The best 22 for 2005

[silverphoenix]

i don't see why rowe seems to be in everyones minds as a starting player and future gun. and personally i'd take j.cloke over walker, tristan's just one of those players who makes me cringe whenever he gets the ball.

Then you sir, either havent been watching any football so far this yr, or have to prepare yourself for some heavy cringing. J.Clo needs to develope another level to his game otherwise he could be on the chopping block

 

[Jabso]

Shaw, Holland, Licca..how many taggers do we need though?

Port Adelaide had J.Carr, K.Cornes and Cochrane and even Cassisi as taggers.
We can fit R.Shaw, Holland and Licca in the one team if you look at it this way:
- Licuria will play on a top midfielder and be our main link man at the same time
- Holland can tag the top midfielder out of the game or play a less defensive role and be more attacking.
- R.Shaw will be the specialist tagger and I don't expect him to play that many games anyway.

 

[collingwoody]

B: Clement Wakelin Lonie
HB: Morrison Presti Buckley
C: Johnson Cole Rowe
HF: Caracella Rocca Didak
F: Fraser Tarrant Burns
R: Richards Liccuria Holland
IC: Lockyer J Cloke C Cloke D King

No room for Leon Woey or O Bree apoligies to Tex and Nick Maxwell.
Am I being to kind to the Clokes folks ??

 

[browny4PM]

At the crossroads: R Shaw, M Lokan, S O'Bree, A Williams, T WalkerD King

Walker being at the crossroads as a 20 y.o.

Bad call.

Is a projest player and in the early stages of development.

 

[Jabso]

Where's eddiesmith?

 

[eddiesmith]

Why?