The King!
Chosen One
Whichever one never won coach of the year surely
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Longmire having only 2.2% in that poll right now shows how overrated he is.
Added Franklin and Tippett to a premiership team and has achieved nothing since. Inherited a team with bloods culture and an ability to punch above their weight talent wise and perform on the big stage and unintentionally installed Bondi culture with underachievement relative to list talent and crapping themselves on the big stage.
Bloods culture = JPK type player
Bondi culture = Luke Parker
Longmire was a large part of that club changing resulting in having too many Luke Parker types and not enough JPK's.
I went for something different and picked Woosha. He had an absolutely elite list and won a flag by one point against a far inferior list.
Geelongs bottom 10 is a hell of a lot better then richmonds and its top ten is better too. Scott is a shite coach.I actually think Chris Scott is a decent coach, but doesn't have enough talent.
Dangerfield, Selwood then a gap to Duncan and a further gap to Hawkins. Take a look at his bottom 10 now, and he's done very well to get them to multiple prelims.
I went for something different and picked Woosha. He had an absolutely elite list and won a flag by one point against a far inferior list.
Longmire having only 2.2% in that poll right now shows how overrated he is.
Added Franklin and Tippett to a premiership team and has achieved nothing since. Inherited a team with bloods culture and an ability to punch above their weight talent wise and perform on the big stage and unintentionally installed Bondi culture with underachievement relative to list talent and crapping themselves on the big stage.
Bloods culture = JPK type player
Bondi culture = Luke Parker
Longmire was a large part of that club changing resulting in having too many Luke Parker types and not enough JPK's.
Elite list lol? More like an elite midfield which carried a whole heap of average players.I went for something different and picked Woosha. He had an absolutely elite list and won a flag by one point against a far inferior list.
Yeh this. The forward line especially, thay midfield + ruck combo was insane though.Elite list lol? More like an elite midfield which carried a whole heap of average players.
Elite list lol? More like an elite midfield which carried a whole heap of average players.
As ordinary as your forward line was, Lynch kicked 60-odd goals in the flag year, and aside from Cox, Cousins, Judd and Kerr, the side also contained Glass, Wirrpanda, Waters and Fletcher who were all AA players.
Braun, Embley, Chick, Banfield, Adam Selwood - these blokes weren’t mugs either.
8 All australians, possibly the best ruck/midfield combination of all time, half a dozen good to very good other players..... think you’re underselling the quality in that line up.
Maybe at Simonds, but a Premiership is won at the MCGGeelongs bottom 10 is a hell of a lot better then richmonds and its top ten is better too. Scott is a shite coach.
I do not necessarily think Longmire is the worst. Just that he is extremely overrated looking at the poll results. There does not feel like much difference between him and Chris Scott both with one crowning achievement. Collingwood 2011 were an extremely strong side and Scott punched above his weight to beat them despite the strength of Geelog just like Longmire used his cattle well to deliver above well expectations in 2012.I'm not a Longmire defender but in 2012 when he did win I think he had changed the team style a lot from Roos and engineered the success
Since then it's a different story
On behalf of the AFC I would like to apologise to big footy for not putting a lid on this garbage by defeating Richmond on Saturday.
Tigers fans - did scott need clarko's advice ? No he did not. Horse ? Beveridge ?
So who is the worst premiership coach now ? Dimma.
Geelongs bottom 10 is a hell of a lot better then richmonds and its top ten is better too. Scott is a shite coach.
Richmond fans are getting creative with just how many "is X (Richmond team/person) the best ever?"
You guys can win a premiership and enjoy it without having to be the best of all time in every area.
You already had the AFL gift Dusty a clean sweep (all deserved except norm smith) which gives him the best individual season ever but that's it.
Well take away the Freo goal after the siren and we finish top. You can add in the Giants beating the Tigers in the last 30 seconds and also the Sydney game if you like in which they got us in the lsat 2 minutes after we dominated all day. We probably should have finished on top anyway and were the best team all year. We really only put in 2 bad games for the year.
Once finals hit six goals was as close as the the other top three teams could get to us. Richmond were the best team in 2017 and you will just have to learn to live with it. RICHMOND PREMIERS 2017.
Hardwick by so far it's not funny.
The thing about Chris Scott is, whiles there's no question his teams have underachieved in finals since 2012, I think that Geelong has consistently produced above preseason expectations in his time. I'd say that when you consider that aspect, he's only really underperformed in 2012 and 2015. We were expected to make up the numbers in the eight in 2011/16/17, to fall away in 2013. Given the mass departures that we had at the end of 2013, I would say that finishing fifth (following a straight sets finals exit) was probably about par from what was expected of the team in preseason. I'd rate his seasons as follows, from where I remember us being expected to finish at the start of the year:
I'd downgrade his 2016 and 2017 (and to a lesser extent, 2013) slightly because, while top four is nothing to sneeze at for most clubs, premierships were there for the taking in each of those years and despite having flawed teams Geelong failed to seize that golden opportunity (where other flawed teams, arguably more flawed teams, were able to capitalise).
- 2011: 10/10
- 2012: 5/10
- 2013: 8/10
- 2014: 6/10
- 2015: 3/10
- 2016: 8/10
- 2017: 7.5/10
Does Chris Scott actually get to decide the current Cats drafting/trading policy?
I'm sorry beating up on bottom 10 opponents all year (doubling up 3 of the bottom 5) doesn't make you the best all year.
Celebrate your premiership by all means but at least acknowledge your soft draw meant that a minor premiership, had it happened, would not have been a fair reflection