Recruiting EFC Trade/Draft Talk III - 1 McClug, 1 Billings (AND ROSS) for 4th rounder get it done dodoro

[eDPS]

I have a seat

Lucky bastard! Got to meet Cal Twomey in the standing area though which was cool.

 

[quotemokc]

How would you feel if it went.....

1-McGrath (GWS)
2-Brodie (GCS - bid match)
3-SPS (BL)
4-McLuggage (Freo)
5-??????????????? (Ess)
6-Whoever doesnt go at 5 (Carl)
7-Ainsworth (Rich)

Who would we take?

Do you mean Bowes at 2?

If Hogan doesnt end up at Freo they take Marshall even if they get McCarthy aswell.

If they do get Hogan, they would seriously consider English to replace Sandilands

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Is the game today televised?

AFL live pass if you haven't got fox.

 

[citizen-erased]

How would you feel if it went.....

1-McGrath (GWS)
2-Brodie (GCS - bid match)
3-SPS (BL)
4-McLuggage (Freo)
5-??????????????? (Ess)
6-Whoever doesnt go at 5 (Carl)
7-Ainsworth (Rich)

Who would we take?

Taranto would still be a good get.
he's started well in the U18s game too

 

[citizen-erased]

Do you mean Bowes at 2?

If Hogan doesnt end up at Freo they take Marshall even if they get McCarthy aswell.

If they do get Hogan, they would seriously consider English to replace Sandilands

my bet is they go tall. esp with Weller and Blakely looking good this year and Hill likely to come in

 

[bomberman500]

How would you feel if it went.....

1-McGrath (GWS)
2-Brodie (GCS - bid match)
3-SPS (BL)
4-McLuggage (Freo)
5-??????????????? (Ess)
6-Whoever doesnt go at 5 (Carl)
7-Ainsworth (Rich)

Who would we take?

Why have you got carlton at 6?
If we have pick 5 that is Carltons pick that GWS would most likely get in any Marchbank trade
Richmonds pick would be 6, and they might ship it off to GC for Prestia
GWS would be 7 which would possibly be sent to us as part of the pick 1 trade

 

[eDPS]

What a start from McCluggage

 

[scanlon]

McCluggage has kicked 2 in the first quarter...

Get ready for a new number 1 favourite

 

[citizen-erased]

Why have you got carlton at 6?
If we have pick 5 that is Carltons pick that GWS would most likely get in any Marchbank trade
Richmonds pick would be 6, and they might ship it off to GC for Prestia
GWS would be 7 which would possibly be sent to us as part of the pick 1 trade

i think he has it as following (quoted my post without updating the teams);
1-McGrath (GWS)
2-Brodie (BL)
3-SPS (Freo)
4-McCluggage (Gold Coast)
no Bowes bid yet.
At 5, who do we take. My vote is Taranto

 

[citizen-erased]

McCluggage has kicked 2 in the first quarter...

Get ready for a new number 1 favourite

Brown and Taranto's work set both up.
Ainsworth, strong run!

 

[scanlon]

Brown and Taranto's work set both up.
Ainsworth, strong run!

Yeah rate Tarantos game higher than McCluggages so far. Looks like the other team are just letting clug roam free and do whatever he wants in the 50

 

[Skipper_]

Saw the parade close up with my young son today.

This Grand Final is Men versus Boys. The Dogs are SO young looking.....

If they get up, it will be a re-incarnation of the Baby Bombers.

This may surprise you but the Swans are playing a younger best 22 than the Dogs.

 

[Travisty1331]

Forget trading pick one take mccluggage and pray a battle or sharenberg falls to 19


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[eDPS]

Great quality game so far. Some weird matchups with Drew playing on Ainsworth. McCluggage with 2 goals not sure he has had a lot of the footy yet though. Taranto been busy. Cedric Cox and Rotham have looked good aswell. Anyone watching on tv please give an update on disposals.

 

[Seagrave_Holmes]

First goal from McClug was just smart positioning in space, the second one I couldn't quite see what happened but he was on the end of a free kick advantage and kicked from the goal square.

 

[Seagrave_Holmes]

McGrath maybe just the one touch down back so far.

 

[Nomulus]

I'm really liking Ainsworth from what little I've seen. Seems like a Dangerfield, Colyer, Ballantyne hybrid.

 

[Seagrave_Holmes]

Great quality game so far. Some weird matchups with Drew playing on Ainsworth. McCluggage with 2 goals not sure he has had a lot of the footy yet though. Taranto been busy. Cedric Cox and Rotham have looked good aswell. Anyone watching on tv please give an update on disposals.

I also saw Drew on McCluggage at one point!

 

[bomberman500]

i think he has it as following (quoted my post without updating the teams);
1-McGrath (GWS)
2-Brodie (BL)
3-SPS (Freo)
4-McCluggage (Gold Coast)
no Bowes bid yet.
At 5, who do we take. My vote is Taranto

Would Taranto still be there at 7, if the draft falls this way could get Ainsworth/Taranto with 5/7

Provided Richmond cough up pick 6 for Prestia, that would give GC picks 4 and 6 (and 8)
If Brisbane bid on Bowes with pick 2 then the 25% discount means GC just have to give up pick 4

however,

If GWS bid on Bowes at 1(3000pts),could make it part of any trade we make. with a 25% discount thats 2250pts
If GC match they have to give up pick 4 (2034pts) and lose 216pts on their pick 6, which by my understanding of the system drops their pick 6 back to pick 8.

If we traded 1 for 5/7 and Bowes was bid on, and matched with pick 1. we would have pick 5 and 6, with GC having 7 and 8

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Warming to trading our 2017 1st to either GC or GWS, they could have 5 or 6 of the top 10 picks.

 

[citizen-erased]

Yeah rate Tarantos game higher than McCluggages so far. Looks like the other team are just letting clug roam free and do whatever he wants in the 50

right now, I'm think 5 & 7 and Ainsworth & Taranto would be a sensational haul.
Ainsworth looks very dangerous everywhere from HBF to the FP.

 

[citizen-erased]

Warming to trading our 2017 1st to either GC or GWS, they could have 5 or 6 of the top 10 picks.

Hibberd for Melbourne 2017 2nd + our 2017 2nd into Pick 7 or 8

 

[straightuplazy]

Shai Bolton looking pretty good

 

[citizen-erased]

SPP, not doing himself any favours
Bolton reminds me of Lovett without the foot skills....

 

[citizen-erased]

Shai Bolton looking pretty good

kicks haven't been great, but the line breaking runs are