List Mgmt. 2020 Best 25

[witsend]

From the Prelim:

In: Hawkins, Steven
Out: Henderson, Kelly

is the easy bit.

Then it’s harder to see where Rohan, Clark, Jenkins and Constable fit.

Also Duncan...

 

[Tony Barber]

B: O'Connor - Blicavs - Kolo
HB: Stewart - Taylor - Henry
C: Duncan - Selwood - Clark
HF: Miers - Steven - Dahlhaus
F: Jenkins - Hawkins - Rohan
R: Ratugolea - Dangerfield - Narkle

I: (From) Guthrie - Tuohy - Parfitt - Fogarty - Ablett - Cockatoo - Stanley

Left out, Menegola, Atkins, constable, Bews

Would consider dropping Taylor and pushing Clark or Cockatoo back.

 

[CatRiot]

I'd say our depth is as good as it has been since probably 2011...

Assuming no significant drop off in the form of our aging stars - Taylor, Ablett, Selwood, Hawkins.

Hopefully some more younger kids on the list can break into Best 22 with rich form.

 

[Turbocat]

I'd say our depth is as good as it has been since probably 2011...

Assuming no significant drop off in the form of our aging stars - Taylor, Ablett, Selwood, Hawkins.

Hopefully some more younger kids on the list can break into Best 22 with rich form.

How we handle them is critical... Taylor and Ablett can not be allowed to demand selection coming off a fresh Off season playing well... and then get injured tired etc.

 

[Turbocat]

If everyone is fit ... and you can get into the best 22 you will be doing well


B: O'Connor - Blicavs - Bews
HB: Stewart - Kolo - Henry
C: Duncan - Constable - Clark
HF: Steven - Jenkins - Dahlhaus
F: Miers - Hawkins - Ablett
R: Ratugolea - Dangerfield - Selwood

I: - 2e , Parfitt , Cockatoo , Narkle

 

[CabWesty]

O'Connor, Kolo, Bews (Would see Kolo and Blitz swapping as needed, similarly work Bews, Tuohy and O'Connor around as needed.)
Stewart, Blicavs, Henry (I'd like to see the opportunity for Blicavs to still be accountable, but be able to take more advantage of his tank.)
Duncan, C Guthrie, Clark (could swap Henry and Clark)
Selwood, Hawkins, Dahlhaus (Selwood to go into the middle as needed. I really like Hawkins when he switches to Carey mode and gets up the ground a bit rather than staying home and wrestling defenders under a high ball.)
Ablett, Jenkins, Miers
Stanley, Dangerfield, Steven
Rohan, Ratugolea, Narkle, Parfitt (really struggle with not having Atkins in here)

E Cockatoo, Menegola, Tuohy

Would like to see Cocky, Menegola, Tuohy, as well as Constable, Kreuger, Fort, Atkins and Abbott really smash it up in the VFL and give themselves every opportunity to get promoted.

That's 30 names up there already. That's some pretty good depth even without the names below.

Think Z Guthrie, Henderson and Taylor should be fixtures in the 2s this year.

 

[Chinacats]

FB: O’Connor. Blicavs. Bews
HB: Stewart. Henry. Clark
W: Duncan Guthrie. Selwood
HF: Dahlhaus Ratugolea Miers
FF: Ablett. Hawkins. Cockatoo
R: Stanley. Danger Narkle
B: Constable, Steven, Parfitt, Kolo
E: Rohan, Menegola, Toohey

No Selwood in the wing thanks. I thought we learnt that already??

 

[Chinacats]

I believe Henry needs to play CHB in the vfl until he forces Harry out of the team

Go with Henry first, give youth a go!

