Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood?

[Monco Matt]

Hmmm, this question again. Well, let me see.....tough choice. Oh, right............

Collingwood. Sorry for the delay, was thinking about going back to back.

 

[Pistol Night]

**** me has there ever been a losing prelim side so full of shit

 

[Wolfgang West]

* me has there ever been a losing prelim side so full of s**t

They’re Coming

 

[Jeremias]

* me has there ever been a losing prelim side so full of s**t

Do you think it's only recently that Collingwood fans have become insufferable?

I remember them being particularly boisterous in 2020 and 2023 on the back of losing preliminary finals the year before.

 

[CarnTheScray]

Genuine request, can a Carlton supporter, if willing, provide with the areas of improvement they see that will put them into the top 4? Talking list improvements etc.

 

[Jeremias]

Genuine request, can a Carlton supporter, if willing, provide with the areas of improvement they see that will put them into the top 4? Talking list improvements etc.

Has been done already.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Genuine request, can a Carlton supporter, if willing, provide with the areas of improvement they see that will put them into the top 4? Talking list improvements etc.

Been done above, Pies fans just can't fathom improvement from within if it's not their own team

 

[Doc1763]

Genuine request, can a Carlton supporter, if willing, provide with the areas of improvement they see that will put them into the top 4? Talking list improvements etc.

The inclusion of The Lamp has catapulted them to outright premiership favoritism.

 

[Ctracks]

Carlton supporters, is it true that only Carlton will improve?

 

[Jeremias]

Carlton supporters, is it true that only Carlton will improve?

Can you show us one Carlton supporter who has said that?

Or are you simply trolling?

 

[Ctracks]

Can you show us one Carlton supporter who has said that?

Or are you simply trolling?

Why do you think I’m trolling?

 

[Jeremias]

Why do you think I’m trolling?

Because you can’t show me one Carlton who has said that only Carlton will improve, can you?

 

[Ctracks]

Because you can’t show me one Carlton who has said that only Carlton will improve, can you?

You took the question as literal. It wasn’t.

It’s true, any player from any team can improve, and any team can improve overall.

I believe, as many other Collingwood supporters posting here, that it’s more likely that other teams will improve more than Carlton.

 

[Jeremias]

You took the question as literal. It wasn’t.

So you were baiting? Glad we cleared that up.

 

[Ctracks]

So you were baiting? Glad we cleared that up.

Straight to baiting? Seems that as a Carlton supporter/moderator you're just looking for that.
Rhetorical questions have been used for centuries to make a point, emphasise a point etc, etc.

 

[Jeremias]

Straight to baiting? Seems that as a Carlton supporter/moderator you're just looking for that.
Rhetorical questions have been used for centuries to make a point, emphasise a point etc, etc.

Oh, you were 'making a point'?

And what "point" would that be?

 

[Ctracks]

Oh, you were 'making a point'?

And what "point" would that be?

For emphasis:

Any player from any team can improve, and any team can improve overall.
I believe, as many other Collingwood supporters posting here, that it’s more likely that other teams will improve more than Carlton

 

[Jeremias]

For emphasis:

Any player from any team can improve, and any team can improve overall.
I believe, as many other Collingwood supporters posting here, that it’s more likely that other teams will improve more than Carlton

Thank you.

Forgive us for dismissing this as Collingwood fans thinking Carlton won’t improve ‘because Carlton’.

 

[The Feeder Club]

Why is this a Collingwood lovefest thread?

It's not, it's the ****ing Carlton Collingwood who has the biggest dick thread and it's utterly tiresome. The fact that two mods have contributed to derailing it, rather than deleting or moving the posts to the already established biggest dick thread, makes it even worse

 

[Jeremias]

It's not, it's the ******* Carlton Collingwood who has the biggest dick thread and it's utterly tiresome. The fact that two mods have contributed to derailing it, rather than deleting or moving the posts to the already established biggest dick thread, makes it even worse

Sorry, I’m not a main board mod.

Otherwise there’d be no Collingwood supporters here.

 

[Robertio]

* me has there ever been a losing prelim side so full of s**t

Collingwood in 2022.

 

[caloschwaby]

In 2023 late Carlton were a 4-5 goal better side than Collingwood.

In AFL 23 on Playstation 5?

 

[Doc1763]

Collingwood in 2022.

I think we may have rectified the situation 12 months later when we WON the GRAND FINAL.

We all know you wont be doing that, which is why you're all soooo salty.

Never mind, just pop on the VHS of the 1995 GF, that'll make you feel better.

 

[Robertio]

I think we may have rectified the situation 12 months later when we WON the GRAND FINAL.

We all know you wont be doing that, which is why you're all soooo salty.

Never mind, just pop on the VHS of the 1995 GF, that'll make you feel better.

Not salty at all, we could win the flag this year as well, at the moment we are equal on points and precentage with the Pies.

I think we may have rectified the situation 12 months later when we WON the GRAND FINAL.

We all know you wont be doing that, which is why you're all soooo salty.

Never mind, just pop on the VHS of the 1995 GF, that'll make you feel better.

Salty about what? At the moment we are equal on points and percentage with Collingwood.

 

[Fadge]

Not salty at all, we could win the flag this year as well, at the moment we are equal on points and precentage with the Pies.

Salty about what? At the moment we are equal on points and percentage with Collingwood.

Gotta love February!