Game Day Geelong Cats v West Coast Eagles - Semi Finals - Fri 13 Sep, 7:50PM AEST, MCG

[juss]

If any of the last 3 finals series are a precedent, he’d be extremely stiff to be suspended. If it was a H&A game, he’d cop a week (unless he’s a Brownlow fancy)

The fact it was a fair way away from the ball is the damning thing for me.

 

[GROTTO]

The timing of ASADA is something special. I would award them 2 votes tonight. 3 Votes to the Umpires and 1 vote for Jetta, his turnovers was breathtaking.

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

Got to say that there's few things sweeter than a win like that. Can't speak for regular supporters and the club internally, but it feels like Eagles supporters on here have consistently failed to give Geelong the slightest bit of respect and were just praying that they'd get a game against the Cats in the finals, despite getting absolutely poleaxed in the one meeting between the clubs during the season. Well it happened: the Eagles got their dream matchup and they got sat on their arse.

 

[Woody Woodman]

Cats flogged them 15 goals in May.

Lucky matches aren't decided on rough estimates like this for you blokes.

 

[Back One Out]

Betcha this 1/4 time margin will be the final margin, give or take a goal
(Geelong 13.10 def West Coast 8.12)

You've lost the game in that quarter, I reckon

Well, it wasn't that bad of a 1/4 time prediction, Cockarfitt

Cats led by 25 points and ended up winning by 20, more or less like I thought.
Eagles lost the game with their poor opening. Didn't look as switched on as the Cats.

Geelong 13.10 def West Coast 10.8

I nailed Geelong's exact score and was out by 8 points with the Eagles.

 

[Generalissimo]

Betcha this 1/4 time margin will be the final margin, give or take a goal

(Geelong 13.10 def West Coast 8.12)

You've lost the game in that quarter, I reckon

Well done; aside from the Eagles being a bit more accurate, this is spot on.

 

[GROTTO]

The fact it was a fair way away from the ball is the damning thing for me.

In finals, you either have to kill someone to miss a game or produce gatorade when you pee.

Hawkins will get off. I disagree with it, but you can take that to the bank.

 

[PieLebo87]

The fact it was a fair way away from the ball is the damning thing for me.

NicNat last week was during a pause in play.

 

[PerthBoy86]

Got to say that there's few things sweeter than a win like that. Can't speak for regular supporters and the club internally, but it feels like Eagles supporters on here have consistently failed to give Geelong the slightest bit of respect and were just praying that they'd get a game against the Cats in the finals, despite getting absolutely poleaxed in the one meeting between the clubs during the season. Well it happened: the Eagles got their dream matchup and they got sat on their arse.

Nah many of us - probably most - recognised this was a danger game. We were fairly confident, but not overly arrogant, aside from a few. But yeah, gotta give it to the Cats, were better and harder at it.

 

[PP34]

How does a commentary team get away with barracking for Geelong's opponents each week.

It's poor. Then trying to get a player suspended from a nothing incident. Gold.

Nothing incident?

He belted someone in the head behind play you biased fool.

 

[juss]

NicNat last week was during a pause in play.

I am not comparing other incidents that aren't like for like actions.
Secondly, one wrong decision doesn't mean we should make another one.

 

[WCfan22]

Got to say that there's few things sweeter than a win like that. Can't speak for regular supporters and the club internally, but it feels like Eagles supporters on here have consistently failed to give Geelong the slightest bit of respect and were just praying that they'd get a game against the Cats in the finals, despite getting absolutely poleaxed in the one meeting between the clubs during the season. Well it happened: the Eagles got their dream matchup and they got sat on their arse.

I wanted to play the pies tonight damn it

 

[PhatBoy]

Dangerfield will never play in a flag.

Neither will any crows players in the next few decades so at least he can miss out on flags closer to home

 

[Chuckie357]

How is Selwood still on the ground? Blood rule doesn’t apply to him I guess

Umps probably think he just ducked onto the red oval paint

 

[PhatBoy]

The timing of ASADA is something special. I would award them 2 votes tonight. 3 Votes to the Umpires and 1 vote for Jetta, his turnovers was breathtaking.

Lol.

Yeah missing an average small forward due to trying to cheat a drug test was the difference.

He was a way bigger out for the eagles than Duncan was for the cats

 

[ThatsjustDappa]

No wonder Willie got done, the two samples in front of Simpson, one was clearly orange whilst the other was yellow....

 

[My Cotchin Rules]

Imagine if Richmond don't win the flag from here. Once again everything falling in their favour.

Collingwood say hi.....

 

[PhatBoy]

Well, it wasn't that bad of a 1/4 time prediction, Cockarfitt

Cats led by 25 points and ended up winning by 20, more or less like I thought.
Eagles lost the game with their poor opening. Didn't look as switched on as the Cats.

Geelong 13.10 def West Coast 10.8

I nailed Geelong's exact score and was out by 8 points with the Eagles.

(Excepting his probable suspension.....)

I suppose we can blame yet another Hawkins failure to stand up in a final on Scott not blasting him in last week’s presser?

 

[Back One Out]

Nothing incident?

He belted someone in the head behind play you biased fool.

Put him down for the count, too

Hawkins was asking him "Are you right, mate?"

... and BT was commending Hawkins for his fine sportsmanship!

 

[PieLebo87]

I am not comparing other incidents that aren't like for like actions.
Secondly, one wrong decision doesn't mean we should make another one.

I just won’t be surprised if he simply gets a fine.

 

[KeilorUnder9s]

You guys were in a slump at that time now hitting your straps. Every chance to win

I hope you’re right!

 

[Back One Out]

Excepting his probable suspension....

Great leadership!

Will he opt for the "jumper punch" defence, or try to argue it was "negligent" and below the necessary force for a report?

 

[Chinacats]

Tigers are good don't get me wrong, but people talk like they are a super team..

Yeah they are not hawks 1980’s or cats 07-11. They are good but not super.

 

[Black white]

NicNat last week was during a pause in play.
[/QUOTE]

I don't think nicnat king hit the bloke

 

[Chuckie357]

Bruce stfu.

Geelong scraped over the line against an interstate 5th in Melbourne after a 24h drug test controversy.

Richmond will beat them easily and they'll turn first into another prelim loss. The monkey well be removed if and when they make a gf.

I found that comment live hilarious too