List Mgmt. The 2018 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals Thread

[mikey_san]

I like Cunningham on the wing and more forward though. He and Florent are the guys we want to have delivering the ball inside 50 because they can hit a target

Fair point, though on our deck anyone running out of defense is kicking inside 50 anyway. Cunningham is pretty good at the longer kick into the fiddy too.

 

[mikey_san]

Cripps signed with the blues lame

I could see us throwing him a 1.2 mill x 6 year offer too. Long shot but would've been nice

 

[cinderella man]

Could be totally wrong but my mail he has already told the pies that he wants to explore his options and Sydney is he preferred club
Also said the he sees him self as a backman and the role proposed by Sydney is something he is excited about

The Pies wanted lynch and were low balling Moore

Cheers Punts.

 

[SMFC1]

Gary Rohan or Sam Naismith for Dan Menzel from Geelong anyone?

Recon would be a good deal, seems to be out of favour with the coach and on 1 year contracts. If he stays on the park recon he can provide us with 2+ goals every week.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

he is useful but he is one out in an otherwise negligible midfield. The price of he and Curnow jnr has cruelled the Filth and will screw retention for whatever young emerging talent they have. Could not happen to a more miserable Club.

We should get into Dow. The Filth deserve to be treated as a breeding barn of talent to be picked up by other Clubs - just as they have treated other Clubs for decades.

 

[The King!]

Gary Rohan or Sam Naismith for Dan Menzel from Geelong anyone?

Recon would be a good deal, seems to be out of favour with the coach and on 1 year contracts. If he stays on the park will provide consistent fire power to the forward line.

Not the worst, I just feel our forward Line is ok already

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Out of that lot I would take Hunt and Tyson. In fact Tyson especially would be handy. Nothing special just knows his way around the contest which is what we're lacking.

Hunt would kind of be a bonus but we also have a few quick HB flankers so not essential

You do realise Tyson left GWS because of the ‘go home’ factor?

 

[SMFC1]

Not the worst, I just feel our forward Line is ok already

I like the look of our forward line as well, just feel there’s no serious pressure for spots there. As good as Hayward, Papley, Ronke and McCartin are they’re all still young and can go missing at times. Really recon Menzel could provide us with something now while Franklin isn’t on the decline, feel like we need another 2 Years before we see the best footy from the younger blokes.

 

[Aflrules1997]

Gary Rohan or Sam Naismith for Dan Menzel from Geelong anyone?

Recon would be a good deal, seems to be out of favour with the coach and on 1 year contracts. If he stays on the park recon he can provide us with 2+ goals every week.

Wouldn't he be a free agent?

 

[SMFC1]

Wouldn't he be a free agent?

Only herd he was out of contract if his a free agent even better as long as his price is within reason. I imagine we would want to get someone else’s payments off our books though.

 

[mikey_san]

Gary Rohan or Sam Naismith for Dan Menzel from Geelong anyone?

Recon would be a good deal, seems to be out of favour with the coach and on 1 year contracts. If he stays on the park recon he can provide us with 2+ goals every week.

Nuh. We have that position more than covered.
How bout Rohan for Kelly?

 

[Aflrules1997]

Only herd he was out of contract if his a free agent even better as long as his price is within reason.

Well I'd say he'd be close to unrestricted, 27-28?

 

[TheMase]

Wouldn't he be a free agent?

Yep, unrestricted.

http://m.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-22/official-afl-releases-list-of-2018-free-agents

 

[Punts]

Would trade Gazza and Naismith tomorrow if it were up to me

 

[Aflrules1997]

Would trade Gazza and Naismith tomorrow if it were up to me

The Eagles might be searching for reinforcements

 

[Cadsky]

Dan Menzel is on the exact opposite end of the scale to Rohan. can kick a goal but he is the worst rated forward in the league for defensive pressure.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Dan Menzel is on the exact opposite end of the scale to Rohan. can kick a goal but he is the worst rated forward in the league for defensive pressure.

whereas Gazza performs 400 inferred pressure acts a game.... these are of course like electrons, not visible to the naked eye.

 

[Punts]

Would love Caracella

Out of contract at years end

Assistant or head coach

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Would love Caracella

Out of contract at years end

Assistant or head coach

Head coach please

 

[Superstar swan]

So looks like there is no one left worth getting. I can easily see a steep drop off next year. Wont be for long but we could be losing a hell of alot of exp this year

 

[Superstar swan]

Grundy,mcveigh and lloyd are big dents to our best 22.. who comes in and replaces them that makes us a better team next year?

 

[Aflrules1997]

Grundy,mcveigh and lloyd are big dents to our best 22.. who comes in and replaces them that makes us a better team next year?

Melican,Mills,Blakey,Ling or Moore if we land him

 

[Aflrules1997]

So looks like there is no one left worth getting. I can easily see a steep drop off next year. Wont be for long but we could be losing a hell of alot of exp this year

It's actually exiting... We won't win a flag without changes.
Swans have drafted well over the last few years and adding Blakey and possibly Moore is something to look forward to.

 

[mtooler]

You do realise Tyson left GWS because of the ‘go home’ factor?

He might return due to the unemployed factor.

 

[Mick Oxlong]

He might return due to the unemployed factor.

You’re kidding yourself if you believe that Tools. That’s like saying Barry Hall may return because he’s unemployed!