Rumour Charlie Cameron to request a trade home to Queensland

[GC2015]

This one gained quite a bit of momentum over the last two weeks among Crows and Lions fans, and to a lesser extent Suns fans. Although, according to those in the know, it's not completely clear which QLD team is his preference.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Is it because he now realises both Queensland teams are closer to a flag than Adelaide?

 

[Milanista28]

Whats he worth? Pick between 10 and 20, Or is that too much, I really rate him.

Lions would pay overs just to land another great talent who wants to play for the club, Deal would be easy of he picked the lions I think.

 

[Tales]

Is it because he now realises both Queensland teams are closer to a flag than Adelaide?

Just think he'd prefer to play with men not a team full of fairys

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Just think he'd prefer to play with men not a team full of fairys

You watched the game last night too then?

 

[Red Bull]

Cameron for Ports 2017 1st rounder that Brisbane hold .
That pick added to Adelaide's 2017 1st rounder lands the Crows Gibbs .
Rory Sloane will be most pleased ...

 

[bungalow_bill]

Whats he worth? Pick between 10 and 20, Or is that too much, I really rate him.

Lions would pay overs just to land another great talent who wants to play for the club, Deal would be easy of he picked the lions I think.

General consensus on our board is our 2nd rounder which is about pick 18 or 19. Very unlikely we would trade Ports pick.

 

[BrennoWookie]

Feel it is very hard to judge what he is worth being in a forward line overloading with talent. From what I have seen of his game his pressure he applies is first class however Brisbane seem to have a lot of that this year what we don't have is consistent goal kickers. Not sure I can see Cameron averaging 2 goals a game. Because of this I could not see Brisbane being willing to part with a first rounder.

 

[DapperDon]

General consensus on our board is our 2nd rounder which is about pick 18 or 19. Very unlikely we would trade Ports pick.

Very fair

 

[Carlos Danger]

General consensus on our board is our 2nd rounder which is about pick 18 or 19. Very unlikely we would trade Ports pick.

Hard to have serious conversation about ports pick. If you told me they finish top 4 I'm not that surprised. If you tell me they missed the finals I'm not that surprised.

IMO 18 is more than fair

 

[Cleric]

Cameron for Ports 2017 1st rounder that Brisbane hold .
That pick added to Adelaide's 2017 1st rounder lands the Crows Gibbs .
Rory Sloane will be most pleased ...

You won't be getting 2 firsts. Let it go.

 

[Cleric]

Jed Anderson went for pick 15, CCs in contract and a better, healthier player.
Do the maths.

 

[Cleric]

General consensus on our board is our 2nd rounder which is about pick 18 or 19. Very unlikely we would trade Ports pick.

You won't get him for a second. If talent like Cameron was worth a second rounder it would be pretty easy to get a top 4 team together.

 

[The 747]

18 or 19 sounds about right to me.

 

[CrowsB4hoes]

I'd take 18 or 19.

 

[Two Planks]

Jed Anderson went for pick 15, CCs in contract and a better, healthier player.
Do the maths.

Dont let facts get in the way of a good story.

It wasn't a straight pick 15, it was a bit more complicated than that.

Pick 19 would be spot on.

 

[Red Bull]

You won't be getting 2 firsts. Let it go.

If you get pick 18 for Cameron from Brisbane which is technically the start of the 2nd round with GWS penalty invoked , we'll take that and your 2017 1st rounder for Gibbs .
That's a 1st and a 2nd rounder .
Can't be fairer than that

 

[Carlos Danger]

Jed Anderson went for pick 15, CCs in contract and a better, healthier player.
Do the maths.

Jed Anderson was a double pick swap worth way less than 15, was 15 & 54 for 38 & 40

Brad hill traded for pick 23 while in contract reckon that's pretty close to Cameron's value. Hence why 18 is pretty reasonable trade.

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

Jed Anderson went for pick 15, CCs in contract and a better, healthier player.
Do the maths.

Others have told you how you have misrepresented the trade. I don't care about that. Just because Anderson a bust, you use it as trade value??
Hill went 23?? I think CC more upside, so slightly higher. Pick 17-22 fair.

 

[Hawk_francais]

Others have told you how you have misrepresented the trade. I don't care about that. Just because Anderson a bust, you use it as trade value??
Hill went 23?? I think CC more upside, so slightly higher. Pick 17-22 fair.

We let Hill go for unders. We had no leverage.

CC would go for more, but Hill is a better player. I think CC will stay though - or rather Adelaide will fight for it.

 

[Carlos Danger]

We let Hill go for unders. We had no leverage.

CC would go for more, but Hill is a better player. I think CC will stay though - or rather Adelaide will fight for it.

Why no leverage? Was still in contract wasn't He?

 

[Mr Mediocracy]

Crows player wanting to return home to Queensland. Well he'll be coming to Sydney and miss 11 games then.

 

[iBeng]

Cameron for Ports 2017 1st rounder that Brisbane hold .
That pick added to Adelaide's 2017 1st rounder lands the Crows Gibbs .
Rory Sloane will be most pleased ...

That could be anywhere from pick 13-18 or even lower, this year has thrown up some odd games. I wouldnt be giving up a pick that high for him, even if he requested to come to us. We'd work something out.

 

[Billy Puller]

Cause it's on compassion grounds Adelaide will have to accept whatever's been offered. Be prepared to be bent over the table Adelaide you guys are about to get screwed

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Cause it's on compassion grounds Adelaide will have to accept whatever's been offered. Be prepared to be bent over the table Adelaide you guys are about to get screwed

Compassion grounds????