 

[Chinacats]

B: O'Connor - Blicavs - Kolo
HB: Stewart - Taylor - Henry
C: Duncan - Selwood - Clark
HF: Miers - Steven - Dahlhaus
F: Jenkins - Hawkins - Rohan
R: Ratugolea - Dangerfield - Narkle

I: (From) Guthrie - Tuohy - Parfitt - Fogarty - Ablett - Cockatoo - Stanley

Left out, Menegola, Atkins, constable, Bews

Would consider dropping Taylor and pushing Clark or Cockatoo back.

Yes do what you consider. More speed and ball carry down back. Good thoughts.

 

[Chinacats]

Who makes way for Jenkins and Steven?

Rohan & Kelly

 

[Chinacats]

B: Jed Bews - Harry taylor - Henderson
HB: Mark blicavs - Jake Kolodjashnij - Tom Stewart
C: Jordan Clark - Brandon Parfitt - Mitch Duncan
HF: Gary Ablett - Esava Ratagoulea - Josh jenkins
F: Luke Dahlhaus - Tom Hawkins - Gryan Miers
R: Rhys Stanley - Patrick Dangerfield - Joel Selwood
I: Jack steven - Quinton Narkle - Cam guthrie - Sam Menegola

A bit top heavy down back. One more speed player in back half would be good. Get narkle, cockatoo, Danger & Steven on the ball.

 

[MotlopMagic]

FB: O’Connor ~ Blicavs ~ Henry
HB: Stewart ~ Kolodjashnij ~ Tuohy
C: Duncan ~ Parfitt ~ Clark
HF: Steven ~ Ratugolea ~ Miers
FF: Ablett ~ Hawkins ~ Dahlhaus
R: Stanley ~ Dangerfield ~ Selwood

INT: Guthrie ~ Menegola ~ Jenkins ~ Cockatoo

E: Taylor ~ Narkle ~ Rohan ~ Atkins

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Warhorse]

A bit top heavy down back. One more speed player in back half would be good. Get narkle, cockatoo, Danger & Steven on the ball.

Just going with what I think Scott will pick

 

[Chinacats]

Just going with what I think Scott will pick

True he has his favourites

 

[strauchnyy]

Fb. Bews. Blicavs. Stewart
Hb. Clark. Kolo. Henry
C. Duncan. Danger. Parfitt
Hf. Miers. Esava. Dahlhaus
Ff. Steven. Hawkins. Rohan
Foll. Stanley. Selwood. Guthrie
Int. Jenkins. Narkle. Constable. O’Connor

Emg. Taylor. Atkins. Fogarty

 

[Vdubs]

Who makes way for Jenkins and Steven?

Kelly and Smith.

 

[Shadow89]

Now that all is said and done, reckon we have a really good squad to pick from (some of the draftees could push players out too). I reckon this is our Best 25 right now as it stands:

B: O'Connor, Blics, Henry
HB: Stewart, Kolo, Clark
C: Duncan, Selwood, Parfitt
FO: Ratugolea, Danger, Steven
HF: Ablett, Hawkins, Dahl
F: Miers, Jenkins, Cockatoo
INT: Narkle, Guthrie, Constable, Rohan

EMG: Stanley (I'm tired of him right now, lol), Taylor, Menegola

Kreuger, (reckon he's gonna kill it this year and allow Sav to ruck a lot more) Atkins, Rohan, Fog, Bews, Tuohy, Henderson (if he somehow stays) all pushing for the squad. Pretty handy depth.

 

[Purrfect pussy]

Just going with what I think Scott will pick

Feel like there is a big difference between what we see as best 22/26 and what we think Scott might pick.

If I was choosing what I think Scott will pick I’d be picking at least 9 defenders.

