ONLY averages less than 10 kicks a game. Well, woopdephucendo ? He forgot the handballs how convenient.
How about this stat - Nick averages , oh wait, to have an average, you must register a particular stat. Oh well, can't bring that one up. Good night circle jerkers

Cripps does average 10 kicks a game against us, so I don't see the issue. You can always do a handball comparison

 

[Chief]

Cripps is averaging 0.07 possessions per game against Collingwood than Daicos is against Carlton.

This doesn't make sense as a sentence.

 

[manicpie]

This doesn't make sense as a sentence.

I think you mean "that", unless you're referring to your own sentence

 

[Chief]

I think you mean "that", unless you're referring to your own sentence

Quite poseable.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

His abacus only dates back to 2001

I wondered where my abacus was.

Why is it that Carlton has been the least successful Melbourne based Club this Century?

It is an indictment when Saints and nmfc fans point and laugh at Pratt Park.

 

[manicpie]

Quite poseable.

Trust me, I did year 10 twice

 

[manicpie]

I wondered where my abacus was.

Why is it that Carlton has been the least successful Melbourne based Club this Century?

It is an indictment when Saints and nmfc fans point and laugh at Pratt Park.

I think st.kilda made 3 grand finals in that time

 

[CarmenSandiego]

I really don't need to answer that, it's very obvious. Maybe the fact that Cripps has played 8 of those years when the GOAT wasn't even in the system

Your mate drew comparisons with Pendlebury who’s played 8 years more than Cripps.

 

[manicpie]

Your mate drew comparisons with Pendlebury who’s played 8 years more than Cripps.

Good point

 

[Arr0w]

I wondered where my abacus was.

Why is it that Carlton has been the least successful Melbourne based Club this Century?

It is an indictment when Saints and nmfc fans point and laugh at Pratt Park.

Some clubs need to be relocated, financially and list assisted to have any form of success

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Some clubs need to be relocated, financially and list assisted to have any form of success

So when are the Blues moving to Nauru as part of internationalisation of the great game.

 

[Fadge]

Your mate drew comparisons with Pendlebury who’s played 8 years more than Cripps.

Good point

Ah, no.

It's not a good point at all.

My comment about Pendlebury was a direct response to the comment that 'Cripps has been more dominant than any other player against Collingwood in recent times'.

Pendlebury, as the first Collingwood player I thought of to check out, averages MORE Brownlow votes per game against Carlton than Cripps does against Collingwood.

The averages include both players' early years but I suggest Pendlebury's stats as a 32 to 36 year old haven't done a lot for his averages.

And I'm not even suggesting Pendlebury has been particularly 'dominant' against Carlton, let alone 'more dominant than any other player against Carlton in recent times'.

Wowee.

 

[Fadge]

So when are the Blues moving to Nauru as part of internationalisation of the great game.

Not soon enough.

 

[Arr0w]

So when are the Blues moving to Nauru as part of internationalisation of the great game.

Too big of a club, we don't have to lose our identity after not winning a flag post WWII

 

[doppleganger]

Huh ? He averages more disposals against Collingwood, than golden boy does against Carlton.
What type of stat are you trying to manipulate here ? Are you saying that handballing is a useless possession now. Oh dear.....

Manipulation, what manipulation?

The mighty Crippa aint even avg 10 kicks a game against us, and has won just 3 of his 15 games against The Pies.

You are the clown who is saying Crippa dominates Collingwood, all based on a single game where Carlton lost and Crippa was helpless as the Baggers gave up a big lead and lost again.

Absolutely hilarious.

 

[Thrawn]

This thread is getting boring.

Colonwood. Haha. Gottem.

 

[Arr0w]

Manipulation, what manipulation?

The mighty Crippa aint even avg 10 kicks a game against us, and has won just 3 of his 15 games against The Pies.

You are the clown who is saying Crippa dominates Collingwood, all based on a single game where Carlton lost and Crippa was helpless as the Baggers gave up a big lead and lost again.

Absolutely hilarious.

Cripps has averaged 9.6 kicks over his career

Tom Mitchell averaged 9.6 kicks over 26 games last year.

You really do clutch at straws thinking you are some guru analyst and then calling others clown

 

[Fadge]

Manipulation, what manipulation?

The mighty Crippa aint even avg 10 kicks a game against us, and has won just 3 of his 15 games against The Pies.

You are the clown who is saying Crippa dominates Collingwood, all based on a single game where Carlton lost and Crippa was helpless as the Baggers gave up a big lead and lost again.

Absolutely hilarious.

Yeah, Dopple....

Why would you bring up Tom Mitchell?

Oh that's right... you didn't....

I've never seen a supporter group tie themselves in so many knots!

 

[CarmenSandiego]

Ah, no.

It's not a good point at all.

My comment about Pendlebury was a direct response to the comment that 'Cripps has been more dominant than any other player against Collingwood in recent times'.

Pendlebury, as the first Collingwood player I thought of to check out, averages MORE Brownlow votes per game against Carlton than Cripps does against Collingwood.

The averages include both players' early years but I suggest Pendlebury's stats as a 32 to 36 year old haven't done a lot for his averages.

And I'm not even suggesting Pendlebury has been particularly 'dominant' against Carlton, let alone 'more dominant than any other player against Carlton in recent times'.

Wowee.

Shut up mate nobody cares.

 

[doppleganger]

Yeah, Dopple....

Why would you bring up Tom Mitchell?

Oh that's right... you didn't....

I've never seen a supporter group tie themselves in so many knots!

Poor old Bagger embarassed himself.

Based his Crippa dominance claim.off one single game that Crippa couldn't even win.

Probably time for old Wormy to bring up the 1970s.

Rinse and repeat.