List Mgmt. 2020 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals

[Mt Isa Mustang]

I just saw the highlights reel of a kid in the Adelaide Academy called Tariek Newchurch. Talk about impressive! Why can't we have a Newchurch?!?

not sure if this is a joke

I think you guys currently have and have had a few decent academy players

 

[Mt Isa Mustang]

Considering Brodie isn't playing, a second round pick sounds generous

I'd rather keep him on his contract until end of 2022 if this was the case.

At what point does someone go from having potential to not performing. Hard to say.

I would be happy to give up a 4th rounder for Elijah Taylor if he isn't regularly playing in your best 22 by 2022.

 

[dosser]

not sure if this is a joke

I think you guys currently have and have had a few decent academy players

Yeah, but we want more! Geez, Adelaide looks to have a good one there, though. I wonder how long it would be before they want to trade him out?

 

[Mt Isa Mustang]

Yeah, but we want more! Geez, Adelaide looks to have a good one there, though. I wonder how long it would be before they want to trade him out?

Or he wants to leave.

 

[xInfected_Virus]

I reckon you guys desperately need a ruckman.

I'd say you could bring back Nankervis or go after Ivan Soldo. Or if you want a dominant tap ruck then I'd go after Braydon Preuss from the Dees since they now have Luke Jackson and Preuss is pretty much redundant unless Max Gawn goes down.

Another KPD would be your second priority but not sure which players are available. I know you went after Darcy Moore in 2018 but he ultimately resigned with the Pies.

 

[Kapers]

I reckon you guys desperately need a ruckman.

I'd say you could bring back Nankervis or go after Ivan Soldo. Or if you want a dominant tap ruck then I'd go after Braydon Preuss from the Dees since they now have Luke Jackson and Preuss is pretty much redundant unless Max Gawn goes down.

Another KPD would be your second priority but not sure which players are available. I know you went after Darcy Moore in 2018 but he ultimately resigned with the Pies.

We just need anybody tall to not get injured, you have a family member or friend around 200cm?

 

[SGBeach]

A dreamy Sunday morn after a nightmare Saturday arvo..

Swans finish 17th -- pick2
Paps leaves for Melbourne -- p4 + Pruess + future 2nd
A 'Fit' Daniher arrives as a free agent
Darcy Moore + p16 (pies 1st pick) arrives for p4
Harry Perryman (GWS - midfielder - 40 games - p14 2016) arrives for p16
We mourn the loss of Paps but celebrate the gains of a ruckman, quality mid, quality kpd and a future 2nd round pick
We draft p2 + Campbell + Gulden - all good to elite 18yo's

2021..
Buddy plays alongside Daniher and they kick 100 goals between them
Ling plays every game and shows why he was our 1st pick all those years ago
A young midfield, now full of class - Florent, Rowbum, Stephens, Warner, Perryman, Campbell is well serviced by a proper Ruck..
Three talls make their mark in defence - Gould, Moore and OConnor (who takes mark of the year - why not, its a dream)
The Class, pace, skill and hardness take the Swans to the 2021 Granny

Rampe wins Bob Skilton
E Taylor wins Rising star
JPK wins the Norm Smith and retires on the high he deserves
Swans win the Flag

 

[brad cooper]

A dreamy Sunday morn after a nightmare Saturday arvo..

Swans finish 17th -- pick2
Paps leaves for Melbourne -- p4 + Pruess + future 2nd
A 'Fit' Daniher arrives as a free agent
Darcy Moore + p16 (pies 1st pick) arrives for p4
Harry Perryman (GWS - midfielder - 40 games - p14 2016) arrives for p16
We mourn the loss of Paps but celebrate the gains of a ruckman, quality mid, quality kpd and a future 2nd round pick
We draft p2 + Campbell + Gulden - all good to elite 18yo's

2021..
Buddy plays alongside Daniher and they kick 100 goals between them
Ling plays every game and shows why he was our 1st pick all those years ago
A young midfield, now full of class - Florent, Rowbum, Stephens, Warner, Perryman, Campbell is well serviced by a proper Ruck..
Three talls make their mark in defence - Gould, Moore and OConnor (who takes mark of the year - why not, its a dream)
The Class, pace, skill and hardness take the Swans to the 2021 Granny

Rampe wins Bob Skilton
E Taylor wins Rising star
JPK wins the Norm Smith and retires on the high he deserves
Swans win the Flag

Dreams can come true.

Last night I dreamt I was a 45 year old slowly going bald, with 3 moody teenage children, my football team just lost to a team from the city I live in meaning I get bombarded with texts all week.

I woke up and it had all come true.

 

[TheMase]

A dreamy Sunday morn after a nightmare Saturday arvo..

Swans finish 17th -- pick2
Paps leaves for Melbourne -- p4 + Pruess + future 2nd
A 'Fit' Daniher arrives as a free agent
Darcy Moore + p16 (pies 1st pick) arrives for p4
Harry Perryman (GWS - midfielder - 40 games - p14 2016) arrives for p16
We mourn the loss of Paps but celebrate the gains of a ruckman, quality mid, quality kpd and a future 2nd round pick
We draft p2 + Campbell + Gulden - all good to elite 18yo's

2021..
Buddy plays alongside Daniher and they kick 100 goals between them
Ling plays every game and shows why he was our 1st pick all those years ago
A young midfield, now full of class - Florent, Rowbum, Stephens, Warner, Perryman, Campbell is well serviced by a proper Ruck..
Three talls make their mark in defence - Gould, Moore and OConnor (who takes mark of the year - why not, its a dream)
The Class, pace, skill and hardness take the Swans to the 2021 Granny

Rampe wins Bob Skilton
E Taylor wins Rising star
JPK wins the Norm Smith and retires on the high he deserves
Swans win the Flag

‘Spose if you’re going to dream, you go all out hey?

