Traded Josh Schache [traded to Bulldogs]

[mad_doggy911]

He bailed on the chance to play in the NEAFL grand final. After that he was gone no matter the price we recieved. I saw it as a betrayal of the club and so did management. Watching him play live he has a pea heart. Doesnt want body contact at all. Ballenden will be twice the player...

On SM-T530 using BigFooty.com mobile app

Thank you sir. Like I said over on the Brisbane board he's never gone near a pack.

Dud pick and a bust. Good luck Dogs you'll need it.

 

[BRAB]

Why is a suns fan mouthing off in here, lol.

 

[Roylion]

Certainly didn't look FAIR AND EQUAL!

Hmmm. Not sure. Could you go through today's Eagles / Lions trade again?

 

[BRAB]

Why would the Lions accept Pick 15 for a contracted KPF that was their No. 2 pick, two years ago?

FAIR AND EQUAL

 

[conrad_437]

And yet Franklin is a superstar of the game.

I think its a very good comparison. Schache is the same height (199 cm) and has the same athleticism as Franklin.

man i wish

 

[mad_doggy911]

Richmond should've just given you #17 for Schache and a gnetleman's agreement we wouldn't bid on Ballenden.

I think the main reason we didn't end up wanting Schache was the $380k wage.

And that he's a marshmellow.

 

[QLDbeachbabe]

You'd need to get a pick around 10 or above.

15-16 would probably just get eaten up by a bid on Ballenden.

Pick 10?

 

[Roylion]

Yeah why would the Lion's accept pick 15 for a contracted KPF that was their No. 2 pick, two years ago?

They wanted Charlie Cameron to fill a need in their best 18. See here.

 

[SurreyBlue]

Great get Bulldogs. Well done. I'm disappointed we didn't use 10 to snag him.

 

[QLDbeachbabe]

I'm not acknowledging anything. A 'godfather' offer might make Brisbane consider a trade is all I'm saying. Get Richmond to make one. Make it very good. Too good to refuse.
As others have said a minimum Top Ten pick. And that is pure speculation on my part sure.

Howeever I do know for a fact that the Brisbane coaching staff rate Schache very highly. Offering a late round pick plus a fringe player is fanciful.

You wanted a godfather offer and a top ten pick?

 

[QLDbeachbabe]

Richmond: "Just putting in a call about Josh Schache. We're interested and we'd like to offer Pick 16 for you to trade him to us.
Brisbane: "No thanks. He's contracted for two more years. You'll have to do better than that."
Richmond: "We'll get back to you."

You always talk like this?

 

[Two Eyes]

FAIR AND EQUAL

FAIR AND EQUAL

FAIR AND EQUAL

FAIR AND EQUAL

 

[Two Eyes]

You always talk like this?

He's rOCDylion!

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Boyd FF
Schache CHF

Not bad doggies

 

[Two Eyes]

Hmmm. Not sure. Could you go through today's Eagles / Lions trade again?

FAIR AND EQUAL

 

[Roylion]

You wanted a godfather offer and a top ten pick?

No, I thought it was clear. Do you have trouble with basic comprehension in normal life?

"A 'godfather' offer might make Brisbane consider a trade." A 'godfather' offer would be a top ten pick. I also said a late round pick and a fringe player was fanciful. Did that happen?

 

[QLDbeachbabe]

It doesn't matter one iota what media pundits Healy, Brown, Dunstall and King or indeed Richmond supporters think is "fair". What matters is how the Brisbane Lions list management team (esentially Noble and Dom Ambrogio) and coaching staff (Fagan etc.) value Schache. They've already made it clear that they value him very highly.

They didn't value him a top 15 first round pick in return.

 

[QLDbeachbabe]

At least Pick 6 means the Lions could pick elite youngsters at #1, #6 and possibly #12 and still pay for Ballenden by using Pick 18 or later picks. What's the point of trading Schache for Pick 15 if the Lions have to use it to pay for Ballenden (an Academy player they will get anyway with later picks)?

The earlier statement made by a Richmond supporter that "Pick 15 is as good as pick 9 in this draft" is plainly ridiculous. On a number of counts.

Yep that's a hard bargin to pull off

 

[Two Eyes]

They didn't value him a top 15 first round pick in return.

Correct. Given your trade with the Tigers, pick 15 is worth 2 Schaches.

 

[QLDbeachbabe]

What's Schache is worth compared to a mature AFL star is irrelevant. Schache is worth whatever the market says he's worth.

Brisbane will assign a trade value to a contracted, 2nd year, 20 year old KPF taken at No. 2 in the 2015 draft and if Victorian clubs want to try and prise him out of Brisbane by offering a trade equal or better than Brisbane's assigned value then they are welcome to approach Brisbane and give it their best shot. IF it's accepted then that's what Schache is worth.

Your word's not mine but only worth a second and third round pick. 25/40

 

[Frank Gallagher]

You really are a campaigner.

I do what i can.

 

[BPikkers]

Is it time to close the thread?
If Roy could just cease engaging, this thread may have just run it’s course......

 

[BRAB]

Is it really that difficult to admit you were wrong.

Wow

 

[BPikkers]

Is it really that difficult to admit you were wrong.

Wow

Don’t answer that....please.

 

[dean33]

No, but I don't expect a club to come out and deny it completely if it happened - I'd expect them to weasel around it or simply not say anything. Richmond was "adamant Schache didn't cry in the interview" so either they are lying or it didn't happen. They didn't leave any wiggle room.

Maybe he didn’t cry and just sobbed a little?