VFL 2nd Semi Final - Sandringham vs Collingwood at North Port Oval (Pies lost 97-104) :-(

[Baltimore Jack]

Congrats on not doing a Hodgey, and for actually giving a **** about other people on the road.

I've seen Kennedy play blinders in the VFL, so today wasn't a good reflection of what he can do. His confidence might be a bit shot, to be honest, but I don't think it'll cost us too much to see what he can do next year, given that we'll be delisting/trading quite a few others.

I actually think Kennedy has a little currency and could be used in either the Trelaor or Aisho 'steak knives' trades
I agree he looked lacking in confidence today and he copped a couple of big hits

 

[Pedro]

Scharenberg is a good defender, just not when hes giving up 6cm and almost 10kgs

This. Didn't help us to have no KPP size players to play on Brown. He was just a bit too big in the end.

 

[TradeDraft]

Apparently Moore,Adams and Grundy never make a mistake.

HA HA VERY FUNNY.

Moore not playing showed our Intentions

 

[good4footy]

If PK is indeed going then great attitude to bust his backside in the two's for the 2nd half of the year. Had a crack for a club he apparently isn't happy with. Alternatively maybe he is staying!!

Different age to Aish but that is the one worry with Aish that he seems to have given up this year because he is not happy.

If we can get Treloar for our first pick and Witts, then we should hand him over and run in the opposite direction as quick as we can. I think he and Cox had a goal and a 'falcon' between them.

Great effort by the two's overall- limited by a couple of injuries, one of which was crucial in Marsh who would have been an option for Brown. Disappointing to lose but very symptomatic of the frustrating year it has been.

 

[shizzle]

* I missed the game completely, it sounds like Shaz did well, good to hear, anyone care to give me their best ons? Any injuries?

 

[TradeDraft]

This. Didn't help us to have no KPP size players to play on Brown. He was just a bit too big in the end.

SPOT ON.

Had no KPD after Marsh went down to play on Brown.

He won the game for them

 

[TradeDraft]

**** I missed the game completely, it sounds like Shaz did well, good to hear, anyone care to give me their best ons? Any injuries?

Marsh did hid Hammy Quite badly

 

[Ketchup]

**** I missed the game completely, it sounds like Shaz did well, good to hear, anyone care to give me their best ons? Any injuries?

All you need to know.

Shaz was close to our best, fantastic game by him. Best for the club.

Marsh destroyed his hammy again, looked like a bad one.

 

[Ketchup]

"

Witts second best on

Hellier third though hahahaha

 

[MagpieBat]

Scharenberg is a good defender, just not when hes giving up 6cm and almost 10kgs

Quoted for truth.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

**** I missed the game completely, it sounds like Shaz did well, good to hear, anyone care to give me their best ons? Any injuries?

Scharenberg best easily
Young and Caff good. Marsh until he went off

 

[JB1975]

I actually think Kennedy has a little currency and could be used in either the Trelaor or Aisho 'steak knives' trades
I agree he looked lacking in confidence today and he copped a couple of big hits

If he any currency, any attraction to other clubs at all, then I certainly think that we should cash in on it ASAP. However, Brisbane wouldn't be keen to take on an unproven player who would bolt back to South Australia at the first given opportunity, and I couldn't think that the Giants would rate him at all.

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

I actually think Kennedy has a little currency and could be used in either the Trelaor or Aisho 'steak knives' trades
I agree he looked lacking in confidence today and he copped a couple of big hits

He could be used as what? Kennedy would not even be worth a 2nd rounder on form shown to date in his career.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

If he any currency, any attraction to other clubs at all, then I certainly think that we should cash in on it ASAP. However, Brisbane wouldn't be keen to take on an unproven player who would bolt back to South Australia at the first given opportunity, and I couldn't think that the Giants would rate him at all.

Much like no one rated Crisp?
Maybe

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

If we can get Treloar for our first pick and Witts, then we should hand him over and run in the opposite direction as quick as we can. I think he and Cox had a goal and a 'falcon' between them.

Great effort by the two's overall- limited by a couple of injuries, one of which was crucial in Marsh who would have been an option for Brown. Disappointing to lose but very symptomatic of the frustrating year it has been.

No way will we get Treloar for a first rounder and Witts. Apart from ruck work, Witts was totally ineffective today and Cox also showed that he is a long way off playing AFL.

 

[JB1975]

Much like no one rated Crisp?
Maybe

Brisbane supporters rated Crisp. They saw glimpses of his best football just before he left, and I recall more than a minor lament that he'd left. The only reservations came from Collingwood supporters who (like me) had no idea what they were getting.

BK is a different story. He hasn't done a lot to fill Collingwood supporters with any hope, so we can't expect other teams to get too excited about the boy.

 

[shizzle]

Marsh did hid Hammy Quite badly

Oh * that's awful news

 

[Maggie5]

Well done to the boys today, showed a lot of fight, still a good future ahead.

Disappointing, but now they can have their break, fix any niggles and come back for a big 2016.

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

"

Witts second best on

Hellier third though hahahaha

Witts was terrible. He had no presence whatsoever around the ground. Maybe he is being pumped up for trade purposes.

 

[Anzacday]

Gee Gus Borthwick reminds me on Liam Picken with attack on the ball/player.
Doesn't take a backward step.

 

[Hardas]

Really awful way for Marsh to finish such a positive year - footy can be a real bummer at times.

 

[Hardas]

Oh and, great to hear Shaz backing up well this week - good sign on several fronts.

 

[mattys123]

Tough day down at North Port for our VFL boys.

We couldn't take a trick injury wise but fought out the game.

Dwyer, Marsh cry:), Karnezis, Pendlebury and Close all came off at times with different injuries.

Dwyer ended up playing full forward in the final term, terrible idea by the way.

Scharenberg was great especially early, he still has parts of his game to improve (one on one defense) but he's getting there.

Marsh going day and us losing makes it a s**t day though.

 

[mattys123]

Tough day down at North Port for our VFL boys.

We couldn't take a trick injury wise but fought out the game.

Dwyer, Marsh cry:), Karnezis, Pendlebury and Close all came off at times with different injuries.

Dwyer ended up playing full forward in the final term, terrible idea by the way.

Scharenberg was great especially early, he still has parts of his game to improve (one on one defense) but he's getting there.

Marsh going day and us losing makes it a s**t day though.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Quoted for truth.

Everyone it is a reserves game at the end.
Well done all gor your seconds efforts