List Mgmt. 2016 Trade/Free Agency Part 2

[TigerImposter]

http://footyprophet.com/market-value-dion-prestia/

 

[Sassafras]

http://footyprophet.com/market-value-dion-prestia/

The '2nd possible trade' is a bit of a gamble.

 

[TigerImposter]

The '2nd possible trade' is a bit of a gamble.

Yep wouldn't go down that path. The third is probably the best of the lot, but still not certain if I would commit to any.
There still appears to be some risk with him.
I don't watch too many Suns games so I don't know too much about him. This is one for the experts.
If I had to take a punt I would walk away unless a package like Houli or Grigg packaged with Conca came up.
That's just me.
Based on the risks mentioned and cost over a long deal I get heart murmurs.
I just hope the club does their due diligence on him

 

[GoTigers2015]

Is Eddy McGuire like the Sam Allardyce of the AFL? Seems likely that extra incentives were offered to get players to nominate the Pies last trade period. Especially on the Aish and Treloar deals.

 

[captain blood 17]

Literally laughed out loud.

I wasn't sure who'd actually get the gag


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[GoTigers2015]

Is Eddy McGuire like the Sam Allardyce of the AFL? Seems likely that extra incentives were offered to get players to nominate the Pies last trade period. Especially on the Aish and Treloar deals.

Treloars manager

 

[GoTigers2015]

http://footyprophet.com/market-value-dion-prestia/

Prestia worth 7-11, Mitchell worth 17-23. Seems the value get inflated when are linked to a player. No way we should pay that value for Prestia.

 

[THE THIN MAN]

But the Power will not move - as speculated - on Western Bulldogs free-agent ruckman Will Minson in a homecoming move to Adelaide. The out-of-favour Bulldog is commanding interest from several clubs - in particular Brisbane, Gold Coast, Richmond and North Melbourne - but Port Adelaide insists the Norwood draftee is “not on our radar”

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...t/news-story/eeafb55359e1e1d06c9594837f8f9c2e


Great to see the brainiacs that are currently responsible for our list troubles, are chasing Will Minson.

The same short term thinking that now requires a list rebuild is being used again.

Will the cycle of whoa never end......

 

[TheProwler]

Agree totally.
The idea of trading future selections I don't like fullstop.

Trading future picks when you are in bottom six of ladder is a dangerous game. You are really backing your team to improve markedly for that. With the massive holes in our list on most lines that is a gutsy gamble to take. Imagine if Freo had given their 2016 first selection to GWS for McCarthy. Would have seemed a good deal last year but not so much this.

 

[GoTigers2015]

But the Power will not move - as speculated - on Western Bulldogs free-agent ruckman Will Minson in a homecoming move to Adelaide. The out-of-favour Bulldog is commanding interest from several clubs - in particular Brisbane, Gold Coast, Richmond and North Melbourne - but Port Adelaide insists the Norwood draftee is “not on our radar”

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...t/news-story/eeafb55359e1e1d06c9594837f8f9c2e


Great to see the brainiacs that are currently responsible for our list troubles, are chasing Will Minson.

The same short term thinking that now requires a list rebuild is being used again.

Will the cycle of whoa never end......

Must be true if in the HUN...

 

[GoTigers2015]

Trading future picks when you are in bottom six of ladder is a dangerous game. You are really backing your team to improve markedly for that. With the massive holes in our list on most lines that is a gutsy gamble to take. Imagine if Freo had given their 2016 first selection to GWS for McCarthy. Would have seemed a good deal last year but not so much this.

Got a got a good deal from Lollingwood for Treloar. Got pick 7 off them plus last years first.

 

[Equus]

But the Power will not move - as speculated - on Western Bulldogs free-agent ruckman Will Minson in a homecoming move to Adelaide. The out-of-favour Bulldog is commanding interest from several clubs - in particular Brisbane, Gold Coast, Richmond and North Melbourne - but Port Adelaide insists the Norwood draftee is “not on our radar”

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...t/news-story/eeafb55359e1e1d06c9594837f8f9c2e


Great to see the brainiacs that are currently responsible for our list troubles, are chasing Will Minson.

The same short term thinking that now requires a list rebuild is being used again.

Will the cycle of whoa never end......

The cycle of Whoa ends when you stop reading that s**t...

 

[TheProwler]

Welcome to Richmond, John Butcher.