Haha

 

[Millky95]

A dreamy Sunday morn after a nightmare Saturday arvo..

Swans finish 17th -- pick2
Paps leaves for Melbourne -- p4 + Pruess + future 2nd
A 'Fit' Daniher arrives as a free agent
Darcy Moore + p16 (pies 1st pick) arrives for p4
Harry Perryman (GWS - midfielder - 40 games - p14 2016) arrives for p16
We mourn the loss of Paps but celebrate the gains of a ruckman, quality mid, quality kpd and a future 2nd round pick
We draft p2 + Campbell + Gulden - all good to elite 18yo's

2021..
Buddy plays alongside Daniher and they kick 100 goals between them
Ling plays every game and shows why he was our 1st pick all those years ago
A young midfield, now full of class - Florent, Rowbum, Stephens, Warner, Perryman, Campbell is well serviced by a proper Ruck..
Three talls make their mark in defence - Gould, Moore and OConnor (who takes mark of the year - why not, its a dream)
The Class, pace, skill and hardness take the Swans to the 2021 Granny

Rampe wins Bob Skilton
E Taylor wins Rising star
JPK wins the Norm Smith and retires on the high he deserves
Swans win the Flag

Please don't keep all those nose beers to yourself. Some of us would like some

 

[The King!]

id tell papley stiff s**t we arent trading you

unpopular no doubt but If someone else would take buddy id trade him

 

[Membling]

Will Brodie?
His deficiencies would be somewhat negated on the SCG.

Not sure how a trade would work.
Would love Dawson or Mills but imagine they're untradeable

Wouldn't mind Brodie.

He is a down on GC mid depth charts and has been a while.

Dawson and Mills would not be included in any trade discussions unless is ridiculous offer.

Would give maybe pick 30ish for him.

 

[Punts]

No more ducking list cloggers please

Getting to a point we just looking to fill a list

 

[xInfected_Virus]

We just need anybody tall to not get injured, you have a family member or friend around 200cm?

Nope, I wish.

 

[The King!]

No more ducking list cloggers please

Getting to a point we just looking to fill a list

yep id rather the cap space

 

[SGBeach]

No more ducking list cloggers please

Getting to a point we just looking to fill a list

Im thinking we'll all be pleasantly surprised this trade period.. no list cloggers, instead genuine best 22 and maybe even better. We have the cap space and we have a lot of youth, I reckon we'll only take 2-3 from the draft and put in a big effort with the trade

 

[Punts]

Im thinking we'll all be pleasantly surprised this trade period.. no list cloggers, instead genuine best 22 and maybe even better. We have the cap space and we have a lot of youth, I reckon we'll only take 2-3 from the draft and put in a big effort with the trade

Have we got cap space?

Surely Reid will be traded

 

[The King!]

Going to be hard to do list changes with covid s**t

Can’t see kids play and contracts /cap space will be hard to get

 

[TheMase]

No more ducking list cloggers please

Getting to a point we just looking to fill a list

The alleged cutting back of the playing list due to Covid could be a blessing in disguise for us. Get rid of a bit of dead wood.

 

[Punts]

This in I can see

Gone
Armerty
Bell
Stoddart
Fox
Wicks
Thurlow
Clarke (don’t be surprised if kept )
Knoll
Maibum
Reynolds


Possible
Reid trade
Kennedy retire
Ling 1 year deal
Hewett ask to go home


Foot imo will be kept

 

[Virgin Dog]

Reckon you guys should grab Jackson Trengove off us. I honestly rate him as a very decent KPD, just doesn't seem to be the type Bevo wants in our current game plan. Able to play backup ruck when needed too, just a little short for full time (197cm). Did really well last year, and was statistically one of the best one-on-one players in the AFL, but hasn't been seen since Round 23 last year. Out of contract this year, and could probably be taken as DFA, or a token pick trade like we did for Roughead a couple years ago (pick in the 70s)

 

[TheMase]

This in I can see

Gone
Armerty
Bell
Stoddart
Fox
Wicks
Thurlow
Clarke (don’t be surprised if kept )
Knoll
Maibum
Reynolds


Possible
Reid trade
Kennedy retire
Ling 1 year deal
Hewett ask to go home


Foot imo will be kept

Hewett is interesting. I thought I’d look up where his partner was from expecting Sydney (wouldn’t want a trade) or Adelaide (closer to family for Misses) but I think I’ve found she is from the UK so there goes that lol.

 

[The King!]

Hewett is interesting. I thought I’d look up where his partner was from expecting Sydney (wouldn’t want a trade) or Adelaide (closer to family for Misses) but I think I’ve found she is from the UK so there goes that lol.

Hewett to manchester united?

 

[The King!]

This in I can see

Gone
Armerty
Bell
Stoddart
Fox
Wicks
Thurlow
Clarke (don’t be surprised if kept )
Knoll
Maibum
Reynolds


Possible
Reid trade
Kennedy retire
Ling 1 year deal
Hewett ask to go home


Foot imo will be kept

COR and Ronke can go too

 

[Punts]

COR and Ronke can go too

Are they still not contracted?