2017 trade hypothetical thread

[Vindicater]

Exactly what we need.

To be fair I went back and checked on Ben Cunnington.

I thought he was closer to 30. He is only 26.

Not as gross.

 

[Milanista28]

To be fair I went back and checked on Ben Cunnington.

I thought he was closer to 30. He is only 26.

Not as gross.

He looks 35 in your defense.

 

[Magpie Monopoly]

Essendon trade
Aaron Francis
2017 3rd round pick
for
Crows 2018 1st
Crows 2017 2nd

(Presuming they lose Lever)

Essendon trade
2017 1st
crows 2018 1st &
Essendons 2018 2nd for
Josh Kelly


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Since when is Francis worth more than a 1st?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[schmuttt]

Ben Cunnington for our 1st rounder?

Would need to put your 2018 2nd in there to make it fair IMO

 

[bungalow_bill]

Would need to put your 2018 2nd in there to make it fair IMO

Pick 1 not enough according to a north fan on our board

 

[schmuttt]

Pick 1 not enough according to a north fan on our board

That's why the hypothetical trade thread is good, you can get neutral opinions because fans are way too bias

 

[Crowstar]

Essendon trade
Aaron Francis
2017 3rd round pick
for
Crows 2018 1st
Crows 2017 2nd

(Presuming they lose Lever)

Essendon trade
2017 1st
crows 2018 1st &
Essendons 2018 2nd for
Josh Kelly


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Lol that's gold.
You want a hungry jacks membership thrown in for Francis too?

 

[the rooboy]

Would you say pick 1 for any player is fair obviously the super talented ones.

 

[WilloTree]

Since when is Francis worth more than a 1st?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

That trade values him at Pick 15

https://www.draftguru.com.au/pick-value-calculator#18,36|Francis,46

 

[crowsfan2017]

Adelaide Crows Hypothetical:

Trades
Charlie Cameron > Brisbane
Pick 14 (Received from PA) > Adelaide

Jake Lever > Collingwood
Pick 6 + Scharenberg > Adelaide

Mitch McGovern > Fremantle
Pick 5 > Adelaide

H Wigg + R.Atkins > Carlton
B.Gibbs > Adelaide

Would leave Adelaide Picks 5, 6, 17, 34, 52 and picks 70 + 88 for rookie upgrades (Greenwood + Keath).

Free Agency
Pick Up
Tom Rockliff (BL)
D. Menzel (Geel)
J. Trengrove (Melb)

Delist
S.Thompson (ret)
C.Ellis Yoleman
T. Menzel

2018 Round 1 Team

F Brown, Talia, Keath
HB Kelly, Hartigan, Laird
C Smith, M.Crouch, Rockliff
HF Lynch, Walker, D.Menzel
F Betts, Jenkins, Greenwood
FOLL Jacobs, B.Gibbs, R. Sloane

INT B.Crouch, D.Mackay, R.Knight, Scharenberg

What do people think?

 

[LukeParkerno1]

How in the blue moon is Atkins and Wigg equal to Gibbs? Gibbs will cost a first rounder (not two, but at least 1).

 

[Russian Demon]

Adelaide Crows Hypothetical:

Trades
Charlie Cameron > Brisbane
Pick 14 (Received from PA) > Adelaide

Jake Lever > Collingwood
Pick 6 + Scharenberg > Adelaide

Mitch McGovern > Fremantle
Pick 5 > Adelaide

H Wigg + R.Atkins > Carlton
B.Gibbs > Adelaide

Would leave Adelaide Picks 5, 6, 17, 34, 52 and picks 70 + 88 for rookie upgrades (Greenwood + Keath).

Free Agency
Pick Up
Tom Rockliff (BL)
D. Menzel (Geel)
J. Trengrove (Melb)

Delist
S.Thompson (ret)
C.Ellis Yoleman
T. Menzel

2018 Round 1 Team

F Brown, Talia, Keath
HB Kelly, Hartigan, Laird
C Smith, M.Crouch, Rockliff
HF Lynch, Walker, D.Menzel
F Betts, Jenkins, Greenwood
FOLL Jacobs, B.Gibbs, R. Sloane

INT B.Crouch, D.Mackay, R.Knight, Scharenberg

What do people think?

Cameron worth pick 30 at best

You can have Trengove for nothing

 

[bungalow_bill]

No way is ports pick traded for Cameron.

 

[Pea Nut]

That trade values him at Pick 15

https://www.draftguru.com.au/pick-value-calculator#18,36|Francis,46

Now try and justify it. Look at the suggestions on what Adelaide would get for some of their players. How in the hell is Francis worth that. He has shown very little.

 

[harro92]

Now try and justify it. Look at the suggestions on what Adelaide would get for some of their players. How in the hell is Francis worth that. He has shown very little.

What do you value him at ?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Francis would be worth more to Essendon than you'd get trading him. Late first would be the best I'd offer

 

[harro92]

Francis would be worth more to Essendon than you'd get trading him. Late first would be the best I'd offer

Pick 15 is kinda a late 1st ahha


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Pick 15 is kinda a late 1st ahha

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

A lot of clubs wouldn't offer that. Early 2nd to mid 2nd is his value but I'd be happy giving a late first so long as there is a bit coming back our way. Depends on the club really

 

[harro92]

A lot of clubs wouldn't offer that. Early 2nd to mid 2nd is his value but I'd be happy giving a late first so long as there is a bit coming back our way. Depends on the club really

Yeah no way should they trade him for that, unless it is picks moved to gws to land Kelly


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Yeah no way should they trade him for that, unless it is picks moved to gws to land Kelly


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That's why I said keep him- he's worth more to Essendon than a trade. He will come good next season not sure why you want to trade him. Kelly will stay at GWS.

GWS ideally won't want to trade too much with Dodoro as he takes weeks to make his mind up.

 

[harro92]

That's why I said keep him- he's worth more to Essendon than a trade. He will come good next season not sure why you want to trade him. Kelly will stay at GWS.

GWS ideally won't want to trade too much with Dodoro as he takes weeks to make his mind up.

Well if Kelly chooses just Essendon they would have to wouldn't they


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Mitch Mcgov ain't worth pick 5.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Mitch Mcgov ain't worth pick 5.

Freo have pressing needs but surely you take pick 5 to the draft.

 

[Timmytime]

Adelaide Crows Hypothetical:

Trades
Charlie Cameron > Brisbane
Pick 14 (Received from PA) > Adelaide

Jake Lever > Collingwood
Pick 6 + Scharenberg > Adelaide

Mitch McGovern > Fremantle
Pick 5 > Adelaide

H Wigg + R.Atkins > Carlton
B.Gibbs > Adelaide

Would leave Adelaide Picks 5, 6, 17, 34, 52 and picks 70 + 88 for rookie upgrades (Greenwood + Keath).

Free Agency
Pick Up
Tom Rockliff (BL)
D. Menzel (Geel)
J. Trengrove (Melb)

Delist
S.Thompson (ret)
C.Ellis Yoleman
T. Menzel

2018 Round 1 Team

F Brown, Talia, Keath
HB Kelly, Hartigan, Laird
C Smith, M.Crouch, Rockliff
HF Lynch, Walker, D.Menzel
F Betts, Jenkins, Greenwood
FOLL Jacobs, B.Gibbs, R. Sloane

INT B.Crouch, D.Mackay, R.Knight, Scharenberg

What do people think?

You're dreaming if you think we're giving up Pick 5 for an out of contract 4th tall.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Freo have pressing needs but surely you take pick 5 to the draft.

Best available player at 5. None of this Logue stuff. Would love Mitch but 5 is wayyyyy overs.