Kilroy
Hall of Famer
- Nov 10, 2013
- 30,388
- 83,055
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
When you're going through HAL, keep going ?... HAL IS BACK
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 11
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
When you're going through HAL, keep going ?... HAL IS BACK
Development IMHO isn't the issue. Paddy is definitely AFL quality, so he needs to be ******* playing there, not at Sandy.Okay. [Insert KPF here] took time to develop.
He's not AFL quality. What makes you say that.Development IMHO isn't the issue. Paddy is definitely AFL quality, so he needs to be ******* playing there, not at Sandy.
Every game at Sandy is stalling his development.
Think you just answered your own question. Why the heck did we select him with pick 1 if he isn't AFL quality?He's not AFL quality. What makes you say that.
I don't think it matters where he was selected. Not all #1 picks have turned out to be stars. I think he has the potential to be a star, but he hasn't shown it yet. So for now I think the VFL is where he belongs, until he can show that he deserves to play in the seniors.Think you just answered your own question. Why the **** did we select him with pick 1 if he isn't AFL quality?
Ask trout. He picked him.Think you just answered your own question. Why the **** did we select him with pick 1 if he isn't AFL quality?
I'm the opposite. He deserves to play & needs to play this year to get 'AFL fit' & up to the speed of the game so he's ready to go bang next year.I don't think it matters where he was selected. Not all #1 picks have turned out to be stars. I think he has the potential to be a star, but he hasn't shown it yet. So for now I think the VFL is where he belongs, until he can show that he deserves to play in the seniors.
Yep . Knees , hammies ******* most s**t can be fixed but I don't know if a solution to avoiding concussion when a jarring bump happens . Will only get concussed easier and easier each time . Just ask Dean Kemp .I'm the opposite. He deserves to play & needs to play this year to get 'AFL fit' & up to the speed of the game so he's ready to go bang next year.
Don't blame him if he's seriously considering a move though. His manager is obviously fishing for a bite.
Depending on the potential return for him, if he wanted out, I'd definitely consider trading due to his health issues
If you can afford a Ferrari, you can drive it wherever the **** you like.
That a thread can be started about trading a future KPF who has hardly been able to get on the park in his first few years says more about the stupidity of people on here than anything else.
Really ******* pathetic.
Do you think we should be gifting games to players?I'm the opposite. He deserves to play & needs to play this year to get 'AFL fit' & up to the speed of the game so he's ready to go bang next year.
Don't blame him if he's seriously considering a move though. His manager is obviously fishing for a bite.
Depending on the potential return for him, if he wanted out, I'd definitely consider trading due to his health issues
Every time we have a new item thread my heart sinks as they seem to always be designed to embarrass ourselves.
Whether it's scab rippers like this one, or the big noting ourselves ones that signal disaster - hats off to the physios, we can make the 8, this is the year.....
There isn't a sainter out there who didn't have some negative thoughts on paddys future when they heard of his Ko today but why do we have to stick the knife in on here. Let's not make robbo's job easier for him eh.
I think some posters care more about their faceless personas on this forum than they do about the club
And Jack Watts was a spud.Similar things were said about Scott Gumbleton.
And Jack Watts was a spud.
And how long did Watts take and how many times did he get dropped?Well Jack Watts has turned out much better than Gumbleton....
Gumbleton was a pick 2 key fwd. Got injured a lot. Went to Freo. Got injured. That was that.
No at all, but how are you supposed to get a feel for the level when you only play 1-2 games in a row at best? Should pick him & stick with him for at least 5-6 weeks & give him a decent chance.Do you think we should be gifting games to players?
Watts is now above average at best . They would be spewing he turned out that way .And how long did Watts take and how many times did he get dropped?
No at all, but how are you supposed to get a feel for the level when you only play 1-2 games in a row at best? Should pick him & stick with him for at least 5-6 weeks & give him a decent chance.
Took a long time.And how long did Watts take and how many times did he get dropped?