Which Tiger from the 90s-00s would you slot into todays line up if you could? (No Richo!)

[JAKLAUGHING]

See I think Bowdo should have been half forward, he was misused, he would be competing for Caddy's spot.

I love your mention of Broderick wow, what a gun

I never remember Broderick being a gun! He was a slow fat plodder that handballed a lot!

 

[roacheee]

Shane Tuck....would fit right in to this side

 

[thedreamisreal]

2005 Nathan Brown in this team would be something pretty ridiculous.

He was pretty ridiculous in THAT team iirc.

 

[tigs2010]

He was pretty ridiculous in THAT team iirc.

Was he ever. Didnt he kick 5 in the last after we trailed the Pies all day lol

 

[Tigerchamp19]

Terry Keays....

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Shane Tuck....would fit right in to this side

Ahhhh yes Tucky would be a great get...a big bullocking mid that knows only one way...Tucky would be awesome in todays side!
Forgot about Tucky!
If one had to choose between Tucky and Knighta it would be a tough call...but for our current side I would lean towards Tucky, as much as I rate Knighta, simply cos he would be the perfect compliment to our on-ball brigade! Tough and hard at it like Mr Cripps!

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Terry Keays....

 

[_Wang_]

Knighta, campbell, Gaspar and I reckon Stafford would have enjoyed our style now

 

[Rancid_Beasties]

But could he kick raking goals on the run a la Tivendale?

Look, I enjoyed watching Tivva wind up and roost one, but he was actually a fairly poor kick in terms of accuracy, and a truly shocking decision maker - one of the worst we have ever had. Bloody good player in one of the AFL video games though!

 

[_Wang_]

Look, I enjoyed watching Tivva wind up and roost one, but he was actually a fairly poor kick in terms of accuracy, and a truly shocking decision maker - one of the worst we have ever had. Bloody good player in one of the AFL video games though!

Turnoverdale !!

 

[ZEV]

Was he ever. Didnt he kick 5 in the last after we trailed the Pies all day lol

On an AA defender in top form James Clement at that.

 

[Sir_Loin]

Look, I enjoyed watching Tivva wind up and roost one, but he was actually a fairly poor kick in terms of accuracy, and a truly shocking decision maker - one of the worst we have ever had. Bloody good player in one of the AFL video games though!

Was good for about a season then it was like wtf is wrong with this guy. Looks like a great kick but isn’t

 

[Neen]

1. Matty Knights - I was at that Essendon Final. Turned the game. Walk straight into the side
2. Brad Ottens - At his peak, playing as full time ruck resting forward when Lynch is resting
3. Leon Cameron - Imagine after Houli's retirement, Leon was plonked across half back.
4. Craig Lambert - Inside beast that had a brilliant footy IQ and handballed to advantage where no one else would be thinking could happen.
5. Paul Broderick - Another smart player that was highly skilled and played better as the game wore on.

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

I don't get the Broderick love to play in our current side that fat plodder would have battled to keep up with the pace...

 

[HTT]

Imagine trying to defend Jack + Lynch + Dusty + peak Brown

Phwoar

 

[roacheee]

Ahhhh yes Tucky would be a great get...a big bullocking mid that knows only one way...Tucky would be awesome in todays side!
Forgot about Tucky!
If one had to choose between Tucky and Knighta it would be a tough call...but for our current side I would lean towards Tucky, as much as I rate Knighta, simply cos he would be the perfect compliment to our on-ball brigade! Tough and hard at it like Mr Cripps!

and a dead-eye kick for goal

 

[CaptchaProofBot]

willo of cartwheel fame ? we need a real campaigner in the side...or someone who can cartwheel. aw sheeet...does he even qualify in the 90s-00s ? damn...missed it by that much...one year.

 

[Infamy]

Imagine trying to defend Jack + Lynch + Dusty + peak Brown

Phwoar

Plus Richo… on the wing

 

[richoplzbreed]

Andy goodwin!!! I’d put him on Dangerfield and tell him to beat the living piss out of him!

 

[chriso11]

I tell ya what if we had knighta,This year would have been a 3peat.

We do, we have Caddy who is a deadset ringer for Knighta sometimes, and might even become the same type of player

 

[chriso11]

Hoping we gets a chance to re-live the Tambling name back at RFC with F/S's...

I wouldn’t go that far
Happy enjoying our current success without dipping too far into the days of gut wrenching losses when we were overrun in the final quarter and managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory
Happy to not have to witness any games like Rd7 2007, 157pt loss to Geelong. Nowadays, we make THEM cry

 

[YeOldTiger]

M Knights for me.

 

[tigerz18]

From grand final team

Ottens replace Nankervis
Bowden replace Broad
Krakouer replace Castagna
Deledio replace Lambert
Tambling replace Bellis





Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Sorry, thats the only one i disagree with. Broad is one of my favs and is completely underrated. If bowden replaces anyone from the premiership team, i'd have to say Pickett (only coz he's had one game) otherwise he'd replace baker.

 

[Vassp]

Knights would be a walk up start

Knights was great, his lack of speed might be noticed more now days.

But did Knights have time, he was like DR strange playing football !

 

[Sir_Loin]

1. Matty Knights - I was at that Essendon Final. Turned the game. Walk straight into the side
2. Brad Ottens - At his peak, playing as full time ruck resting forward when Lynch is resting
3. Leon Cameron - Imagine after Houli's retirement, Leon was plonked across half back.
4. Craig Lambert - Inside beast that had a brilliant footy IQ and handballed to advantage where no one else would be thinking could happen.
5. Paul Broderick - Another smart player that was highly skilled and played better as the game wore on.

Lambert was a very handy player - def worthy of being in the discussion