JB1975
Brownlow Medallist
The Age - Monday 22 September 1958.
https://news.google.com.au/newspapers?id=WCUQAAAAIBAJ&sjid=6pQDAAAAIBAJ&pg=4428,3432838&hl=en
Couple of things strike me as interesting in that report. First, the fact that Collingwood protected it's record of four straight premierships in 1958 is neither here nor there. Caught up in its own moment, the article instead seems interested that Melbourne's period of dominance might be over.
Second, there's a strong mythology that Collingwood effectively bashed their way to that premiership, in order to deny Melbourne 4th cup. The contemporary reports don't bear that out, instead highlighting the simple fact of one team playing better football than its opponent.