Bailey Smith vs Sam Walsh

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Elmer_Judd

#Teague2020
Jul 25, 2019
10,889
19,854
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Leeds United
FYI Bont has had a much season than Cripps, and right now he is ahead on points on career performances and achievements so far. Not questioning that
 

chunkylover53

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 13, 2008
6,270
13,142
From Where You'd Rather Be
AFL Club
Carlton
Good learning experience though for the kids if/when you make the finals next year. Playing finals not getting spanked!
nah, does more damage than good. Dees 2018 spring to mind. been a rabble since being destroyed in the prelim. happened to north a few times too a few years back. GWS look mentally shot after last years Granny. Adelaide fell off the cliff after richmond embarrassed them.

How many of the finalists did you beat this year?
Dunno, don't really care. we couldn't even beat Adelaide in a dead rubber game haha.

finals is different and you know it. pinching a big win against a flat WB in rd 6 or whatever is very different to facing off against them in an elimination final. we weren't ready this year and had we have made it, i reckon we would have been spanked by another more worthy qualifier.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

BoundbyKreuze

Club Legend
Feb 9, 2020
1,120
2,195
AFL Club
Carlton
How many of the finalists did you beat this year?
2 - just your mob and Geelong. But we led 3 after the siren. And another 2 we led all day till the last 15 minutes.

Are you aware Carlton beat more top 8 sides this year than western bulldogs did (1). And that was by 2 points (west coast) everyone else smacked them.
 

GoalSneak38

Club Legend
Suspended
Aug 16, 2006
2,934
1,462
Melbourne
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
2 - just your mob and Geelong. But we led 3 after the siren. And another 2 we led all day till the last 15 minutes.

Are you aware Carlton beat more top 8 sides this year than western bulldogs did (1). And that was by 2 points (west coast) everyone else smacked them.
Have you read the above threads. One of your Carlton mates stated that he didn't want Carlton to play finals which I think is ridiculous. His reasoning is that they would get pumped. I disagree and hence asked how many finals teams they beat during the season. I was on your side. But well done on jumping the gun and assuming and going on a rant about the Bulldogs
 

BoundbyKreuze

Club Legend
Feb 9, 2020
1,120
2,195
AFL Club
Carlton
Have you read the above threads. One of your Carlton mates stated that he didn't want Carlton to play finals which I think is ridiculous. His reasoning is that they would get pumped. I disagree and hence asked how many finals teams they beat during the season. I was on your side. But well done on jumping the gun and assuming and going on a rant about the Bulldogs
I read it all. I couldn’t care less. I’m pointing out that Carlton beat more teams in the 8 than the dogs. Just because 1 carlton fan said that doesn’t mean we all do. You brought up how many teams we’ve beaten now you look stupid for asking the question. Here’s a new question for you. How many times have a team played finals after only beating 1 other team in the 8??
 

GoalSneak38

Club Legend
Suspended
Aug 16, 2006
2,934
1,462
Melbourne
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
I read it all. I couldn’t care less. I’m pointing out that Carlton beat more teams in the 8 than the dogs. Just because 1 carlton fan said that doesn’t mean we all do. You brought up how many teams we’ve beaten now you look stupid for asking the question. Here’s a new question for you. How many times have a team played finals after only beating 1 other team in the 8??
Surely I don't have to explain the reasoning for asking it. But I'll do it just for you. Your fellow supporter shouldn't be saying Carlton shouldn't be playing finals as they'll get whacked and I disagree as they have between teams playing in the finals. Jog on mate. I'm sure you'll be happen once they let you back into the classroom
 

BoundbyKreuze

Club Legend
Feb 9, 2020
1,120
2,195
AFL Club
Carlton
Surely I don't have to explain the reasoning for asking it. But I'll do it just for you. Your fellow supporter shouldn't be saying Carlton shouldn't be playing finals as they'll get whacked and I disagree as they have between teams playing in the finals. Jog on mate. I'm sure you'll be happen once they let you back into the classroom
Pfft. Lol. Way to deflect away from my point that Carlton have beaten more teams in the 8 than the dogs. I couldn’t give a fu** about what 1 person that’s not me said about Carlton shouldn’t be playing finals. Coz we bloody well should be. Weve been more competitive than the majority of the 8 this year. Just not consistent against the sh*t sides.
 

conrad_437

Club Legend
Jun 26, 2016
1,383
2,274
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Didn't see every dogs game but when I did watch he was brilliant.
Way better this year too (Cripps playing injured this year though).
Fair enough. I've said previously in this thread that I personally disagreed and though Cripps was marginally better last year. It's clearly Bont right now but what has happened to Cripps? You'd think by now there'd be a sense of clarity on what sort of injury it was.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Top Bottom