List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion

[Jen2310]

Does Noble have to be upgraded this year?

He does.
Been on the rookie list for 3 years
2019-2022

 

[Prexm]

Chugg. Wilson. Madgen. Roughy. And if Grundy or/and Poulter leave?
Can add in one of the browns if necessary.
You dont have to select 3 players at the draft. Just use three picks. You can select 2 plus upgrade a rookie (noble)

if we say Chugg Madgen Roughy and Poulter and bring the 3 from other clubs in. We are still at 42. Would need another 2-3 off. As for Grundy I am not including him because if he does go I am expecting to replace him with someone better than the 3 players mentioned that we look like bringing in.

 

[KinderSmock]

Just curious, is Gunston still unsigned or did I miss something?

Unsigned, linked to Brisbane.

 

[KinderSmock]

if we say Chugg Madgen Roughy and Poulter and bring the 3 from other clubs in. We are still at 42. Would need another 2-3 off. As for Grundy I am not including him because if he does go I am expecting to replace him with someone better than the 3 players mentioned that we look like bringing in.

This off-season will be ruthless for list cuts.

If Hill, Taranto, Frampton and McStay are the ins,

Then the outs will be at least 7.

 

[Jen2310]

if we say Chugg Madgen Roughy and Poulter and bring the 3 from other clubs in. We are still at 42. Would need another 2-3 off. As for Grundy I am not including him because if he does go I am expecting to replace him with someone better than the 3 players mentioned that we look like bringing in.

Carmichael would replace chugg on the rookie list
Noble replaces roughy on the senior list
There is a rookie spot open. Could delist and rookie one of those on the senior list to open up a senior spot.

Wilson would only make way for a cat B rookie, if we can get one or both of our NGA prospects through to the rookie draft, if we both either or both (there are two cat b spots open with Keane gone)
Madgen for McStay
Poulter (if he goes/not offered a contract) for Hill
Grundy only if we get Taranto

Then deal with the draft.

What to do with WHE?

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Mihocek and Elliott will be 33 and 32 respectively going into the 2025 season. Both have huge hearts, so you would be foolish to ever write them off.

Back in the here and now - I believe Brody will appreciate the off season to freshen up, and Jamie is in very good nick. But some of us can drop off quite sharply post 29.

We just re-signed Billy for three years, so if he’s near retirement that’s a concern.

 

[unplugged]

Unsigned, linked to Brisbane.

If we think we can win another flag with Howe, Pendles and Sidebottom we should be offering him a 2 year deal.

Then again it might make Henry go crying to mum and dad

 

[The Royal Sampler]

I don't think we looked second rate today. We were beaten by a better side by 4 goals on their home deck with flu and injury affecting us. We attacked relentlessly in the last thirty minutes for no reward. Second rate is what Hawthorn and Essendon were this weekend.

Figure of speech. We certainly didn’t look our usual standard.

 

[Prexm]

Carmichael would replace chugg on the rookie list
Noble replaces roughy on the senior list
There is a rookie spot open. Could delist and rookie one of those on the senior list to open up a senior spot.

Wilson would only make way for a cat B rookie, if we can get one or both of our NGA prospects through to the rookie draft, if we both either or both (there are two cat b spots open with Keane gone)
Madgen for McStay
Poulter (if he goes/not offered a contract) for Hill
Grundy only if we get Taranto

Then deal with the draft.

Your spot on. Just need to add some more delistings for the number of draft spots we want and perhaps Frampton. Would think Kelly might be in trouble if that’s the case.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Poulter for Frampton could be a direct swap at this rate, although Poulter had some more than decent passages yesterday in the VFL.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Your spot on. Just need to add some more delistings for the number of draft spots we want and perhaps Frampton. Would think Kelly might be in trouble if that’s the case.

Kelly should be in dire trouble regardless.

 

[Jen2310]

Your spot on. Just need to add some more delistings for the number of draft spots we want and perhaps Frampton. Would think Kelly might be in trouble if that’s the case.

I've been told he will get a new contract. But things could change. But our lack of talls may save him.

 

[KinderSmock]

I've been told he will get a new contract. But things could change. But our lack of talls may save him.

Daddy will make sure he gets a new contract.

 

[KinderSmock]

Carmichael would replace chugg on the rookie list
Noble replaces roughy on the senior list
There is a rookie spot open. Could delist and rookie one of those on the senior list to open up a senior spot.

Wilson would only make way for a cat B rookie, if we can get one or both of our NGA prospects through to the rookie draft, if we both either or both (there are two cat b spots open with Keane gone)
Madgen for McStay
Poulter (if he goes/not offered a contract) for Hill
Grundy only if we get Taranto

Then deal with the draft.

What to do with WHE?

If we won the premiership, I imagine a few of our issues would be solved.

 

[makethat2]

Wrong. He signed on January 2020 after one of the best seasons of any modern ruckmen ever. Then covid happened not long after

He signed during 2020 while not producing

 

[gouki88]

He signed during 2020 while not producing

He signed the January of 2020. The summer before the pandemic season. You only need to go to his Twitter account and see his pinned tweet.



Really not sure why people are having such a hard time with this simple fact.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Where the hell is this speculation we're interested in Frampton coming from? I haven't seen it anywhere except this thread.

 

[Jen2310]

He signed the January of 2020. The summer before the pandemic season. You only need to go to his Twitter account and see his pinned tweet.



Really not sure why people are having such a hard time with this simple fact.

Coming off a year he won the copeland trophy 2 years running.
There was a lot of pressure to sign him before the start of the 2020 season.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Coming off a year he won the copeland trophy 2 years running.
There was a lot of pressure to sign him before the start of the 2020 season.

From Eddie.

 

[Apex36]

Where the hell is this speculation we're interested in Frampton coming from? I haven't seen it anywhere except this thread.

Rumour started on the Adelaide board, I believe.

 

[gouki88]

Rumour started on the Adelaide board, I believe.

Trying to generate value in a delisting.

I've also heard North is interested in Chugg

 

[makethat2]

He signed the January of 2020. The summer before the pandemic season. You only need to go to his Twitter account and see his pinned tweet.



Really not sure why people are having such a hard time with this simple fact.

I stand corrected!

He has been average since signing then.

 

[gouki88]

I stand corrected!

He has been average since signing then.

Definitely not who he was

 

[Roverjg]

Sydney much better team than us, and they just draft good.

Can anyone remember the last time they didn’t draft a FRP?

2020- McDonald, Campbell (gulden -32)
2019 - Stephens
2018 - Blakely
2017 - Ling (made up for it with T.Mccartin & Amartey)
2016 - Florence & Hayward
2015 - mills
2014 - Heeney

I’ve just named 8 first round picks who are playing for them. Only 1 miss (Ling).

Even the players that left brought them great value (Hewett, Jones, S.Murray).


We have to build through the draft.

Any idea how many of these players were gifted to the Swans via their academy?

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[What is a cakewalk]

Any idea how many of these players were gifted to the Swans via their academy?

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Campbell, gulden, blakely, mills and heeney from the academy.