 

[TheProwler]

One of those afl trade Facebook pages are saying we have offered Jack Darling 550k for 5

Yeah but it would be the trade cost that would hurt most. Won't get from WCE without a good trade. No from me.

 

[TheProwler]

Got a got a good deal from Lollingwood for Treloar. Got pick 7 off them plus last years first.

Yep exhibit A there. If pies finished top four even six then they win/break even there but to stay the same = reamed up the rearo

 

[tigs2010]

Yep exhibit A there. If pies finished top four even six then they win/break even there but to stay the same = reamed up the rearo

Just the way Eddie likes it

 

[Ned_Flanders]

But the Power will not move - as speculated - on Western Bulldogs free-agent ruckman Will Minson in a homecoming move to Adelaide. The out-of-favour Bulldog is commanding interest from several clubs - in particular Brisbane, Gold Coast, Richmond and North Melbourne - but Port Adelaide insists the Norwood draftee is “not on our radar”

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...t/news-story/eeafb55359e1e1d06c9594837f8f9c2e


Great to see the brainiacs that are currently responsible for our list troubles, are chasing Will Minson.

The same short term thinking that now requires a list rebuild is being used again.

Will the cycle of whoa never end......

Why so angry?

You do realise most the ahit being reported is leaked from managers trying to talk up their players?

Also "showing interest" could be nothing more than agreeing to have a chat with the manager or player

We really over react to every hun thought bubble

 

[Charlie Pannam]

We're looking at Will Minson according to HS

If we are seriously considering Minson we are fools we have an equal on the list at the moment - Maric.
Both are cooked imo, but if we are getting rid of Ivan then his replacement needs to be somebody with upside not a plodder.

 

[Catscratch]

Ohh gee I dunno.

Exactly, hasn't achieved anything and never will.

 

[partycorolla]

If we are seriously considering Minson we are fools we have an equal on the list at the moment - Maric.
Both are cooked imo, but if we are getting rid of Ivan then his replacement needs to be somebody with upside not a plodder.

If the HUN say we are looking at Minson then we are 95% certain not to be looking at him. Just throwing our name in the mix at the request of his manager to try and drum up some interest. Happens every off-season. Don't be sucked in by it.

 

[cairo tiger]

Not minson no f way! Do we have any idea

 

[turtle27]

Not minson no f way! Do we have any idea

Cairo, read below.

Why so angry?

You do realise most the ahit being reported is leaked from managers trying to talk up their players?

Also "showing interest" could be nothing more than agreeing to have a chat with the manager or player

We really over react to every hun thought bubble

 

[abcxyz]

If we are seriously considering Minson we are fools we have an equal on the list at the moment - Maric.
Both are cooked imo, but if we are getting rid of Ivan then his replacement needs to be somebody with upside not a plodder.

Having watched Minsons performances in the VFL over the last few weeks it is obvious he is cooked. Too slow, not great around the ground anymore, looks like he is running around trying to hurt younger better players that he cannot keep up with.

Agree that he isn't an upgrade on Ivan. Not to mention how much more Ivan brings to the club in a mentoring capacity.

Minson could run a language school for the VFL. He has to be the smartest flog playing the game today.

 

[Charlie Pannam]

Having watched Minsons performances in the VFL over the last few weeks it is obvious he is cooked. Too slow, not great around the ground anymore, looks like he is running around trying to hurt younger better players that he cannot keep up with.

Agree that he isn't an upgrade on Ivan. Not to mention how much more Ivan brings to the club in a mentoring capacity.

Minson could run a language school for the VFL. He has to be the smartest flog playing the game today.

Pretty sure Ivan Maric and Soldo toweled him up in the VFL towards the end of the year.
Gotta be better options in the State leagues around the country than Minson.

 

[TigerImposter]

But the Power will not move - as speculated - on Western Bulldogs free-agent ruckman Will Minson in a homecoming move to Adelaide. The out-of-favour Bulldog is commanding interest from several clubs - in particular Brisbane, Gold Coast, Richmond and North Melbourne - but Port Adelaide insists the Norwood draftee is “not on our radar”

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...t/news-story/eeafb55359e1e1d06c9594837f8f9c2e


Great to see the brainiacs that are currently responsible for our list troubles, are chasing Will Minson.

The same short term thinking that now requires a list rebuild is being used again.

Will the cycle of whoa never end......

I predicted this in another thread. Omg.