 

[CatRiot]

B: O'Connor, Blicavs, Henry
HB: Stewart, Kolo, Clark
C: Duncan, Selwood, Parfitt
FO: Dahlhaus, Hawkins, Cockatoo
HF: Ablett, Jenkins, Miers
F: Stanley, Dangerfield, Steven
INT: Guthrie, Constable, Narkle, Tuohy

EMG: Rohan, Atkins, Bews, SavRat, Taylor, Menegola, Parsons, Fogarty, Abbott

Forward Depth: Rohan, Atkins, SavRat, Menegola, Kreuger
Midfield Depth: Parsons, Fogarty
Ruck Depth: Abbott, Fort
Defence Depth: Henderson, Bews, Taylor

* I know people are disappointed with my mentioning of SavRat back to VFL, but I think Jenkins is an upgrade in the short term. SavRat will need to push him out, and he probably can.

 

[CatRiot]

B: O'Connor, Blicavs, Henry
HB: Stewart, Kolo, Clark
C: Duncan, Selwood, Parfitt
FO: Dahlhaus, Hawkins, Cockatoo
HF: Ablett, Jenkins, Miers
F: Stanley, Dangerfield, Steven
INT: Guthrie, Constable, Narkle, Tuohy

EMG: Rohan, Atkins, Bews, SavRat, Taylor, Menegola, Parsons, Fogarty, Abbott

Forward Depth: Rohan, Atkins, SavRat, Menegola, Kreuger
Midfield Depth: Parsons, Fogarty
Ruck Depth: Abbott, Fort
Defence Depth: Henderson, Bews, Taylor

* I know people are disappointed with my mentioning of SavRat back to VFL, but I think Jenkins is an upgrade in the short term. SavRat will need to push him out, and he probably can.

Assuming we manage and the form of Ablett, Taylor, Selwood, Hawkins doesn't fall off a cliff this season - then this may be the best depth we've had in a while.

 

[DanA]

I could see the following happen from the Prelim Final:

• Harry loses his place to Blicavs
• Bews loses his place to Clarke
• Blicavs spot on the wing is taken by Steven
• Kelly's spot is taken by Constable
• Guthrie's tagging role is taken by Fogarty
• Henderson loses his spot to Hawkins
• Parfitt loses his spot to Cockatoo

 

[Larry Donohue]

FB: O’Connor ~ Blicavs ~ Henry
HB: Stewart ~ Kolodjashnij ~ Clark
C: Duncan ~ Constable ~ Cockatoo
HF: Dahlhaus ~ Hawkins ~ Rohan
FF: Ablett ~ Ratagolea ~ Miers
R: Stanley ~ Dangerfield ~ Steven

INT: Selwood ~ Parfitt~ Jenkins ~ Narkle

E: Taylor ~ Tuohy ~ 3 draftees ~ Atkins Menegola Guthrie Fogarty Kreuger Bews Fort Tarca Parsons Simpson Abbott +delisted free agent Bennell

Selwood to play his more familiar midfield role but less time on the field
Cockatoo to take on the tagging role, so if he plays on the best mid, he smashes him and feeds off him

 

[BIGANT]

If Blicavs doesn't start at FB next year then Chris Scott might as well hand in his resignation early.

A query for another thread, but in the fallout of the PF loss...What was the reasoning of playing Blicavs on the wing ? What was the mis match the MC were trying to create !? Apart from Scott digging in at his presser but as per norm didn't give anything away.

 

[BIGANT]

From the Prelim:

In: Hawkins, Steven
Out: Henderson, Kelly

is the easy bit.

Then it’s harder to see where Rohan, Clark, Jenkins and Constable fit.

I can see the argument of JJ in the *outer group right now. I see him as the foil for TH but not sure what they're going to do with Sav ?! leave him at chf whole and souly then going to fit in GA'J, Dahl, TA, GM, BP QN. And Steven if he's fwd first over onball.

 

[year of the cat]

I could see the following happen from the Prelim Final:

• Harry loses his place to Blicavs
• Bews loses his place to Clarke
• Blicavs spot on the wing is taken by Steven
• Kelly's spot is taken by Constable
• Guthrie's tagging role is taken by Fogarty
• Henderson loses his spot to Hawkins
• Parfitt loses his spot to Cockatoo

And Duncan comes in for Menegola